- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Importance and nature of management: art, science and profession
Explain five reasons why management is important, and examine whether management is an art, a science and a profession by testing it against the features of each.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State and explain five points of importance of management.
- Test management against the features of an art and of a science, and explain why it is an inexact science.
- Explain which features of a profession management has and which it lacks.
Management is not only needed; it makes a visible difference. In this lesson we first see why it is so important, and then take up an old question about its nature: is management an art, a science, a profession, or a mixture?
Importance of management
Why management is important
- Achieving group goals Gives a common direction to individual efforts towards the organisation's overall goal.
- Increasing efficiency Reduces costs and raises productivity through better planning, organising, staffing, directing and controlling.
- Creating a dynamic organisation Helps people accept and adapt to change, which they often resist, so the firm keeps its competitive edge.
- Achieving personal objectives Motivation and leadership let members meet their own goals while contributing to group goals.
- Development of society Provides good quality products and services, creates jobs and adopts new technology.
Is management an art?
Art is the skilful and personal application of existing knowledge to achieve desired results; it is learnt by study, observation and experience and calls for creativity. Its features are: (i) existence of theoretical knowledge, (ii) personalised application, which differs from person to person, and (iii) being based on practice and creativity. A classical singer and a film singer both use the same musical notes, yet each performs in an individual way.
Management meets these tests. A large body of literature exists on management areas such as marketing, finance and human resources. Each manager applies this knowledge to a situation in a personal, skilful way, which gives rise to different styles of management. Managers improve with long practice and use creativity, imagination, initiative and innovation. So management is an art.
Is management a science?
Science is a systematised body of knowledge that explains general truths or general laws. Its features are: (i) a systematised body of knowledge based on cause and effect, (ii) principles developed by observation and tested by repeated experiment under controlled conditions, and (iii) universal validity.
Management meets these tests only partly. It has a systematised body of knowledge with its own vocabulary and principles, and it draws on economics, sociology, psychology and mathematics. Its principles have developed through observation and repeated experiment in many organisations, for example the principles of F.W. Taylor and Henri Fayol that you will study in the next chapter. But management deals with human beings, whose behaviour cannot be predicted or reproduced exactly, so results of these experiments are not exact and principles must be adapted to each situation. Management is therefore an inexact science.
Management as art and as science
-
Art
- Theoretical knowledge exists
- Personalised application of knowledge
- Based on practice and creativity
- Management meets all three features
-
Science
- Systematised body of knowledge
- Principles tested by experiment
- Universal validity
- Management meets these only partly: an inexact science
The textbook's conclusion is that management has features of both. The practice of management is an art; the principles on which good practice is based are its science. The two are not mutually exclusive; they complement each other.
Is management a profession?
A profession has five features: (i) a well-defined body of knowledge acquired through instruction, (ii) restricted entry through an examination or a degree, (iii) a professional association that regulates entry, certifies members and enforces a code of conduct, (iv) an ethical code of conduct, and (v) a service motive.
| Feature of a profession | Does management meet it? | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Well-defined body of knowledge | Yes | Systematic knowledge taught in colleges and institutes and found in books and journals |
| Restricted entry | No | Anyone can be appointed a manager; no degree is legally required, though one is preferred |
| Professional association | Partly | Associations of managers exist, such as the All India Management Association, but membership is not compulsory and has no statutory backing |
| Ethical code of conduct | Partly | Associations have laid down codes, but they bind only voluntary members |
| Service motive | Partly | The basic purpose is achieving the organisation's goal; a well-run firm serves society by offering good products at reasonable prices |
So management does not meet all the criteria of a profession, although it has some professional features and, as the textbook puts it, is to a large extent professional in character.
Management is an art (personal, creative application), an inexact science (systematised but not exactly predictable principles), and not a full-fledged profession (entry is not restricted and associations are not compulsory).
Worked example 1: art or science?
Case (made up): two branch managers of a made-up bank, Rohit and Sana, attend the same training programme on handling customer complaints. Rohit handles angry customers with humour; Sana prefers a calm, formal approach; both resolve complaints well. Reasoning: both use the same body of knowledge but apply it in their own way. This illustrates personalised application, a feature of management as an art.
Worked example 2: is the profession test met?
Case (made up): Priyanka has a degree in history and no management qualification, but she is appointed operations manager of a made-up logistics firm because of her experience. Reasoning: a person cannot practise as a chartered accountant or a lawyer without passing the prescribed examination or degree, but there is no such legal requirement for a manager. This shows that the feature of restricted entry is not met.
Worked example 3: naming the point of importance
A made-up company, Swift Couriers, moves to a new tracking system. Many employees fear the change, so managers hold training sessions and explain the benefits, and the change is adopted smoothly. Answer: management creates a dynamic organisation, helping people adapt to change.
Key takeaways: management helps achieve group goals, increases efficiency, creates a dynamic organisation, helps achieve personal objectives and helps develop society. It is an art because its practice is personal and creative; an inexact science because its principles deal with human behaviour; and not a full profession because entry is unrestricted and membership of associations is voluntary.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which feature of a profession is NOT met by management?
- Existence of a body of knowledge
- Restricted entry through an examination or degree
- Knowledge that can be acquired through instruction
- Existence of some management associations
Show answer
Answer: B. Anyone can be appointed a manager whatever his or her qualifications; no degree is legally required. So the feature of restricted entry is not met.
-
2. Management is called an inexact science mainly because:
- it has no body of knowledge
- its principles were never tested
- it deals with human behaviour, which cannot be predicted exactly
- it is not taught in any institution
Show answer
Answer: C. Management principles were developed through observation and experiment, but because they deal with people, outcomes cannot be accurately predicted or replicated. Hence management is an inexact science.
-
3. Two managers trained in the same principles handle the same problem in different ways, both successfully. This shows management as:
- a science
- a profession
- an intangible force
- an art
Show answer
Answer: D. Personalised application of the same theoretical knowledge, with creativity, is the main feature of an art.
-
4. Assertion (A): Management helps in the development of society. Reason (R): Management provides good quality products, creates jobs and adopts new technology.
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: B. Both are true, and R gives the ways in which management develops society: quality goods and services, employment and new technology for the greater good.
-
5. Case: In a made-up firm, managers explain a new computer system to worried employees and train them, so the change is accepted without trouble. Which point of importance of management is shown?
- Management increases efficiency
- Management helps in achieving personal objectives
- Management helps in the development of society
- Management creates a dynamic organisation
Show answer
Answer: D. People often resist change. Management helps them adapt to change so that the organisation keeps its competitive edge; this is creating a dynamic organisation.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.