- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
The paradox of thrift, full employment, deficient and excess demand
Work through the paradox of thrift with numbers, distinguish equilibrium from full employment income, explain deficient and excess demand, and state the effective demand principle.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain and calculate the paradox of thrift.
- Distinguish equilibrium income from full employment income, and define deficient demand and excess demand.
- State the effective demand principle.
A surprising result follows from the model: if everyone tries to save a larger share of income, total saving in the economy does not rise - it stays the same or falls. This is the paradox of thrift: as people become more thrifty, they end up saving less or the same as before.
Worked example 1: the paradox of thrift (illustrative)
Navpur starts in equilibrium with C = 60 + 0.75Y, Ī = 40 and Y = 400 (₹ crore). Saving = 400 − (60 + 0.75 × 400) = 400 − 360 = 40. Now, fearing hard times, people become more thrifty: MPC falls from 0.75 to 0.5 (MPS rises from 0.25 to 0.5).
- At the old income of 400, consumption falls by (0.75 − 0.5) × 400 = 100, so AD falls by 100 and there is excess supply of 100.
- Producers cut output by 100; income falls by 100; with the new MPC of 0.5, consumption falls by 0.5 × 100 = 50, creating more excess supply; output falls by 50, then 25, and so on.
- Total fall in output = 100 ÷ (1 − 0.5) = 200, so new income = 400 − 200 = 200. Check: Y* = A ÷ (1 − c) = 100 ÷ 0.5 = 200.
- New saving = 200 − (60 + 0.5 × 200) = 200 − 160 = 40 - exactly the same as before.
Saving is unchanged because, in equilibrium, planned saving must equal planned investment, and investment (40) did not change. The attempt to save more only reduced income, from 400 to 200. On the diagram, the fall in MPC swings the AD line downward (it becomes flatter, pivoting on its intercept of 100), meeting the 45-degree line at a lower income. If investment also fell as sales dropped, saving would actually fall.
Paradox of thrift: if all people try to save a larger proportion of income (MPS rises), total saving does not rise - it remains the same or falls - because income falls.
Equilibrium is not the same as full employment
The equilibrium level of output also determines the level of employment, given the other factors of production. But equilibrium income, where Y equals AD, need not be the income at which everyone is employed. Full employment level of income is the level at which all factors of production are fully employed. Equilibrium only means that, left to itself, income will not change - even if there is unemployment.
Equilibrium compared with full employment
-
Deficient demand
- Equilibrium output below full employment output
- Demand not enough to employ all factors
- Leads to a fall in prices in the long run
-
Excess demand
- Equilibrium output would be above full employment output
- Demand more than output at full employment
- Leads to a rise in prices in the long run
Worked example 2: a deficient-demand gap (illustrative)
Suppose Navpur's full employment income is ₹500 crore, but equilibrium income is ₹400 crore (with A = 100 and c = 0.75). Working: there is deficient demand; output falls short of full employment by 500 − 400 = ₹100 crore. With a multiplier of 4, autonomous spending would need to rise by 100 ÷ 4 = ₹25 crore to bring income to 500. If instead demand were such that equilibrium would be ₹560 crore while the economy can produce only ₹500 crore, there would be excess demand, which raises prices in the long run.
The effective demand principle
The chapter's model rests on these assumptions: a constant price of final goods and a constant rate of interest in the short run, and aggregate supply perfectly elastic at that price. Under these conditions, aggregate output is determined solely by the level of aggregate demand. This is the effective demand principle. An increase (decrease) in autonomous spending raises (lowers) aggregate output by a larger amount through the multiplier.
Effective demand principle in brief
- Prices and interest rate fixed; supply perfectly elastic Unused resources available
- Aggregate demand decides output Y* = A/(1 − c)
- Change in autonomous spending Output changes by a multiple
Worked example 3: putting it together (illustrative)
A made-up economy has C = 20 + 0.9Y and Ī = 30. Working: A = 50; Y* = 50 ÷ 0.1 = 500; multiplier = 10. If investment falls by 5, income falls by 5 × 10 = 50, to 450. If MPC instead fell to 0.8 with investment fixed at 30, Y* = 50 ÷ 0.2 = 250, and saving at the new equilibrium = 250 − (20 + 0.8 × 250) = 250 − 220 = 30 = Ī, the same as at the old equilibrium (500 − (20 + 450) = 30) - the paradox of thrift again.
Key takeaways: when everyone tries to save more, income falls and total saving stays the same or falls (paradox of thrift), because planned saving must equal planned investment in equilibrium. Equilibrium income need not be full employment income: below it there is deficient demand (prices tend to fall in the long run), above it excess demand (prices tend to rise). With fixed prices and interest rate and perfectly elastic supply, aggregate demand alone determines output - the effective demand principle.
Check your understanding
-
1. The paradox of thrift says that when all people try to save a larger share of income:
- Total saving rises sharply
- Total saving stays the same or falls, because income falls
- Investment rises automatically
- Income rises
Show answer
Answer: B. A higher MPS lowers aggregate demand and income; since planned saving must equal (unchanged) planned investment in equilibrium, total saving does not rise.
-
2. With Ī = 30 and C̄ = 20, MPC falls from 0.8 to 0.6. Equilibrium income falls from ₹250 to:
- ₹200
- ₹83.3
- ₹125
- ₹150
Show answer
Answer: C. A = 20 + 30 = 50. Old Y* = 50 ÷ 0.2 = 250. New Y* = 50 ÷ 0.4 = ₹125. Saving at both is 30, equal to investment.
-
3. If equilibrium output is below full employment output, the economy has:
- Excess demand
- Full employment
- A liquidity trap
- Deficient demand
Show answer
Answer: D. Demand is not enough to employ all factors of production, so equilibrium output falls short of full employment output: deficient demand. In the long run it tends to lower prices.
-
4. The effective demand principle states that, with fixed prices and perfectly elastic supply, output is determined by:
- Aggregate demand alone
- The money supply alone
- The rate of interest alone
- Full employment
Show answer
Answer: A. Under the chapter's assumptions, aggregate output is determined solely by the level of aggregate demand.
-
5. Assertion (A): An economy in equilibrium must be at full employment. Reason (R): Equilibrium only means that, left to itself, income will not change.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: D. A is false: equilibrium can occur with unemployment (deficient demand) or above full employment output (excess demand). R is true, and it is exactly why equilibrium does not imply full employment.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.