• Foundation
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

Treatment of goodwill on retirement or death

Credit the outgoing partner with his share of goodwill through the gaining partners, handle a continuing partner who also sacrifices, write off goodwill already in the books, and find hidden goodwill.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Pass the entry for the outgoing partner's share of goodwill when no goodwill appears in the books.
  • Adjust goodwill when the new ratio makes a continuing partner sacrifice too, and when goodwill already appears in the books.
  • Work out hidden goodwill from a lump-sum settlement.

The firm's goodwill was earned through the efforts of all the partners, including the one leaving. After he leaves, the continuing partners will enjoy his share of the future super profits, so they must pay him for it. The basic rule is simple: gaining partners compensate sacrificing partners to the extent of their gain.

When goodwill does not appear in the books

Goodwill is valued as agreed, and the outgoing partner's share of it is credited to his capital account by debiting the gaining partners' capital accounts in their gaining ratio: Gaining Partners' Capital A/cs Dr., To Retiring (or Deceased) Partner's Capital A/c. No Goodwill Account is opened, which agrees with AS 26's position that self-generated goodwill is not recorded.

Worked example 1: the basic entry

Illustrative. Deepak, Esha and Farhan share 3:2:1. Esha retires; goodwill is valued at ₹1,20,000; Deepak and Farhan continue in their old ratio 3:1, so the gaining ratio is 3:1. Esha's share = 2/6 × ₹1,20,000 = ₹40,000, borne ₹30,000 by Deepak and ₹10,000 by Farhan.

Goodwill on retirement, no goodwill in the books (illustrative)
ParticularsL.F.Dr (₹)Cr (₹)
Deepak's Capital A/c ... Dr.30,000
Farhan's Capital A/c ... Dr.10,000
To Esha's Capital A/c40,000
(Esha's share of goodwill adjusted to gaining partners in gaining ratio 3:1)

When a continuing partner also sacrifices

If the new ratio agreed by the continuing partners reduces one of their own shares, that partner is a sacrificing partner too. The gaining partner then compensates both the outgoing partner and the continuing partner who sacrificed, each to the extent of his sacrifice. Always compute new share minus old share for every continuing partner.

Worked example 2: the gainer pays two partners

Illustrative. Jai, Kabir and Leena share 4:3:3. Kabir retires, and Jai and Leena agree to share 1:2. Goodwill is ₹90,000. In thirtieths: Jai old 12/30, new 10/30, so he sacrifices 2/30; Leena old 9/30, new 20/30, so she gains 11/30; Kabir's share is 9/30. Leena pays 11/30 × ₹90,000 = ₹33,000: ₹27,000 (9/30) to Kabir and ₹6,000 (2/30) to Jai.

Goodwill when a continuing partner also sacrifices (illustrative)
ParticularsL.F.Dr (₹)Cr (₹)
Leena's Capital A/c ... Dr.33,000
To Kabir's Capital A/c27,000
To Jai's Capital A/c6,000
(Leena, the only gaining partner, compensates the retiring partner Kabir and the sacrificing partner Jai)

When goodwill already appears in the books

Goodwill already in the balance sheet is first written off by debiting all partners' capital accounts, including the outgoing partner's, in the old ratio: All Partners' Capital A/cs Dr., To Goodwill A/c. Then the current value of goodwill is adjusted through the gaining partners as above.

Worked example 3: writing off and adjusting

Illustrative. Meena, Neel and Om share 2:2:1. Goodwill appears in the books at ₹25,000. Neel retires; goodwill is now valued at ₹1,00,000, and Meena and Om will share equally. Gains: Meena 1/2 − 2/5 = 1/10, Om 1/2 − 1/5 = 3/10, total 4/10 = Neel's share. Neel's share of goodwill = 2/5 × ₹1,00,000 = ₹40,000, paid ₹10,000 by Meena and ₹30,000 by Om.

Goodwill already in the books (illustrative)
ParticularsL.F.Dr (₹)Cr (₹)
Meena's Capital A/c ... Dr.10,000
Neel's Capital A/c ... Dr.10,000
Om's Capital A/c ... Dr.5,000
To Goodwill A/c25,000
(Existing goodwill written off in old ratio 2:2:1)
Meena's Capital A/c ... Dr.10,000
Om's Capital A/c ... Dr.30,000
To Neel's Capital A/c40,000
(Neel's share of goodwill (2/5 of ₹1,00,000) adjusted in gaining ratio 1:3)

Hidden goodwill

If the firm agrees to pay the outgoing partner a lump sum that is more than the balance in his capital account after all other adjustments (reserves, revaluation and so on), the excess is his share of goodwill, called hidden goodwill. It is debited to the gaining partners in their gaining ratio and credited to the outgoing partner.

