- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Positive and normative economics; microeconomics and macroeconomics
Distinguish positive from normative economic analysis, distinguish microeconomics from macroeconomics with examples, and see how the five chapters of the book fit together.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish positive economic analysis from normative economic analysis and explain why the line is not sharp.
- Distinguish microeconomics from macroeconomics and classify questions under each.
- Outline the plan of the Introductory Microeconomics book.
The central problems can be solved by different mechanisms - planning, markets or a mix - and each mechanism is likely to produce a different allocation of resources and a different distribution of output. So economists ask two kinds of question: how does each mechanism actually work, and how desirable are its results? This lesson separates these two kinds of analysis and then separates the two branches of economics.
Positive and normative economic analysis
In positive economic analysis, we study how the different mechanisms function and what outcomes they are likely to produce. Positive statements are about what is, was or will be, and in principle can be checked against facts. In normative economic analysis, we try to judge whether these mechanisms and their outcomes are desirable. Normative statements are about what ought to be and involve value judgements.
| Basis | Positive analysis | Normative analysis |
|---|---|---|
| Question asked | How does a mechanism work? What will happen? | Is the outcome desirable? What should be done? |
| Nature | Describes and explains | Evaluates and recommends |
| Can it be tested against facts? | Yes, in principle | Not by facts alone; depends on values |
| Illustrative statement | If the price of a good rises, buyers usually buy less of it | The government should make basic health care free |
The book adds an important caution: the distinction is not a very sharp one. Positive and normative questions about the central problems are closely related, and neither can be properly understood in isolation from the other. To judge whether a policy is good (normative), we first need to know what it will actually do (positive); and the questions we choose to study are often guided by what we care about.
Worked example 1: classifying statements
| Statement (made up) | Type | Why |
|---|---|---|
| When the price of tea rose last year, tea sales fell | Positive | A claim about what happened; can be checked with data |
| Income should be distributed more equally | Normative | Contains a value judgement ('should') |
| A tax on sugary drinks will reduce their consumption | Positive | A prediction that can be tested |
| Higher education ought to be free for all students | Normative | Says what ought to be |
| Unemployment in the town is too high and is unfair to young people | Normative | Judges the situation as too high and unfair |
A useful test: if a statement can be settled, at least in principle, by looking at evidence, it is positive; if people could agree on all the facts and still disagree because of their values, it is normative. Words such as should, ought, fair, good and too much often signal a normative statement.
Positive economics studies how economic mechanisms work; normative economics judges whether their outcomes are desirable. The two are closely linked.
Microeconomics and macroeconomics
Traditionally, economics is studied in two broad branches. In microeconomics, we study the behaviour of individual economic agents - consumers and producers - in the markets for different goods and services, and try to work out how the prices and quantities of these goods are determined through their interaction. In macroeconomics, we try to understand the economy as a whole by focusing on aggregate measures such as total output, employment and the aggregate price level, and on how these are determined and how they change over time.
Two branches of economics
-
Microeconomics
- Studies individual consumers and producers
- Markets for particular goods and services
- How price and quantity of a good are determined
- Example: what decides the price of onions
-
Macroeconomics
- Studies the economy as a whole
- Aggregates: total output, employment, price level
- How these are determined and change over time
- Example: why the general price level rises
Typical macroeconomic questions listed in the book include: what is the level of total output and how is it determined; how does total output grow over time; are resources such as labour fully employed, and if not, why; and why do prices rise? Instead of looking at separate markets, macroeconomics studies aggregate measures of the economy's performance.
Worked example 2: micro or macro?
- How a made-up cycle maker decides how many cycles to produce - micro (one producer).
- Why total employment in the country fell during a slowdown - macro (an aggregate).
- How a family divides its income between milk and fruit - micro (one consumer).
- What determines the general price level of the economy - macro (an aggregate).
- How the price of cotton is fixed in the cotton market - micro (one market).
The plan of the book
Introductory Microeconomics focuses on individual consumers and producers of a single commodity and on how price and quantity are determined in the market for that commodity. Chapter 2 studies consumer behaviour; Chapter 3 the basic ideas of production and cost; Chapter 4 producer behaviour under perfect competition; and Chapter 5 how price and quantity are determined in a perfectly competitive market.
How the chapters build on each other
- Ch 1 Introduction Scarcity, choice, central problems
- Ch 2 Consumer behaviour Demand side
- Ch 3 Production and costs Technology and cost
- Ch 4 Firm under perfect competition Supply side
- Ch 5 Market equilibrium Demand meets supply
Key takeaways: positive analysis explains how mechanisms work; normative analysis judges whether outcomes are desirable; the two are closely related. Microeconomics studies individual agents and the price and quantity of single goods; macroeconomics studies aggregates such as total output, employment and the price level.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement is normative?
- A fall in the price of pens usually raises the quantity of pens bought
- The country's farm output rose last year
- The government ought to give free textbooks to every child
- A tax on cars will raise their price to buyers
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Ought to' expresses a value judgement about what is desirable, so it is normative. The other statements describe or predict what happens and can be checked against facts.
-
2. Which topic belongs to macroeconomics?
- The determination of the general price level of an economy
- The price of wheat in a wheat market
- A consumer's choice between tea and coffee
- A firm's decision on how many workers to hire
Show answer
Answer: A. The general price level is an aggregate measure of the whole economy, so it is studied in macroeconomics. The others concern a single market, consumer or firm.
-
3. According to the textbook, the distinction between positive and normative analysis is:
- Absolutely sharp, with no overlap
- Not very sharp, since the two kinds of issue are closely related
- Relevant only to macroeconomics
- The same as the distinction between micro and macro
Show answer
Answer: B. The book says the distinction is not a very sharp one: understanding one kind of question properly is not possible in isolation from the other.
-
4. Microeconomics mainly studies:
- Total employment in the economy
- The growth of national output over time
- Why the general price level rises
- How the price and quantity of a particular good are determined by individual buyers and sellers
Show answer
Answer: D. Microeconomics looks at individual economic agents in the markets for particular goods and how their interaction determines price and quantity.
-
5. Assertion (A): 'Rent control will reduce the supply of rented houses' is a positive statement. Reason (R): It is a prediction that can, in principle, be checked against evidence.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. The statement predicts an outcome without saying whether it is good or bad, and such a prediction can be tested with data. That is exactly what makes it positive, so R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.