- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The divisional structure and comparison with the functional structure
Explain the divisional structure with its advantages, disadvantages and suitability, and compare functional and divisional structures on six bases.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the divisional structure and why a division is a profit centre.
- State its advantages, disadvantages and suitability.
- Compare functional and divisional structures and choose the right one in a case.
As firms diversify into several product lines, the simple functional structure becomes hard to manage. Many large organisations have therefore moved to a divisional structure.
Divisional structure
In a divisional structure, the organisation consists of separate business units or divisions, usually formed on the basis of different products. Each division has a divisional manager who has authority over it and is responsible for its performance. Each division is multifunctional: production, marketing, finance and purchase are performed within it, so it is self-contained. In other words, a functional structure is usually adopted inside each division. Each division works as a profit centre: its head is responsible for its profit or loss. A large company might have divisions for cosmetics, clothing and footwear.
Managing Director of a made-up diversified company
- Cosmetics division Its own production, marketing, finance and HR.
- Garments division Its own production, marketing, finance and HR.
- Footwear division Its own production, marketing, finance and HR.
- Skin care division Its own production, marketing, finance and HR.
Advantages
- Product specialisation develops varied skills in divisional heads, because they gain experience of all functions related to a product, which prepares them for higher positions.
- Divisional heads are accountable for profits, since revenues and costs of each division can be identified. This gives a basis for measuring performance and fixing responsibility for poor results.
- Flexibility and initiative: each division is an autonomous unit, so decisions are faster.
- Expansion and growth: a new division can be added for a new product line without disturbing existing operations.
Disadvantages
- Conflict among divisions over allocation of funds; a division may try to maximise its own profit at the cost of others.
- Higher costs from duplication of activities, because each division has its own set of similar functions.
- Excess power: a divisional manager who controls all activities of a division may, over time, ignore organisational interests to assert independence.
Suitability. It suits enterprises making a large variety of products using different productive resources, and firms that are growing and need more employees, departments and levels.
Functional and divisional structures compared
| Basis | Functional structure | Divisional structure |
|---|---|---|
| Formation | Based on functions | Based on product lines, supported by functions |
| Specialisation | Functional specialisation | Product specialisation |
| Responsibility | Difficult to fix on a department | Easy to fix responsibility for performance |
| Managerial development | Difficult; each functional manager reports to top management | Easier; autonomy and multiple functions develop managers |
| Cost | Economical; functions not duplicated | Costly; resources duplicated across divisions |
| Coordination | Difficult for a multi-product company | Easy; all functions of a product are integrated in one division |
The textbook adds that, since business operates in a dynamic environment, the structure should be reviewed periodically and modified when needed.
Divisional structure: separate self-contained divisions by product, each a profit centre with its own functions. Easy to fix responsibility and grow; costly because functions are duplicated.
Worked example 1: choosing a structure
Case (made up): a made-up company, Everbright Ltd, makes only one product, ceiling fans, in large volume. A second made-up company, Rangoli Group, makes paints, tiles and kitchen appliances using quite different machines and selling to different buyers. Reasoning: Everbright needs specialised functions for a single product line, so a functional structure fits it; Rangoli has a large variety of products using different resources, so a divisional structure fits it, each product line being a division and profit centre.
Worked example 2: fixing responsibility (illustrative figures)
Rangoli Group's three divisions report results for a year.
| Division | Revenue (₹ lakh) | Costs (₹ lakh) | Profit or loss (₹ lakh) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paints | 500 | 420 | 80 |
| Tiles | 300 | 330 | −30 |
| Appliances | 400 | 350 | 50 |
Working: paints 500 − 420 = 80; tiles 300 − 330 = −30 (a loss); appliances 400 − 350 = 50. Total profit = 80 − 30 + 50 = ₹100 lakh. Because each division's revenue and cost are separate, the loss can be traced to the tiles division and its head held responsible. This is the advantage of accountability for profits.
Worked example 3: spotting a disadvantage
Case (made up): in Rangoli Group, each division keeps its own accounts team, its own buyers and its own delivery vans. Disadvantage shown: higher cost due to duplication of activities.
Key takeaways: a divisional structure groups activities by product into self-contained, multifunctional divisions, each a profit centre. It develops managers, makes heads accountable, gives flexibility and eases expansion, but can cause inter-divisional conflict, duplication cost and over-powerful divisional heads. Functional structures specialise by function and are economical; divisional structures specialise by product and make responsibility easy to fix.
Check your understanding
-
1. In a divisional structure, each division is generally formed on the basis of:
- functions such as finance and marketing
- different products
- personal friendships
- levels of management
Show answer
Answer: B. In a divisional structure, manpower is generally grouped on the basis of different products, and each division performs all functions for its product.
-
2. Why is it easy to fix responsibility in a divisional structure?
- Because there is no divisional head
- Because all decisions are taken by the managing director
- Because each division's revenues and costs can be identified, making it a profit centre
- Because functions are not duplicated
Show answer
Answer: C. Revenues and costs of each division are separately identifiable, so the divisional head is accountable for its profit or loss.
-
3. A made-up company's divisions earn: A ₹60 lakh profit, B ₹15 lakh loss, C ₹35 lakh profit. What is the company's total profit?
- ₹110 lakh
- ₹80 lakh
- ₹95 lakh
- ₹50 lakh
Show answer
Answer: B. Total = 60 − 15 + 35 = ₹80 lakh. Divisional accounts also show that division B is responsible for the loss.
-
4. Which is a disadvantage of the divisional structure?
- Duplication of activities across products increases costs
- Difficulty in fixing responsibility
- Little scope for managerial development
- Coordination is very difficult for a multi-product company
Show answer
Answer: A. Each division has its own set of similar functions, which duplicates activities and raises cost. The other options are disadvantages of the functional structure.
-
5. Assertion (A): A divisional structure facilitates expansion. Reason (R): A new division can be added for a new product line without interrupting existing operations.
- A is true, but R is false
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
Show answer
Answer: D. Both are true and R explains A: adding a new division with its own head and staff does not disturb existing divisions, so growth is easy.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.