Worked example 4: lump-sum settlement

Illustrative. Tara retires from the firm of Tara, Uma and Vir. After all adjustments her capital is ₹1,10,000, but Uma and Vir agree to pay her ₹1,30,000 in full settlement. The excess ₹20,000 is her share of goodwill. Uma and Vir gain in the ratio 3:2, so they bear ₹12,000 and ₹8,000.

Hidden goodwill on retirement (illustrative)
ParticularsL.F.Dr (₹)Cr (₹)
Uma's Capital A/c ... Dr.12,000
Vir's Capital A/c ... Dr.8,000
To Tara's Capital A/c20,000
(Hidden goodwill: amount paid in excess of Tara's adjusted capital, borne in gaining ratio 3:2)

Goodwill on retirement or death

  1. Write off any goodwill in the books All partners, old ratio.
  2. Value goodwill as agreed
  3. Find each continuing partner's new share minus old share Gain or sacrifice.
  4. Gaining partners' capital accounts debited Gain × goodwill.
  5. Outgoing and any sacrificing continuing partners credited Sacrifice × goodwill.

Gaining partners compensate sacrificing partners (the outgoing partner, and any continuing partner whose share falls) to the extent of their gain. Goodwill already in the books is written off to ALL partners in the OLD ratio.

Key takeaways: the outgoing partner's share of goodwill is credited to him and debited to the gaining partners in the gaining ratio, without opening a Goodwill Account. A continuing partner whose share falls is also compensated. Old goodwill is written off to all partners in the old ratio. A lump sum above the adjusted capital is hidden goodwill.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A, B and C share 2:2:1. B retires; goodwill is ₹75,000; A and C continue in their old ratio. A's capital account is debited with:

    1. ₹30,000
    2. ₹15,000
    3. ₹20,000
    4. ₹10,000
    Show answer

    Answer: C. B's share = 2/5 × ₹75,000 = ₹30,000. A and C gain in their old ratio 2:1, so A bears 2/3 × ₹30,000 = ₹20,000 and C ₹10,000.

  2. 2. Goodwill appears in the books at ₹30,000 when one of three equal partners retires. The entry to write it off is:

    1. All three partners' Capital A/cs Dr. ₹10,000 each, To Goodwill A/c ₹30,000
    2. Continuing partners' Capital A/cs Dr. ₹15,000 each, To Goodwill A/c
    3. Retiring partner's Capital A/c Dr. ₹30,000, To Goodwill A/c
    4. Goodwill A/c Dr. ₹30,000, To all partners' Capital A/cs
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Existing goodwill is written off to all partners, including the retiring one, in their old ratio. Equal partners each bear ₹10,000.

  3. 3. X, Y and Z share 5:3:2. Y retires; X and Z will share 1:1. Goodwill is ₹1,00,000. The entry for goodwill is:

    1. X Dr. ₹15,000 and Z Dr. ₹15,000, To Y ₹30,000
    2. Z's Capital Dr. ₹30,000, To Y's Capital ₹30,000
    3. X's Capital Dr. ₹30,000, To Y's Capital ₹30,000
    4. Z's Capital Dr. ₹30,000, To X ₹15,000 and Y ₹15,000
    Show answer

    Answer: B. X: old 5/10, new 5/10, no change. Z: old 2/10, new 5/10, gains 3/10 = Y's share. So Z alone pays Y 3/10 × ₹1,00,000 = ₹30,000.

  4. 4. Case: After all adjustments, a retiring partner's capital is ₹85,000. The continuing partners pay him ₹1,00,000 in full settlement and share future profits 2:1. How much goodwill does the first continuing partner bear?

    1. ₹15,000
    2. ₹7,500
    3. ₹5,000
    4. ₹10,000
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Hidden goodwill share = ₹1,00,000 − ₹85,000 = ₹15,000. Assuming they gain in their ratio 2:1, the first bears 2/3 × ₹15,000 = ₹10,000.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): On retirement, a continuing partner can be credited with a share of goodwill. Reason (R): If the new ratio reduces a continuing partner's share, he sacrifices and is compensated by the gaining partner.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: when the agreed new ratio lowers a continuing partner's share, he becomes a sacrificing partner and is credited with goodwill for his sacrifice.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery