- Foundation
- About 22 min
- 5 practice questions
Population interactions: predation and competition
Classify interspecific interactions with +, − and 0 signs, explain the roles of predators and the defences of prey and plants, and explain competition, competitive exclusion and resource partitioning.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Classify the six kinds of interspecific interaction by their effect on each species.
- Explain the ecological roles of predators, with examples.
- Describe defences of prey animals and of plants against herbivores.
- Define competition, state Gause's principle and explain competitive release and resource partitioning.
No natural habitat holds just one species. Even a plant, which makes its own food, needs soil microbes to recycle nutrients and often an animal to pollinate it. Populations of different species interact constantly, and these interactions shape the whole biological community.
Kinds of interspecific interaction
| Species A | Species B | Interaction |
|---|---|---|
| + | + | Mutualism |
| − | − | Competition |
| + | − | Predation |
| + | − | Parasitism |
| + | 0 | Commensalism |
| − | 0 | Amensalism |
In predation and parasitism only one species benefits (predator, parasite) while the other (prey, host) is harmed. Predation, parasitism and commensalism share one feature: the interacting species live closely together.
Predation
Predation is nature's way of transferring the energy fixed by plants to higher trophic levels. A tiger eating a deer is predation, but so is a sparrow eating a seed; herbivores are not very different from predators in a broad ecological sense. Predators have other important roles:
- They keep prey populations under control. Without predators, prey could reach very high densities and destabilise the ecosystem. Exotic species often become invasive because the new land lacks their natural predators: the prickly pear cactus introduced into Australia in the early 1920s spread over millions of hectares of rangeland until a cactus-feeding moth from its native habitat was introduced. Biological pest control is based on this regulating ability.
- They maintain species diversity by reducing competition among prey species. When the predatory starfish Pisaster was removed from an enclosed area of the rocky intertidal zone on the American Pacific coast, more than 10 invertebrate species became extinct within a year because of interspecific competition.
- They are 'prudent'. A predator that over-exploits its prey could drive it extinct and then die out itself for lack of food.
Defences against predators and herbivores
-
Prey animals
- Camouflage (cryptic colouring) in some insects and frogs
- Being poisonous or distasteful: the Monarch butterfly carries a chemical obtained by its caterpillar from a poisonous weed
-
Plants: morphological
- Thorns, as in *Acacia* and cactus
-
Plants: chemical
- *Calotropis* makes poisonous cardiac glycosides, so cattle and goats avoid it
- Nicotine, caffeine, quinine, strychnine and opium are made as defences against grazers and browsers
Plants are especially vulnerable because they cannot run away; nearly 25 per cent of all insects are phytophagous, feeding on plant sap and other parts. This explains the astonishing range of plant defences, chemicals that make the herbivore sick, stop it feeding or digesting, disrupt its reproduction or kill it.
Competition
Competition is best defined as a process in which the fitness of one species (measured by its r) is significantly lower in the presence of another species. It is often assumed to occur only between closely related species competing for a limiting resource, but neither condition is necessary. Unrelated species compete too: in some shallow South American lakes, visiting flamingoes and resident fishes compete for zooplankton. And in interference competition, one species reduces the feeding efficiency of another by its inhibitory presence even when food and space are plentiful.
Gause's Competitive Exclusion Principle states that two closely related species competing for the same resources cannot coexist indefinitely; the competitively inferior one is eventually eliminated. This holds when resources are limiting, and it is easy to show in laboratory experiments, but evidence from nature is not always conclusive. Circumstantial evidence exists: the Abingdon tortoise on the Galapagos Islands became extinct within a decade after goats were introduced, apparently because the goats browsed more efficiently. Competitive release is further evidence: a species confined to a small area by a superior competitor expands its range dramatically when the competitor is removed. Connell showed on the rocky coasts of Scotland that the larger barnacle Balanus dominates the intertidal zone and excludes the smaller Chthamalus. In general, herbivores and plants seem more affected by competition than carnivores.
Species facing competition may instead evolve ways to coexist. One such mechanism is resource partitioning: using the same resource at different times or in different ways. MacArthur showed that five closely related species of warblers living on the same tree avoided competition through differences in their foraging behaviour.
Competition lowers r of one species in the presence of another. Gause: exclusion when resources are limiting. Resource partitioning (MacArthur's warblers) allows coexistence.
Worked example 1: predicting the effect of removing a predator
On a rocky shore a starfish eats mussels, barnacles and snails. Reasoning: (1) the mussel is the strongest competitor for space on the rocks; (2) the starfish keeps the mussel population low, leaving room for other species; (3) if the starfish is removed, mussels spread and crowd out the rest. Conclusion: species diversity falls, as happened when Pisaster was removed. The predator was maintaining diversity by reducing competition among its prey.
Worked example 2: is it competition?
Made-up data: alone, beetle species X has r = 0.12 per week; grown with species Y in the same container with plenty of food, its r falls to 0.05. Reasoning: (1) competition means the fitness (r) of one species is significantly lower in the presence of another; (2) X's r fell from 0.12 to 0.05, a fall of (0.12 − 0.05) ÷ 0.12 × 100 ≈ 58%; (3) food was not limiting, so Y's presence must be interfering with X. Conclusion: this is interference competition.
Key takeaways: interactions are mutualism (+ +), competition (− −), predation and parasitism (+ −), commensalism (+ 0) and amensalism (− 0). Predators pass energy up trophic levels, control prey (prickly pear and moth), maintain diversity (Pisaster) and are prudent. Prey use camouflage and poisons; plants use thorns and chemicals such as cardiac glycosides. Competition lowers r of a species in another's presence, even between unrelated species or with abundant food. Gause's principle applies when resources are limiting; competitive release and resource partitioning are key ideas.
Check your understanding
-
1. An interaction in which one species is harmed and the other is unaffected is called
- commensalism
- amensalism
- competition
- mutualism
Show answer
Answer: B. Amensalism is (− 0): one species is harmed while the other is unaffected. Commensalism is (+ 0), competition is (− −) and mutualism is (+ +).
-
2. The prickly pear cactus in Australia was brought under control by
- spraying weedicides
- introducing goats
- introducing a cactus-feeding moth from its natural habitat
- burning the rangeland
Show answer
Answer: C. The invasive cactus spread because Australia lacked its natural predators. Introducing a cactus-feeding moth from its native habitat finally controlled it, an example of predators regulating prey.
-
3. Cattle and goats do not browse on Calotropis because it
- has thorns
- produces highly poisonous cardiac glycosides
- grows only in water
- is camouflaged
Show answer
Answer: B. Calotropis produces cardiac glycosides, poisonous chemicals that protect it from grazing animals. This is a chemical, not a morphological, defence.
-
4. Five closely related warbler species coexisting on the same tree by differing in foraging behaviour illustrates
- competitive exclusion
- brood parasitism
- competitive release
- resource partitioning
Show answer
Answer: D. MacArthur showed that the warblers avoided competition through behavioural differences in foraging, which is resource partitioning, a mechanism that promotes coexistence.
-
5. Assertion (A): Removal of the starfish Pisaster from an intertidal area led to the extinction of more than 10 invertebrate species. Reason (R): Predators maintain species diversity by reducing the intensity of competition among prey species.
- A is false but R is true
- A is true but R is false
- Both A and R are false
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. Without the predator, the strongest competitors among the prey took over and eliminated others through interspecific competition. This shows that the predator had been maintaining diversity, so R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.