- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Recruitment: internal and external sources
Define recruitment, explain internal sources (transfers and promotions) and ten external sources, and compare the merits and limitations of internal and external recruitment.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define recruitment and list the activities it involves.
- Explain transfers and promotions and the merits and limitations of internal sources.
- Explain the main external sources and their merits and limitations.
Staffing has three main aspects: recruitment (identifying and attracting applicants), selection (assessing them and making the final match) and training (acquainting them and developing skills).
Meaning of recruitment
Recruitment is the process of searching for prospective employees and stimulating them to apply for jobs in the organisation. It precedes selection. It involves (a) identifying sources of labour supply, (b) assessing their validity, (c) choosing the most suitable sources and (d) inviting applications. Positions can be filled from within (internal sources) or from outside (external sources).
Internal sources
Transfer means shifting an employee from one job, department or shift to another without a substantive change in responsibilities and status. It is a horizontal movement. It fills vacancies from over-staffed departments, avoids terminations, removes individual problems and can train employees in different jobs. The person transferred must be capable of the new job.
Promotion means shifting an employee to a higher position with greater responsibility, facilities, status and pay. It is a vertical movement. It raises motivation, loyalty and satisfaction, and one promotion at a high level may lead to a chain of promotions below.
Internal recruitment: merits and limitations
-
Merits
- Motivates employees; chain of promotions
- Simpler, more reliable selection: candidates are known
- Transfer trains employees for higher jobs; no induction needed
- Shifts staff from surplus to short departments
- Cheaper than external recruitment
-
Limitations
- Less fresh talent; danger of inbreeding
- Employees may become lethargic if promotion is sure
- A new enterprise cannot use it
- Competition among employees may suffer
- Frequent transfers may reduce productivity
External sources
| Source | How it works | Typical use or feature |
|---|---|---|
| Direct recruitment | Notice on the notice board; job seekers gather on a set date and are selected on the spot | Casual (badli) unskilled or semi-skilled workers on daily wages; very cheap |
| Casual callers | Database of unsolicited applicants screened when vacancies arise | Reduces recruitment cost |
| Advertisement | In newspapers or trade and professional journals | Wide choice; senior posts; may bring many unsuitable applicants |
| Employment exchange | Government-run; links job seekers and employers | Skilled and unskilled operative jobs; records may be out of date |
| Placement agencies and management consultants | Keep data banks; recommend candidates for a fee | Technical, professional, middle and top executives |
| Campus recruitment | Liaison with colleges, universities and institutes | Technical, professional and managerial jobs |
| Recommendations of employees | Present employees introduce candidates | Background known; a kind of preliminary screening |
| Labour contractors | Contractors supply unskilled workers at short notice | If the contractor leaves, his workers may leave too |
| Advertising on television | Vacancies and job details telecast | Wide reach with organisation profile |
| Web publishing | Job websites for seekers and employers | Commonly used by both sides |
Merits of external sources: qualified and trained people can be attracted; a wide advertisement gives a wider choice; fresh talent or new blood enters; and existing staff face competition and work harder.
Limitations of external sources: dissatisfaction among existing staff, who feel their chances of promotion are reduced; a lengthy process, since vacancies must be notified and applications awaited; and a costly process, with money spent on advertising and processing applications.
Internal sources: transfers (horizontal) and promotions (vertical): cheaper, motivating, but little fresh talent. External sources: wider choice and new blood, but costly, slow and possibly demotivating for existing staff.
Worked example 1: choosing a source
Recommend a source for each made-up case: (a) a factory needs 30 extra loaders for two weeks of festival rush; (b) a software firm needs 50 fresh engineering graduates; (c) a bank branch has too many clerks while another branch is short of clerks; (d) a company needs a chief financial officer with rare experience. Answer: (a) direct recruitment (casual workers, cheap and quick) or a labour contractor; (b) campus recruitment; (c) transfer; (d) placement agency or management consultant.
Worked example 2: comparing costs (illustrative)
A made-up firm estimates that filling a supervisor post by advertising costs ₹40,000 (advertisement ₹25,000 plus processing ₹15,000), while promoting an existing worker costs only ₹5,000 for an internal test. Working: saving from internal recruitment = 40,000 − 5,000 = ₹35,000. But if no insider has the skills needed, the cheaper route may not give the right person. This shows the trade-off between cheapness of internal sources and the wider choice of external ones.
Worked example 3: identify the limitation
Case (made up): a made-up company has filled every senior post by promotion for twenty years. Managers say ideas have become stale and nobody challenges old methods. Limitation of internal sources: less fresh talent, danger of inbreeding.
Key takeaways: recruitment searches for prospective employees and encourages them to apply. Internal sources (transfers and promotions) are cheap, motivating and reliable but limit fresh talent and cannot serve a new firm. External sources (direct recruitment, casual callers, advertisement, employment exchange, placement agencies, campus, employee recommendations, labour contractors, television and the web) give a wider choice and new blood but are costly and slow and may dissatisfy existing staff.
Check your understanding
-
1. Shifting an employee to another department without a substantive change in responsibilities and status is called:
- promotion
- transfer
- placement
- direct recruitment
Show answer
Answer: B. A transfer is a horizontal movement from one job, department or shift to another without a substantive change in responsibilities or status.
-
2. Which source is generally used to recruit casual (badli) unskilled workers on a daily-wage basis?
- Direct recruitment
- Campus recruitment
- Management consultants
- Web publishing
Show answer
Answer: A. Under direct recruitment, a notice is put up, job seekers gather on the set date and are selected on the spot; it is used for casual unskilled or semi-skilled vacancies and is very cheap.
-
3. Which is a limitation of internal sources of recruitment?
- It is costly
- It takes a long time
- It creates dissatisfaction because outsiders are brought in
- It reduces the scope for fresh talent
Show answer
Answer: D. Relying only on internal recruitment risks inbreeding and stops the infusion of new blood. High cost, delay and dissatisfaction are limitations of external sources.
-
4. Case: a made-up firm needs a large number of fresh management graduates for trainee posts. Which source is most suitable?
- Labour contractors
- Employment exchange
- Campus recruitment
- Transfer
Show answer
Answer: C. Colleges and management institutes are a popular source for technical, professional and managerial jobs; recruiting from them is campus recruitment.
-
5. Assertion (A): A new enterprise cannot depend on internal sources of recruitment. Reason (R): A new enterprise has no existing employees to transfer or promote.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: B. Both are true and R explains A: internal sources are transfers and promotions of existing employees, which a new enterprise does not yet have.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.