- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Incomplete dominance, co-dominance, multiple alleles and the nature of dominance
Explain cases where Mendel's simple dominance does not hold - incomplete dominance in snapdragon, co-dominance and multiple alleles in ABO blood groups - and what makes an allele dominant.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain incomplete dominance with the snapdragon example and its 1 : 2 : 1 F2 ratio.
- Explain dominance in terms of what an allele's product does.
- Explain co-dominance and multiple alleles using the human ABO blood groups.
- Work out possible blood groups of children from the parents' genotypes.
- Explain why dominance depends on which phenotype we examine.
When Mendel's experiments were repeated with other traits and other plants, some results did not fit the neat pattern of one dominant and one recessive allele. These exceptions do not overturn Mendel's laws - alleles still segregate - but they show that the relationship between two alleles can take several forms.
Incomplete dominance
In the **dog flower (snapdragon, Antirrhinum sp.), a cross between true-breeding red-flowered (RR) and true-breeding white-flowered (rr) plants gives F1 (Rr) plants with pink flowers - a phenotype in between the parents. Selfing the F1 gives F2 in the ratio 1 red (RR) : 2 pink (Rr) : 1 white (rr)**. The genotypic ratio is exactly the Mendelian 1 : 2 : 1, but the phenotypic ratio has changed from 3 : 1 to 1 : 2 : 1, because R is not completely dominant over r and the heterozygote can be told apart.
What makes an allele dominant?
A gene carries the information to express a trait, and a diploid organism has two copies (alleles). Suppose the normal allele makes an enzyme that transforms a substrate S. A modified allele could produce (i) a normal or less efficient enzyme, (ii) a non-functional enzyme, or (iii) no enzyme at all. In case (i) the two alleles are equivalent and give the same phenotype. In cases (ii) and (iii), the phenotype depends only on the working, unmodified allele. The unmodified, functioning allele is usually the dominant one, and the modified allele is generally recessive: the recessive trait is seen only when no working enzyme is made.
Co-dominance and multiple alleles: ABO blood groups
In co-dominance, the F1 resembles both parents. The ABO blood groups of humans are controlled by the gene I, which decides the kind of sugar polymer protruding from the red blood cell membrane. The gene has three alleles: Iᴬ, Iᴮ and i. Iᴬ and Iᴮ produce slightly different sugars; i produces none. Iᴬ and Iᴮ are each completely dominant over i, but when Iᴬ and Iᴮ are together both are expressed - the cells carry both A and B sugars. That is co-dominance.
| Genotype | Sugars on RBC | Blood group |
|---|---|---|
| Iᴬ Iᴬ | A | A |
| Iᴬ i | A | A |
| Iᴮ Iᴮ | B | B |
| Iᴮ i | B | B |
| Iᴬ Iᴮ | A and B | AB |
| i i | None | O |
ABO also illustrates multiple alleles: more than two alleles (here three) govern the same character. Because an individual carries only two alleles, multiple alleles can be found only when populations are studied. With three alleles, the number of genotypes is 3 homozygous + 3 heterozygous = 6, giving 4 phenotypes.
Three relationships between two alleles
-
Complete dominance
- Heterozygote looks like the dominant parent
- Example: Tt pea is tall
- F2 phenotypes 3 : 1
-
Incomplete dominance
- Heterozygote is intermediate
- Example: Rr snapdragon is pink
- F2 phenotypes 1 : 2 : 1
-
Co-dominance
- Heterozygote shows both parental traits fully
- Example: Iᴬ Iᴮ is blood group AB
- F2 phenotypes 1 : 2 : 1
Dominance depends on the phenotype you look at
Starch synthesis in pea seeds is controlled by one gene with alleles B and b. BB plants make starch efficiently and produce large starch grains; bb plants are less efficient and make smaller grains. Mature BB seeds are round, bb seeds are wrinkled, and Bb seeds are round - so for seed shape, B looks dominant. But Bb seeds have starch grains of intermediate size, so for grain size the alleles show incomplete dominance. Dominance is therefore not a fixed property of a gene; it depends on the gene product and on the particular phenotype we choose to examine. This is also an example of one gene affecting more than one phenotype.
