• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Uses, importance and limitations of financial statements

Explain how different users rely on company financial statements and the limitations the textbook identifies, and judge what the statements can and cannot tell a user.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Name the users of financial statements and explain the seven uses listed in the textbook.
  • Explain the seven limitations of financial statements.
  • Judge, for a given decision, what the statements can and cannot tell.

Financial statements are part of a company's annual report, along with the directors' report, the auditors' report and the corporate governance report. Many groups read them, each with its own question in mind. Knowing their uses, and their limits, is the starting point for the analysis in the next two chapters.

Uses and importance

Uses of financial statements (as listed in the textbook)

  • Stewardship report
    • Shows management's performance to shareholders
  • Basis for fiscal policies
    • Input for taxation and economic policies
  • Basis for credit
    • Banks and institutions judge loan proposals
  • Prospective investors
    • Judge solvency and profitability
  • Existing shareholders
    • Judge safety and return of their investment
  • Trade associations
    • Develop standard ratios and uniform accounts
  • Stock exchanges
    • Check transparency; protect investors

The users include management, investors, shareholders, creditors, government, bankers, employees and the public. Each uses the statements to take economic decisions: a shareholder to decide whether to stay invested, a banker whether to lend, the government to frame tax policy, a stockbroker to judge different companies.

Limitations

  • Do not reflect the current situation: they are based on historical cost while the purchasing power of money changes.
  • Assets may not realise: assets show unexpired cost; in a forced sale they may fetch less than stated.
  • Bias: results depend on concepts, conventions and the accountant's judgements.
  • Aggregate information: they give totals, not the detail a user may need.
  • Vital information missing: for example, loss of markets or cessation of agreements is not disclosed in the balance sheet.
  • No qualitative information: industrial relations, quality of work and employee satisfaction are not shown.
  • Only interim reports: profit is for a period and position is at a point of time; they do not show earning capacity over time or likely future changes.

Different users read the same statements with different questions. Short-term lenders and suppliers look mainly at current assets and current liabilities, to judge whether the company can pay soon. Long-term lenders and debentureholders look at borrowings, interest and profits, to judge whether interest and principal are safe. Shareholders and prospective investors look at profit, earnings per share and reserves, to judge return and growth. Management uses the same figures to plan and control. Because one set of statements must serve all of them, the information is general-purpose, and each user has to pick out and analyse the part that answers his or her question, which is the subject of the next chapter.

What the statements tell and what they do not

  • They tell
    • Profit or loss for the period
    • Assets and liabilities at historical cost
    • Sources of funds: owners and borrowings
    • Accounting policies followed
  • They do not tell
    • Current market value of assets
    • Quality of management or labour relations
    • Loss of a major customer after year end
    • Earning capacity over many years

Worked example 1: match the user to the use

User (made-up)Question askedUse served
Sahyadri Bank, considering a loan to Lalit Steels LtdCan it repay with interest?Basis for granting credit
Meera, who holds Lalit Steels sharesIs my investment safe and earning a return?Guide to the value of investment already made
A trade association of steel makersWhat is a typical ratio for our industry?Aids trade associations
A stock exchangeIs the company reporting transparently?Helps stock exchanges
Shareholders at the AGMHow well did management use our money?Report on stewardship

Worked example 2: a limitation in action

Illustrative. Lalit Steels Ltd's balance sheet shows a factory building at ₹2,00,00,000 (cost less depreciation), bought fifteen years ago. A buyer interested in the company finds the building's present market value is far higher, and also learns that the company's largest customer stopped buying from it soon after the year end. Neither fact appears in the statements: the first because they are based on historical cost, the second because vital information of this kind is not disclosed in the balance sheet. The buyer must look beyond the statements.

Financial statements are useful for decisions but are historical, aggregate, monetary and partly judgemental; they need analysis, and sometimes other information, before they are used.

Key takeaways: financial statements serve stewardship, fiscal policy, credit, investors, existing shareholders, trade associations and stock exchanges. Their limitations are historical cost, assets that may not realise, bias, aggregation, missing vital information, no qualitative information and their interim nature; so they must be analysed before use.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A bank studies a company's statements before sanctioning a loan. This use is:

    1. Report on stewardship function
    2. Basis for fiscal policies
    3. Basis for granting of credit
    4. Aids trade associations
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Credit-granting institutions decide on loans using the financial performance shown in the statements, which the textbook calls the basis for granting credit.

  2. 2. Which is a limitation of financial statements?

    1. They are prepared at historical cost and do not reflect current values
    2. They disclose accounting policies
    3. They are prepared in a prescribed format
    4. They are audited
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Being based on historical cost, they do not reflect the current situation when the purchasing power of money changes.

  3. 3. Financial statements do not show the quality of labour relations. This limitation is:

    1. Bias
    2. Aggregate information
    3. Assets may not realise
    4. No qualitative information
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Financial statements contain only monetary information, not qualitative matters such as industrial relations or quality of work.

  4. 4. Case: Investors find a company's balance sheet says nothing about the cancellation, after the year end, of its main supply contract. The textbook's limitation that fits best is:

    1. They are only interim reports
    2. Vital information missing
    3. Bias
    4. Assets may not realise
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook notes that the balance sheet does not disclose information such as loss of markets or cessation of agreements, which is vital to users.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Financial statements provide a report on the stewardship of management. Reason (R): Financial statements are prepared only for the use of the government.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A is true: they report management's performance to shareholders. R is false: they serve many users, including shareholders, investors, creditors, bankers, employees and the government.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery