- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Early theories: the nebular hypothesis and its revision
Describe the nebular hypothesis of Kant and Laplace, its 1950 revision by Otto Schmidt and Carl Weizsacker, and the idea of accretion, and explain why scientists later turned to the origin of the universe.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State who proposed and who revised the nebular hypothesis, with dates.
- Explain how planets form by accretion in the revised hypothesis.
- Explain why later scientists moved from the origin of the earth to the origin of the universe.
People have wondered about the stars for as long as they have looked at the night sky: how many there are, how they came to be, and whether the sky has an end. This chapter tells the scientific story of how stars, planets and finally our own earth formed, and how the earth changed from a hot, barren rock into a planet with air, water and life. We begin with the earliest scientific ideas about the origin of the earth.
Many hypotheses
Philosophers and scientists have proposed a large number of hypotheses about the origin of the earth. A hypothesis is a proposed explanation that is tested against evidence; it may be accepted, revised or rejected as evidence grows. The story of these ideas shows how science improves its explanations step by step.
The nebular hypothesis
One of the earlier and popular arguments came from the German philosopher Immanuel Kant. The mathematician Laplace revised it in 1796. It is known as the Nebular Hypothesis. It held that the planets were formed out of a cloud of material associated with a youthful sun, which was slowly rotating. In simple terms, a young sun was surrounded by a slowly turning cloud of matter, and the planets took shape from that cloud.
Nebular hypothesis (Kant, revised by Laplace in 1796): the planets formed from a cloud of material around a young, slowly rotating sun.
The 1950 revision
In 1950, Otto Schmidt in Russia and Carl Weizsacker in Germany revised the nebular hypothesis somewhat, though they differed in details. They considered that the sun was surrounded by a solar nebula containing mostly hydrogen and helium, along with what may be called dust. Friction and collision of particles led to the formation of a disk-shaped cloud, and the planets were formed through the process of accretion, that is, small particles sticking together and gradually building larger bodies.
Planet formation in the revised nebular hypothesis
- Solar nebula The sun is surrounded by a nebula of mostly hydrogen and helium plus dust.
- Friction and collision Particles rub and collide with one another.
- Disk-shaped cloud The material settles into a flattened disk around the sun.
- Accretion Particles stick together and build up into planets.
| Feature | Nebular hypothesis (Kant, Laplace) | Revised hypothesis (Schmidt, Weizsacker) |
|---|---|---|
| Date | Laplace's revision 1796 | 1950 |
| Starting material | Cloud of material around a youthful, slowly rotating sun | Solar nebula of mostly hydrogen and helium with dust |
| Key process | Planets form from the cloud | Friction and collision make a disk; planets form by accretion |
| Main question | Origin of the planets and the earth | Origin of the planets and the earth |
From the earth to the universe
Both versions tried to explain how the earth and the planets formed. Scientists in a later period took up a bigger problem: the origin of the universe itself, rather than just that of the earth or the planets. Once one understands how the universe, galaxies and stars formed, the formation of the planets fits into a larger sequence. The modern theories in the next lessons follow that sequence: universe, then stars, then planets, then the earth's own evolution.
The modern sequence followed in this chapter
- Origin of the universe Big Bang theory
- Formation of galaxies and stars From nebulae of hydrogen gas
- Formation of planets From planetesimals
- Evolution of the earth Lithosphere, atmosphere, hydrosphere, life
Worked example 1: who said what, and when?
Arrange these in time order and name the idea each is linked with: Schmidt and Weizsacker; Kant; Laplace. Reasoning: Kant gave the original argument; Laplace revised it in 1796; Schmidt and Weizsacker revised it again in 1950. Answer: Kant (nebular hypothesis), then Laplace (revision, 1796), then Schmidt and Weizsacker (solar nebula and accretion, 1950). The time gap between the two revisions is 1950 − 1796 = 154 years.
Worked example 2: explaining accretion with a model
Imagine (a made-up classroom model) a tray of fine flour that you shake gently. Tiny lumps form, the lumps bump into one another and stick, and after a while a few larger lumps remain where there were thousands of specks. Mapping the model: specks are dust particles of the solar nebula; bumping is collision; sticking together is accretion; the few large lumps are planets. The model is only partly accurate, because in space gravity, not shaking, draws the material together, but it shows why accretion turns many small particles into a few large bodies.
Key takeaways: many hypotheses tried to explain the origin of the earth. The Nebular Hypothesis of Kant, revised by Laplace in 1796, said planets formed from a cloud around a young, slowly rotating sun. In 1950 Otto Schmidt and Carl Weizsacker described a solar nebula of hydrogen, helium and dust that formed a disk through friction and collision, with planets built by accretion. Later scientists turned to the larger question of the origin of the universe.
Check your understanding
-
1. The nebular hypothesis was revised by the mathematician Laplace in:
- 1950
- 1920
- 1796
- 1859
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter states that Kant's argument was revised by Laplace in 1796; the later revision by Schmidt and Weizsacker was in 1950.
-
2. According to Otto Schmidt and Carl Weizsacker, the solar nebula contained mostly:
- hydrogen and helium with dust
- oxygen and nitrogen
- iron and nickel
- water vapour and carbon dioxide
Show answer
Answer: A. They considered the sun to be surrounded by a solar nebula of mostly hydrogen and helium along with dust.
-
3. In the revised nebular hypothesis, the process by which planets were built from particles is called:
- degassing
- differentiation
- photosynthesis
- accretion
Show answer
Answer: D. Friction and collision formed a disk-shaped cloud, and planets formed through accretion, the gradual sticking together of particles.
-
4. Why did later scientists shift their attention from the origin of the earth?
- Because the earth was found to be older than the universe
- Because they took up the larger problem of the origin of the universe
- Because the nebular hypothesis had no supporters
- Because planets were found to have no origin
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says scientists later took up the problems of the origin of the universe rather than just that of the earth or the planets.
-
5. Assertion (A): In the 1950 revision, the planets formed from a disk-shaped cloud.
Reason (R): Friction and collision of particles in the solar nebula led to a disk-shaped cloud.- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- A is true but R is false.
- A is false but R is true.
- Both A and R are false.
Show answer
Answer: A. The revised hypothesis says friction and collision produced the disk-shaped cloud from which planets formed by accretion, so R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.