- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Limitations of financial analysis and drawing sound conclusions
Explain the limitations of financial statement analysis listed in the textbook, including price level changes and window dressing, and combine comparative, common size and trend figures to reach careful conclusions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the limitations of financial analysis listed in the textbook.
- Explain how price level changes, window dressing and changes in accounting policy can mislead an analyst.
- Combine the results of different tools to reach a balanced conclusion.
Financial analysis is only as good as the statements it starts from. Since it uses the same figures, it carries all their limitations, and some of its own. A careful analyst knows these limits and checks conclusions against them.
Limitations of financial analysis
The textbook says the analyst must be conscious of the impact of price level changes, window dressing of financial statements, changes in accounting policies, accounting concepts and conventions, and personal judgement. It lists these further limitations:
- Financial analysis does not consider price level changes.
- It may be misleading without knowledge of changes in the accounting procedures followed by the firm.
- It is just a study of the reports of the company.
- Only monetary information is considered; non-monetary aspects are ignored.
- The statements are prepared on the basis of accounting concepts, so they do not reflect the current position.
Why an analysis can mislead
-
Inherited from the statements
- Historical cost
- Concepts, conventions and judgements
- Only monetary information
-
Changes over time
- Price level changes
- Changes in accounting policy
-
Presentation
- Window dressing to look better on the balance sheet date
Price level changes and policy changes, illustrated
Worked example 1: growth that is partly price rise
Illustrative. Rani Fabrics Ltd's sales rose from ₹50,00,000 to ₹55,00,000, a comparative increase of 10 per cent. Its records show it sold 10,000 units at ₹500 in Year 1 and 10,000 units at ₹550 in Year 2. So the entire 10 per cent increase came from a higher price; the quantity sold did not grow at all. Because financial analysis does not adjust for price changes, the comparative figure alone overstates real growth.
Worked example 2: a change in method
Illustrative. In Year 2, Rani Fabrics Ltd changed its depreciation method, which reduced the year's depreciation by ₹2,00,000. Its profit before tax rose from ₹6,00,000 to ₹8,00,000. Without knowledge of the change, an analyst would credit the entire ₹2,00,000 rise to better operations; in fact all of it came from the change in accounting method. This is why the textbook insists that changes in accounting principles be footnoted in comparative statements.
Window dressing
Window dressing means presenting the statements so that the position looks better than it really is on the balance sheet date, for example by delaying payments or rushing collections just before the year end so the cash balance looks strong. Figures for a single date can therefore mislead; trends over several years and supporting information help.
Combining the tools
| Tool's finding (Rani Fabrics Ltd, made-up) | What it suggests | What to check next |
|---|---|---|
| Comparative: sales +10%, profit +33% | Strong improvement | Was there a price rise or a policy change? |
| Common size: materials up from 48% to 52% of sales | Cost pressure | Purchase prices and wastage |
| Trend: sales index 100, 104, 108, 110 over four years | Slowing growth | Market share and competitors |
Remember also where the figures come from. The textbook notes that a company's annual report contains the basic financial statements (balance sheet, statement of profit and loss and cash flow statement) together with management's discussion of performance for the year and of future prospects. Reading this discussion, the notes and the auditor's report alongside the numbers helps an analyst understand changes that the statements alone cannot explain, such as a new product line, the loss of a market or a change in accounting policy.
Before trusting a conclusion, ask: Is the change real or only a price change? Did an accounting policy change? Could the year-end figures be window dressed? What non-monetary factors are missing?
Key takeaways: financial analysis ignores price level changes and non-monetary factors, can be misled by policy changes and window dressing, and inherits the historical, conventional nature of the statements. Using several tools together and checking for these factors leads to sounder conclusions.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which is a limitation of financial analysis listed in the textbook?
- It ignores price level changes
- It uses comparative statements
- It considers only non-monetary factors
- It always uses current market values
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook lists that financial analysis does not consider price level changes; it considers only monetary information and is based on historical figures.
-
2. Sales rose 12 per cent, but the selling price per unit also rose 12 per cent. The real growth in quantity sold is:
- 12 per cent
- 24 per cent
- Nil
- 6 per cent
Show answer
Answer: C. If price rose by the same 12 per cent as sales value, the quantity sold did not change. The rise in rupee sales is due entirely to price.
-
3. Making the balance sheet look better on the balance sheet date than it really is, is called:
- Horizontal analysis
- Window dressing
- Trend analysis
- Common sizing
Show answer
Answer: B. Window dressing is presenting the statements so that the position looks better than it really is, which the textbook warns analysts to keep in mind.
-
4. Case: A company's profit rose sharply in a year when it changed its inventory valuation method, and the comparative statement has no footnote about it. The analyst's best response is:
- Credit the rise entirely to better management
- Ignore the statements altogether
- Use only the common size statement
- Find out the effect of the change in method before concluding
Show answer
Answer: D. Analysis may mislead without knowledge of changes in accounting procedures; the effect of the change must be found and separated before judging performance.
-
5. Assertion (A): Financial analysis gives a complete picture of a firm's performance. Reason (R): Financial analysis considers only monetary information and ignores non-monetary aspects.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: D. A is false: analysis is limited, among other things because it ignores non-monetary aspects such as labour relations and quality of management. R is true and is one reason A is false.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.