• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Third Level: the story, its setting and new words

Follow Charley's strange journey to a hidden third level at Grand Central Station and back, know the story's setting in New York and 1894 Galesburg, and use its key words.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Retell the story in the right order, in your own words.
  • Describe the two settings: modern Grand Central and the 1894 world.
  • Explain key words such as psychiatrist, refuge, philately and first-day cover.
  • Identify the twist at the end.

The Third Level by Jack Finney opens Vistas, the supplementary reader. It is a short fantasy told by an ordinary man who insists that he once walked into the past. Is it real, a dream or a wish? The story never fully answers, and that uncertainty is what makes it so interesting to discuss.

About the writer

Jack Finney (1911-1995) was an American writer best known for science fiction and fantasy, and for stories in which ordinary people slip through time. His novel The Body Snatchers became a famous film. In The Third Level he uses a plain, chatty voice to make an impossible event sound believable.

The setting

Grand Central Station in New York is a huge railway terminal. Officially it has two levels: the first, for long-distance trains, and the second, for suburban trains. The narrator claims to have found a third level - a station from the 1890s, lit by gaslights. The other important place is Galesburg, Illinois, a peaceful small town where he went to school, which he imagines as it was in 1894: big old houses, wide lawns, shady trees and calm summer evenings.

The story in brief (in our own words)

Charley, a New Yorker, insists that Grand Central Station has a third level, though his psychiatrist friend calls it a wish to escape modern worries. One night, hurrying home, he takes a strange corridor down into a station of 1894: gaslights, old-fashioned clothes, an old newspaper. He tries to buy tickets to peaceful Galesburg for himself and his wife Louisa, but the clerk rejects his modern money, and he never finds the way back. Later his friend Sam disappears; in his grandfather's stamp collection Charley finds an 1894 envelope holding Sam's letter from Galesburg, urging them to keep looking. The final surprise: Sam was the psychiatrist.

The plot in order

  1. The claim Charley says there is a third level; his psychiatrist calls it a wish to escape.
  2. Lost in Grand Central Hurrying home, he takes a strange corridor down.
  3. 1894 Gaslights, old clothes, an old newspaper: he is in the past.
  4. The failed ticket His modern money is rejected; he leaves fast.
  5. The search He buys old money but cannot find the way again.
  6. Sam vanishes A letter in an 1894 first-day cover reveals Sam is in Galesburg.
  7. The twist Sam was the psychiatrist.

Key words

Example sentences written for this lesson.
WordMeaningOur own example sentence
psychiatrista doctor who treats mental and emotional problemsThe psychiatrist listened patiently to her worries.
wish fulfilmentsatisfying a wish in imagination or a dreamDreaming of winning the match was pure wish fulfilment.
refugea place or activity that gives safety or comfortThe library was her refuge from the noisy house.
philatelythe collecting and study of stampsHis interest in philately began with one old postcard.
first-day coveran envelope with a new stamp, postmarked on the stamp's first day of issueShe keeps her first-day covers sealed in an album.
spittoona container for spitting into, common in old public placesOld railway waiting rooms once had spittoons.
premiuman extra amount paid above the normal valueRare coins sell at a premium.
skin (slang)to cheat someone out of moneyThe trickster tried to skin the tourists.

Worked example 1: what is the third level?

Answer: For Charley, the third level is a hidden part of Grand Central Station that leads into the year 1894. For the psychiatrist, it is a waking dream - Charley's wish to escape. For the reader, it is a symbol of escape from the stresses of modern life into a peaceful past.

Worked example 2: the twist

Question: why is the last line surprising? Working: Sam earlier explained the third level away as wish fulfilment. Answer: the same man who dismissed the third level as a fantasy has used it himself to escape - suggesting that he too wanted to flee modern life, and that the third level may be real.

The twist: the man who called the third level a wish is the one who escaped through it.

Key takeaways: Charley claims to have found a station in 1894 beneath Grand Central. He fails to buy tickets, cannot find the way back, and then learns that his psychiatrist friend Sam has escaped to 1894 Galesburg. The ending blurs fantasy and reality.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the railway officials, how many levels does Grand Central Station have?

    1. One
    2. Two
    3. Three
    4. Four
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The presidents of the railroads would swear there are only two levels; Charley claims a third.

  2. 2. How does the psychiatrist explain Charley's third level?

    1. As a hidden tunnel built by railway workers
    2. As a joke
    3. As a waking-dream wish fulfilment - a wish to escape
    4. As a ghost story
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He calls it a waking-dream wish fulfilment and says Charley wants to escape the worries of modern life.

  3. 3. How does Charley confirm the date on the third level?

    1. From a newspaper dated June 1894
    2. From the clerk's watch
    3. From a calendar on the wall
    4. From his wife's letter
    Show answer

    Answer: A. He looks at a newsboy's stack of The World and later finds the same front page, dated June 11, 1894.

  4. 4. Why does the clerk refuse Charley's money?

    1. It was too little.
    2. Charley had no money.
    3. The office was closed.
    4. Modern banknotes looked unfamiliar, so he suspected cheating.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Old-style notes were larger and different; the clerk thought Charley was trying to cheat him.

  5. 5. Who was Sam?

    1. Charley's grandfather
    2. Charley's psychiatrist
    3. The ticket clerk
    4. A stamp dealer
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The final twist reveals that Sam, who disappeared to 1894 Galesburg, was Charley's psychiatrist.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery