- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Social hierarchies and late antiquity
Describe the social groups of the early and late empire, the gold-based late Roman economy and the role of law, and the political, economic and religious changes of late antiquity in East and West.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe Tacitus's social groups and how the hierarchy changed in the late empire.
- Explain the switch to gold coinage, bureaucratic corruption and the role of Roman law.
- Describe the reforms of Diocletian and Constantine, Christianisation, and the different fates of East and West.
The final part of the chapter steps back to look at the structure of Roman society and then at late antiquity, the period in which the empire was transformed and broke up. Its developments led into the medieval world and the rise of Islam.
Social hierarchies
The historian Tacitus described the leading social groups of the early empire as: senators (patres, 'fathers'); the leading equites (knights); the respectable people who were clients of the great houses; the unkempt lower class (plebs sordida), whom he called addicted to circus and theatre; and the slaves. The equites ('knights' or 'horsemen') were traditionally the second most powerful group; like senators most were landowners, but many were also shipowners, traders and bankers. In the early third century the Senate numbered about 1,000, and about half its members still came from Italian families.
By the late empire, which begins with Constantine I in the early fourth century, senators and equites had merged into one expanded aristocracy, at least half of it of African or eastern origin. These aristocrats were immensely rich, yet in many respects the military elites had more power, and those soldiers rarely came from aristocratic families. The 'middle' class was now made up of people in imperial service (bureaucracy and army) and prosperous merchants and farmers, sustained chiefly by government service and the State. Below them were the humiliores ('lower'): estate labourers, workers in industry and mines, migrant harvest and building workers, self-employed artisans, casual labourers in big cities, and many slaves, especially in the west. The historian Olympiodorus reported that aristocrats in Rome drew up to 4,000 lbs of gold a year from their estates.
Roman society: early and late empire
-
Early empire (Tacitus)
- Senators
- Leading equites
- Respectable people attached to great houses
- Plebs sordida
- Slaves
-
Late empire (from Constantine)
- Merged, very wealthy aristocracy, half African or eastern
- Powerful military elites from non-aristocratic backgrounds
- Middle class in state service, merchants, farmers
- Humiliores: labourers, artisans, casual workers, slaves
Gold, bureaucracy and law
For three centuries Roman money had been based on silver. In the late empire this ended: the Spanish silver mines had run out, and the state no longer had enough silver to keep the coinage stable. Constantine founded a new system on gold, and vast amounts circulated. The late Roman bureaucracy was comparatively affluent, drawing salaries in gold and buying land. There was much corruption, especially in the courts and military supplies, and governors' greed was proverbial; we know of it because laws tried to end it and writers denounced it, a remarkable element of criticism in the classical world. The Roman state was authoritarian and met protest with violence, yet by the fourth century a strong tradition of Roman law acted as a brake even on fearsome emperors; this is why powerful bishops such as Ambrose could confront emperors who were excessively harsh.
Late antiquity: reforms and prosperity
Late antiquity: the final period in the evolution and break-up of the Roman Empire, broadly the fourth to seventh centuries.
Diocletian (284-305) cut back an over-extended empire by abandoning territories of little strategic or economic value, strengthened frontier defences, redrew the provinces and split civil administration from military command, giving military commanders (duces) more autonomy. Constantine introduced the solidus, a coin of 4½ g of pure gold minted in millions, which outlasted the empire itself, and created a second capital at Constantinople (modern Istanbul, earlier Byzantium), surrounded on three sides by sea; its new senate expanded the governing classes. Monetary stability and a growing population stimulated growth: investment in oil presses, glass factories, screw presses, multiple water-mills, and revived long-distance trade with the East. In Egypt, papyri show a money-using society with large gold incomes; Egypt paid over 2½ million solidi (roughly 35,000 lbs of gold) a year in taxes under Justinian in the sixth century.
Religion: a gradual Christianisation
The traditional religion of the Greek and Roman world was polytheist: many cults, including Roman gods like Jupiter, Juno, Minerva and Mars and many Greek and eastern deities, in thousands of temples; polytheists had no common name for themselves. Judaism, the other great tradition, was not a monolith either. Christianisation - the spread of Christianity until it became dominant - was therefore gradual and complex, after Constantine made it the official religion. Polytheism did not vanish overnight, especially in the west, and in the fourth century the boundaries between religious communities were more fluid than they later became, when powerful bishops enforced a more rigid set of beliefs.
