- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
The search for the genetic material, and DNA versus RNA
Follow the experiments of Griffith, Avery-MacLeod-McCarty and Hershey-Chase that proved DNA is the genetic material, list the criteria for a genetic material, and explain why DNA stores and RNA transmits information.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe Griffith's transformation experiment and its conclusion.
- Explain how Avery, MacLeod and McCarty identified the transforming principle as DNA.
- Explain how Hershey and Chase used radioactive phosphorus and sulfur to prove DNA is the genetic material.
- List the four criteria a genetic material must meet.
- Explain why DNA is the better store of information and why RNA is thought to be the first genetic material.
By 1926 the work of Mendel, Sutton, Morgan and others had narrowed the search for the genetic material to the chromosomes. But chromosomes contain both proteins and DNA, and many scientists thought protein, with its 20 amino acids, was the likelier carrier of information. A chain of clever experiments settled the question.
Griffith's transforming principle (1928)
Frederick Griffith worked with Streptococcus pneumoniae. The S strain forms smooth, shiny colonies because it has a mucous (polysaccharide) coat, and it is virulent: mice infected with it die of pneumonia. The R strain forms rough colonies, has no coat and does not cause pneumonia.
| Injected into mice | Result |
|---|---|
| Live S strain | Mice die |
| Live R strain | Mice live |
| Heat-killed S strain | Mice live |
| Heat-killed S + live R | Mice die; live S bacteria recovered from them |
Griffith concluded that the R strain had been transformed by some 'transforming principle' from the heat-killed S strain, which let it make a polysaccharide coat and become virulent. This had to be a transfer of genetic material, but the experiment did not reveal its chemical nature.
Avery, MacLeod and McCarty (1933-44)
These workers purified proteins, DNA, RNA and other biochemicals from heat-killed S cells and tested which could transform live R cells. DNA alone caused transformation. Proteases (protein-digesting enzymes) and RNases (RNA-digesting enzymes) did not stop transformation, but DNase did. They concluded that DNA is the hereditary material, though not all biologists were convinced.
Hershey and Chase (1952): the unequivocal proof
Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase worked with bacteriophages, viruses that infect bacteria and inject their genetic material into them. They grew some phages in a medium with radioactive phosphorus and others with radioactive sulfur. DNA contains phosphorus but no sulfur; protein contains sulfur but no phosphorus. So the first batch had radioactive DNA and the second radioactive protein.
The Hershey-Chase experiment
- Label phages One batch with radioactive P (labels DNA), one with radioactive S (labels protein).
- Infect E. coli Phages attach and inject their genetic material.
- Blend Agitation in a blender removes the viral coats from the bacteria.
- Centrifuge Heavier bacteria settle; lighter virus particles stay in the supernatant.
- Result Radioactive P is found in the bacteria; radioactive S is not. DNA, not protein, entered the bacteria.
Worked example 1: predicting a result
Question: Suppose, contrary to fact, protein were the genetic material of the phage. What would Hershey and Chase have observed? Reasoning: (1) The genetic material is what enters the bacterium. (2) If it were protein, the sulfur label would enter the bacteria. (3) After blending and centrifuging, the bacterial pellet would be radioactive in the sulfur-labelled batch, and the phosphorus label would stay with the coats. Answer: the opposite of what was seen. The actual result - phosphorus inside, sulfur outside - showed that DNA is the genetic material.
What makes a good genetic material?
- It should be able to make its own copy (replication).
- It should be chemically and structurally stable.
- It should allow slow changes (mutation), needed for evolution.
- It should be able to express itself as 'Mendelian characters'.
Proteins fail the first test: they cannot direct their own copying. DNA and RNA both can, thanks to base pairing. In some viruses, such as tobacco mosaic virus and Qβ bacteriophage, RNA is the genetic material. So why is DNA preferred?
DNA and RNA as genetic material
-
DNA
- No 2'-OH: chemically less reactive
- Double-stranded; separated strands re-join (stability seen even after heating in Griffith's work)
- Thymine instead of uracil adds stability
- Mutates slowly
- Needs RNA to make proteins
- Better for storing information
-
RNA
- 2'-OH makes it reactive, labile and easily degraded
- Also catalytic, hence reactive
- Mutates faster (RNA viruses evolve fast)
- Can directly code for protein synthesis
- Better for transmitting information
The RNA world
There is now enough evidence that RNA was the first genetic material. Essential life processes such as metabolism, translation and splicing evolved around RNA, and some important reactions are still catalysed by RNA catalysts rather than protein enzymes. But a reactive catalyst is unstable, so DNA evolved from RNA with chemical changes that make it more stable; being double-stranded with a complementary strand, DNA also evolved a process of repair.
Worked example 2: why heat did not destroy the transforming principle
Question: Heat killed the S bacteria, yet their transforming principle still worked. How does DNA structure explain this? Reasoning: (1) Heating separates the two strands of DNA by breaking H-bonds, but the sequence of bases on each strand (held by covalent bonds) is not destroyed. (2) The strands are complementary, so on cooling under suitable conditions they come together again. (3) The genetic information therefore survives heating. Answer: DNA's stability and complementarity allowed the information to survive, which is one reason DNA is a good genetic material.
Griffith: transformation happens. Avery-MacLeod-McCarty: the transforming principle is DNA. Hershey-Chase: DNA, not protein, enters the cell - DNA is the genetic material.
Key takeaways
- Griffith showed that heat-killed S bacteria could transform live R bacteria into virulent S bacteria.
- Avery, MacLeod and McCarty showed only DNase stopped transformation, so the transforming principle is DNA.
- Hershey and Chase used radioactive P (DNA) and S (protein) labels to prove DNA enters the host and is the genetic material.
- A genetic material must replicate, be stable, allow slow mutation, and express itself.
- DNA is better for storage; RNA is better for transmission and is thought to be the first genetic material.
Check your understanding
-
1. In Griffith's experiment, mice died when injected with:
- Live R strain bacteria
- A mixture of heat-killed S strain and live R strain bacteria
- Heat-killed S strain bacteria
- Heat-killed R strain bacteria
Show answer
Answer: B. The heat-killed S strain transformed the live R strain into virulent S bacteria, which killed the mice. Live R alone and heat-killed S alone were harmless.
-
2. Which enzyme treatment stopped transformation in the experiments of Avery, MacLeod and McCarty?
- Protease
- RNase
- Lipase
- DNase
Show answer
Answer: D. Only DNase, which digests DNA, inhibited transformation. Proteases and RNases did not, showing the transforming substance was neither protein nor RNA.
-
3. Hershey and Chase grew phages in radioactive sulfur to label their:
- Protein coat
- DNA
- RNA
- Bacterial host's DNA
Show answer
Answer: A. Proteins contain sulfur (in some amino acids) but DNA has none, so radioactive sulfur labels only the phage protein. Radioactive phosphorus labels DNA.
-
4. Which property makes RNA less suitable than DNA for long-term storage of genetic information?
- RNA cannot form base pairs
- RNA cannot code for proteins
- The 2'-OH group in RNA makes it reactive and easily degraded
- RNA cannot mutate
Show answer
Answer: C. The 2'-OH present on every ribose makes RNA labile and reactive. RNA can base pair, code for proteins and mutate - in fact it mutates faster.
-
5. Assertion (A): Viruses with an RNA genome generally mutate and evolve faster. Reason (R): RNA is less stable than DNA.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A. Being unstable, RNA mutates at a faster rate, so RNA viruses, which also have short life spans, mutate and evolve faster.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.