- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Why species diversity matters and the loss of biodiversity
Explain community stability, Tilman's experiments and Ehrlich's rivet popper hypothesis, compare the present 'sixth extinction' with past mass extinctions, and list the effects of biodiversity loss.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe what makes a biological community stable.
- Summarise Tilman's findings on diversity, stability and productivity.
- Explain the rivet popper hypothesis.
- Compare the present extinctions with past mass extinctions and list the effects of losing biodiversity.
Does it matter if a few species disappear? Would a forest work any worse with one tree frog fewer, or the world with fewer kinds of ants? Ecologists cannot give a full answer yet, but experiments and a memorable analogy show why the loss of species should worry us.
Diversity and stability
For decades ecologists believed that communities with more species tend to be more stable. A stable community should not vary too much in productivity from year to year; it should be resistant or resilient to occasional natural or man-made disturbances; and it should be resistant to invasion by alien species. David Tilman's long-term experiments on outdoor plots gave some tentative answers: plots with more species showed less year-to-year variation in total biomass, and increased diversity contributed to higher productivity.
The rivet popper hypothesis
Stanford ecologist Paul Ehrlich offered an analogy. An aeroplane (the ecosystem) is held together by thousands of rivets (species). If each passenger pops out a rivet to take home (a species goes extinct), flight safety (ecosystem function) may not suffer at first, but as more and more rivets go, the plane becomes dangerously weak. And which rivet is lost matters: losing rivets from the wings (key species that drive major ecosystem functions) is far more serious than losing a few from the seats or windows.
The rivet popper analogy
-
In the aeroplane
- The aeroplane
- Rivets
- Passengers popping rivets
- Rivets on the wings
- Flight safety
-
In nature
- The ecosystem
- Species
- Species going extinct
- Key species driving major functions
- Proper functioning of the ecosystem
The loss of biodiversity
It is doubtful whether new species are being added by speciation at any meaningful rate, but there is no doubt that species are being lost, and human activities are clearly responsible. Human colonisation of tropical Pacific islands is said to have led to the extinction of more than 2000 species of native birds. Recent extinctions include the dodo (Mauritius), quagga (Africa), thylacine (Australia), Steller's sea cow (Russia) and three subspecies of tiger (Bali, Javan and Caspian). Extinctions are not random across groups: some, such as amphibians, appear more vulnerable.
Fossil records show that in the more than 3 billion years since life began to diversify there have been five mass extinctions, before humans existed. The present loss is called the 'Sixth Extinction'. What makes it different is its rate: current extinction rates are estimated to be 100 to 1000 times faster than in pre-human times, and human activities are responsible. Ecologists warn that if present trends continue, nearly half of all species might be wiped out within the next 100 years.
Sixth Extinction: present extinction rates are about 100-1000 times pre-human rates, driven by human activities.
Effects of losing biodiversity in a region
- A decline in plant production.
- Lowered resistance to environmental perturbations such as drought.
- Increased variability in certain ecosystem processes such as plant productivity, water use, and pest and disease cycles.
Worked example 1: comparing extinction rates
Made-up data for illustration: suppose a group of 10,000 species lost 1 species per 1000 years before humans. If the present rate is 100 to 1000 times faster, then the group now loses between 100 × 1 = 100 and 1000 × 1 = 1000 species per 1000 years, i.e. 0.1 to 1 species every year. Over one human lifetime of about 70 years, that is 7 to 70 species lost, compared with almost none at the background rate. This shows why the rate, not the fact of extinction, is what makes the Sixth Extinction alarming.
Worked example 2: reading Tilman-style data
Made-up data: over five years, the total biomass of a 2-species plot was 300, 520, 260, 480 and 340 g m⁻² (range 520 − 260 = 260); a 16-species plot gave 610, 650, 600, 640 and 630 g m⁻² (range 650 − 600 = 50). Mean biomass: 2-species plot = 1900 ÷ 5 = 380; 16-species plot = 3130 ÷ 5 = 626. Conclusion: the more diverse plot varied much less from year to year (range 50 against 260) and was more productive (mean 626 against 380), matching Tilman's findings.
Key takeaways: a stable community varies little in productivity, resists or recovers from disturbance and resists invasion. Tilman found that more species meant less year-to-year variation in biomass and higher productivity. Ehrlich's rivet popper hypothesis compares species to an aeroplane's rivets: losses add up, and key species matter most. Five mass extinctions occurred before humans; the present Sixth Extinction is 100-1000 times faster and human-driven. Losing biodiversity lowers plant production, reduces resistance to drought and makes ecosystem processes more variable.
Check your understanding
-
1. Tilman's long-term experiments showed that plots with more species
- had greater year-to-year variation in biomass
- were always invaded by alien species
- showed less year-to-year variation in total biomass and higher productivity
- produced less biomass
Show answer
Answer: C. Tilman found that more diverse plots varied less in total biomass from year to year, and that increased diversity contributed to higher productivity.
-
2. In Ehrlich's rivet popper hypothesis, the rivets on the wings of the aeroplane represent
- key species that drive major ecosystem functions
- alien species
- humans
- extinct species
Show answer
Answer: A. The aeroplane is the ecosystem and the rivets are species. Rivets on the wings stand for key species; losing them threatens ecosystem function far more than losing others.
-
3. How does the present 'Sixth Extinction' differ from the earlier mass extinctions?
- Only plants are going extinct now
- Extinction rates now are about 100-1000 times faster, and humans are responsible
- There were no earlier mass extinctions
- Species are being added faster than they are lost
Show answer
Answer: B. Five mass extinctions occurred before humans. The present one differs in its rate, estimated at 100 to 1000 times pre-human rates, and in being caused by human activities.
-
4. Which of the following is a recent extinction of a tiger subspecies?
- Bengal tiger
- Siberian tiger
- Sumatran tiger
- Javan tiger
Show answer
Answer: D. The Bali, Javan and Caspian subspecies of tiger are among recent extinctions. The others named still survive.
-
5. Assertion (A): Loss of biodiversity in a region may lower its resistance to drought. Reason (R): Communities with high diversity tend to be more resistant or resilient to environmental perturbations.
- A is false but R is true
- A is true but R is false
- Both A and R are false
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. Diverse communities are generally better at resisting or recovering from disturbances such as drought, so losing diversity lowers that resistance. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.