East and West part ways
Prosperity was marked in the East, where population grew until the sixth century despite the plague of the 540s. In the West, Germanic groups (Goths, Vandals, Lombards and others) took the major provinces and set up 'post-Roman' kingdoms: the Visigoths in Spain (overthrown by Arab armies in 711-720), the Franks in Gaul (c. 511-687) and the Lombards in Italy (568-774), foreshadowing the 'medieval' world. In the East, Justinian's reign was the high-water mark: he won back Africa from the Vandals (533), but his long war to regain Italy from the Ostrogoths left the country ruined and let the Lombards in. In the early seventh century the Sasanians invaded the eastern provinces, including Egypt; Byzantium, as the empire was increasingly called, recovered them in the 620s, only to face the expansion of Islam. By 642, barely ten years after the Prophet Muhammad's death, large parts of the eastern Roman and Sasanian empires had fallen to the Arabs - a process that began with the unification of the Arab tribes.
Late antiquity in the East: key steps (dates from the chapter)
- Diocletian (284-305) Cuts back territory, separates civil and military functions.
- Constantine (312-37) Gold solidus; Constantinople founded; Christianity made official.
- Justinian (527-65) Recaptures Africa (533); high-water mark of the East.
- Sasanian invasion and recovery Eastern provinces occupied, then recovered in the 620s.
- Arab conquests (633-42) Syria, Palestine, Egypt, Iraq and parts of Iran taken.
Worked example 1: the solidus and Egypt's taxes
Question: a solidus contained 4½ g of pure gold. Egypt paid about 2½ million solidi a year under Justinian. How much gold is that in kilograms? Working: 2,500,000 × 4.5 g = 11,250,000 g = 11,250 kg. Answer: about 11,250 kg of gold a year. The book gives the same sum as roughly 35,000 lbs of gold. Either way, it shows how rich Egypt remained in late antiquity.
Worked example 2: explaining a change in coinage
Question: why did the late Roman government stop coining in silver, and what replaced it? Working: (1) cause - the Spanish silver mines were exhausted and the government lacked enough silver for a stable coinage; (2) response - Constantine founded a new system on gold; (3) result - the solidus, minted on a very large scale, circulated in millions and outlasted the empire. Answer: silver ran short, so gold replaced it, and the gold solidus gave monetary stability that helped economic growth in the fourth century.
Key takeaways: Tacitus's five groups (senators, equites, respectable people, plebs sordida, slaves) gave way in the late empire to a merged, wealthy aristocracy, powerful military elites, a middle class in state service, and the humiliores. Silver gave way to Constantine's gold solidus. Bureaucracy was corrupt, but laws, critics and Roman law checked power. Diocletian and Constantine reorganised the empire; Christianisation was gradual. The West broke into post-Roman kingdoms, while the East prospered under Justinian until Sasanian wars and the Arab conquests by 642.
Check your understanding
-
1. The 'humiliores' of the late Roman Empire were:
- the senatorial aristocracy
- the mass of the lower classes
- military commanders
- bishops of the Church
Show answer
Answer: B. Humiliores (literally 'lower') was the collective name for the lower classes: rural labourers, industrial and mine workers, migrant workers, artisans, casual labourers and slaves.
-
2. Why did the late Roman government move from silver to gold coinage?
- Gold was cheaper than silver
- The Senate banned silver
- The Spanish silver mines were exhausted and silver stocks were insufficient
- Iran demanded payment in gold
Show answer
Answer: C. The silver-based currency broke down because the Spanish silver mines were exhausted; Constantine founded the new monetary system on gold, the solidus.
-
3. Which emperor separated civilian from military functions and abandoned territories of little strategic or economic value?
- Diocletian
- Augustus
- Justinian
- Trajan
Show answer
Answer: A. Diocletian (284-305) cut back the over-extended empire, fortified frontiers, reorganised provinces and separated civilian from military functions, giving the duces more autonomy.
-
4. Read this source, written for this lesson: 'The bishop stood at the church door and told the emperor he could not enter until he had repented for the cruel punishment of the city's people.' Which feature of the late Roman world does such a scene reflect, according to the book?
- Emperors faced no limits at all
- Bishops had no influence
- Christianity had not yet reached the empire
- A strong tradition of law and criticism allowed powerful bishops to confront harsh emperors
Show answer
Answer: D. The book says that by the fourth century Roman law acted as a brake even on fearsome emperors, which is why powerful bishops like Ambrose could confront emperors who were excessively harsh or repressive.
-
5. Assertion (A): Christianisation of the Roman Empire was a gradual and complex process. Reason (R): Polytheism did not disappear overnight, and the boundaries between religious communities were fluid in the fourth century.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. The survival of polytheism, especially in the west, and the fluid boundaries between communities are exactly why the book calls Christianisation gradual and complex. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.