Worked example 1: a blood group puzzle
Question: A child has blood group O. The father is group A and the mother is group B. Find the parents' genotypes and the possible blood groups of their other children. Working: (1) Group O means the child is ii, so the child received i from each parent. (2) The father is group A and carries i, so he is Iᴬ i. The mother is group B and carries i, so she is Iᴮ i. (3) Gametes: father Iᴬ or i; mother Iᴮ or i, each ½. (4) Combinations: Iᴬ Iᴮ (AB), Iᴬ i (A), Iᴮ i (B), ii (O), each with probability ¼. Answer: other children may be A, B, AB or O, each with a chance of 1 in 4.
Worked example 2: snapdragon numbers
Question: A pink snapdragon is crossed with a white one. What fraction of offspring will be pink? Working: Pink is Rr and white is rr. Rr gives R and r (½ each); rr gives only r. Offspring: ½ Rr (pink) and ½ rr (white). Answer: ½ of the offspring are pink. Notice that in incomplete dominance every genotype has its own phenotype, so phenotypic and genotypic ratios are the same.
Incomplete dominance: heterozygote in between (pink). Co-dominance: heterozygote shows both (AB). Multiple alleles: more than two alleles for one gene in a population (Iᴬ, Iᴮ, i).
Key takeaways
- Incomplete dominance: F1 is intermediate; F2 phenotypes 1 : 2 : 1, same as genotypes.
- A working allele is usually dominant; a modified allele that makes a non-functional or no product is usually recessive.
- ABO blood groups: Iᴬ and Iᴮ are co-dominant, both dominant over i; 6 genotypes, 4 blood groups.
- Multiple alleles can be detected only by studying a population.
- Whether an allele is dominant can depend on which phenotype (seed shape or starch grain size) is examined.
Check your understanding
-
1. In snapdragon, the F2 of a cross between red (RR) and white (rr) flowered plants shows the phenotypic ratio:
- 3 red : 1 white
- 1 red : 1 white
- 1 red : 2 pink : 1 white
- 9 red : 7 white
Show answer
Answer: C. R is incompletely dominant, so Rr is pink. Selfing Rr gives 1 RR (red) : 2 Rr (pink) : 1 rr (white).
-
2. How many genotypes and how many phenotypes are possible for the human ABO blood group system?
- 4 genotypes, 6 phenotypes
- 6 genotypes, 4 phenotypes
- 3 genotypes, 3 phenotypes
- 6 genotypes, 6 phenotypes
Show answer
Answer: B. With three alleles there are 3 homozygous (IᴬIᴬ, IᴮIᴮ, ii) and 3 heterozygous (Iᴬi, Iᴮi, IᴬIᴮ) genotypes = 6. They give 4 phenotypes: A, B, AB and O.
-
3. A man of blood group AB marries a woman of blood group O. Which blood groups are possible in their children?
- AB and O only
- A, B and AB
- A, B, AB and O
- A and B only
Show answer
Answer: D. The father (IᴬIᴮ) passes Iᴬ or Iᴮ; the mother (ii) passes i. Children are Iᴬi (group A) or Iᴮi (group B), each with probability ½. No child can get both Iᴬ and Iᴮ (so not AB), and every child gets Iᴬ or Iᴮ from the father (so not O).
-
4. In pea, Bb seeds are round like BB seeds but have starch grains of intermediate size. This shows that:
- Dominance depends on the phenotype being examined
- B and b blend permanently
- The gene for starch synthesis has three alleles
- Bb plants are true-breeding
Show answer
Answer: A. For seed shape, B appears dominant; for starch grain size, the alleles show incomplete dominance. So dominance is not fixed - it depends on the phenotype we choose to examine.
-
5. Assertion (A): In a heterozygote, an allele that produces a non-functional enzyme usually behaves as recessive. Reason (R): The phenotype is then decided by the functioning allele, which produces the normal enzyme.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A. If one allele makes a working enzyme, the substrate is still transformed and the normal phenotype appears; the modified allele's effect shows only when no working allele is present.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.