• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Ethical issues: GEAC, patents and biopiracy

Explain why genetic modification needs regulation, the role of GEAC, the Basmati patent case and the meaning of biopiracy, and why countries rich in biodiversity protect traditional knowledge.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why manipulation of living organisms needs ethical standards and regulation.
  • State the role of GEAC in India.
  • Describe the Basmati patent case and other attempts to patent Indian bio-resources.
  • Define biopiracy and explain the imbalance between industrialised and developing countries.

Biotechnology can change living things in ways that nature never would. That power brings questions: is it safe to release a GM organism? Who owns a gene, a seed or a traditional remedy? These questions are part of the chapter because science does not happen apart from society.

Why regulation is needed

The manipulation of living organisms cannot continue without regulation. Ethical standards are needed to judge the morality of activities that might help or harm living organisms. There is also a biological concern: a genetically modified organism released into an ecosystem can have unpredictable results. For this reason the Indian Government set up organisations such as the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC), which decides on the validity of GM research and the safety of introducing GM organisms for public services.

Patents on biological resources

A patent is a legal right granted to an inventor that stops others from making or selling the invention without permission. Using living organisms for food and medicine has raised problems with patents. There is public anger that some companies have been granted patents on products and technologies built on genetic material, plants and other bio-resources that farmers and indigenous people of a region have long identified, developed and used.

The Basmati case

Rice has been grown in Asia for thousands of years, and India has one of the richest diversities of rice in the world. Basmati is distinct for its aroma and flavour, has many documented varieties in India and appears in ancient texts, folklore and poetry. In 1997 an American company obtained patent rights on Basmati rice through the US Patent and Trademark Office. This let it sell a 'new' variety of Basmati in the US and abroad. In fact the 'new' variety was derived from Indian farmers' varieties: Indian Basmati had been crossed with semi-dwarf varieties and claimed as an invention. The patent also extended to functional equivalents, which could restrict others selling Basmati. Attempts have also been made to patent uses, products and processes based on Indian traditional herbal medicines such as turmeric and neem.

How the Basmati patent arose

  1. Farmers' varieties Basmati developed and grown in India for centuries.
  2. Crossing Indian Basmati crossed with semi-dwarf varieties.
  3. Claimed as novel The result presented as an invention.
  4. Patent granted (1997) US patent, extending to functional equivalents.

Biopiracy

Biopiracy is the use of bio-resources by multinational companies and other organisations without proper authorisation from the countries and people concerned and without compensatory payment. Most industrialised nations are rich financially but poor in biodiversity and traditional knowledge, while developing and under-developed countries are rich in biodiversity and traditional knowledge about bio-resources. That knowledge can be used to develop modern applications and saves time, effort and money during commercialisation.

The imbalance behind biopiracy

  • Industrialised nations
    • Financially rich
    • Poor in biodiversity
    • Poor in traditional knowledge of bio-resources
  • Developing and under-developed nations
    • Financially poorer
    • Rich in biodiversity
    • Rich in traditional knowledge of bio-resources

There is a growing awareness of the injustice, inadequate compensation and lack of benefit sharing between developed and developing countries. Some nations are therefore making laws to prevent unauthorised exploitation of their bio-resources and traditional knowledge. The Indian Parliament cleared the second amendment of the Indian Patents Bill, which takes such issues into account, including patent terms, emergency provisions and research and development initiatives.

Biopiracy = using a country's bio-resources or traditional knowledge without authorisation and without compensatory payment. GEAC judges the validity of GM research and the safety of releasing GM organisms in India.

Worked example 1: is it biopiracy?

Imagine (a made-up case) a foreign firm learns from a forest community that a leaf paste heals wounds, isolates the active compound, patents it and sells an ointment, paying the community nothing and without permission from the country. Check against the definition: (1) a bio-resource and traditional knowledge were used; (2) there was no authorisation from the country or people; (3) there was no compensatory payment. Conclusion: all three conditions are met, so this is biopiracy. If the firm had obtained permission and agreed to share benefits, it would not be.

Worked example 2: which body decides?

A research institute in India has developed a GM mustard and wants to grow it in open fields. Reasoning: (1) releasing a GM organism into the environment may have unpredictable ecological effects; (2) in India, GEAC decides on the validity of GM research and the safety of introducing GM organisms for public use. Conclusion: the institute must seek GEAC's approval before any field release.

Key takeaways: manipulating organisms needs ethical standards and regulation because GM organisms may have unpredictable effects in ecosystems; in India GEAC decides on GM research and release. Patents on bio-resources long used by farmers and indigenous people cause concern, as in the 1997 US Basmati patent (derived from Indian varieties crossed with semi-dwarf rice) and attempts on turmeric and neem. Biopiracy is unauthorised, uncompensated use of bio-resources; nations rich in biodiversity are making laws, and India amended its Patents Bill.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which organisation in India decides on the validity of GM research and the safety of introducing GM organisms for public services?

    1. GEAC
    2. KVIC
    3. IARI
    4. US Patent and Trademark Office
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC) was set up by the Indian Government to take these decisions. KVIC and IARI are linked with biogas technology, and the US office granted the Basmati patent.

  2. 2. The 'new' Basmati variety patented in 1997 was actually

    1. a completely new species made in a laboratory
    2. a GM rice with a Bt gene
    3. derived from Indian farmers' varieties crossed with semi-dwarf varieties
    4. a variety of wheat
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Indian Basmati was crossed with semi-dwarf varieties and the result was claimed as an invention, although it was derived from varieties developed by Indian farmers.

  3. 3. Biopiracy is best defined as

    1. growing GM crops without a licence
    2. copying a scientific paper
    3. stealing seeds from a farm
    4. using bio-resources without proper authorisation from the countries and people concerned and without compensatory payment
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Biopiracy is the use of bio-resources, often with traditional knowledge, by companies or organisations without authorisation from the countries and people concerned and without compensating them.

  4. 4. Which statement correctly describes the imbalance behind biopiracy?

    1. Developing nations are poor in biodiversity
    2. Industrialised nations are financially rich but poor in biodiversity and traditional knowledge
    3. Industrialised nations are rich in traditional knowledge
    4. All nations have equal biodiversity
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Most industrialised nations are rich financially but poor in biodiversity and traditional knowledge, while developing and under-developed nations are rich in both biodiversity and traditional knowledge.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): GM organisms need regulation before being released into the environment. Reason (R): Genetic modification of organisms can have unpredictable results when they are introduced into the ecosystem.

    1. A is true but R is false
    2. A is false but R is true
    3. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    4. Both A and R are false
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Because the effects of releasing a GM organism into an ecosystem cannot be fully predicted, bodies such as GEAC must assess safety first. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery