Why 'nomadic empire' seems contradictory
-
Nomads (usual image)
- Wanderers organised in family assemblies
- Relatively undifferentiated economic life
- Rudimentary political organisation
-
Empire (usual image)
- A fixed material location
- Complex social and economic structures
- Large territory ruled through an elaborate administration
Phases of Russian and Soviet research on the Mongols
-
Tsarist period (18th-19th centuries)
- Colonial setting
- Survey notes by travellers, soldiers, merchants, antiquarians
-
Soviet Marxist historiography (20th century)
- Mode of production shapes society
- Genghis Khan placed in a move from tribal to feudal
- Vladimirtsov's research on language and society
-
Dissent and censorship
- Bartold's sympathetic view troubles Stalinist censors
- His work published in nine volumes in the 1960s
Most of what we know about the Mongols was written by outsiders - city-based chroniclers, travellers and officials - in many languages. Historians must check for bias and study the original words, acting as philologists.
Key takeaways: the contrast between 'nomad' and 'empire' breaks down in the Mongol case. The Mongols wrote little, so we depend on outsiders, many hostile but some sympathetic. Russian research began in a colonial setting; Soviet Marxists saw a tribal-to-feudal transition; Vladimirtsov studied language and society; Bartold's sympathetic work was censored until the 1960s. Sources in Chinese, Mongolian, Persian, Arabic and European languages often differ, so historians must work as philologists.