- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Characters and themes: dreams, family and the line between fantasy and reality
Contrast Sophie with Jansie, describe her father and Geoff, explain the family's socio-economic background with indicators, and discuss the benefits and dangers of teenage fantasising.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Contrast Sophie and Jansie with evidence.
- Describe Sophie's father's character and temperament.
- Explain what Geoff symbolises for Sophie.
- Identify indicators of the family's financial status.
- Discuss how much of Sophie's story happens only in her imagination.
The theme is adolescent hero-worship and fantasising; the sub-theme is relationships within the family and between friends. Barton tells the story through Sophie's eyes, so we feel how real her dreams seem to her.
Sophie and Jansie
Two friends
-
Sophie
- Dreamy, ambitious, impulsive
- Imagines boutiques, acting, fame
- Lives partly in fantasy
- Keeps secrets; wants something special
-
Jansie
- Practical and realistic
- Accepts the biscuit factory future
- Curious, a little nosey
- Tends to spread news
The family
| Member | Character | Evidence (in our words) |
|---|---|---|
| Father | Practical, short-tempered, scornful of dreams; loves football | Mocks her plans, looks at her with disdain, warns her aggressively; idolises footballers and goes to the pub to celebrate |
| Mother | Tired, worn out, avoids conflict | Bent back at the sink; sighs; gets upset during rows |
| Geoff | Quiet, private, almost grown up | Apprentice mechanic; rarely speaks; keeps Sophie's secret about the date |
| Derek | Young and cheeky | Teases Sophie for thinking money is easy to come by |
What Geoff symbolises
Geoff is the person Sophie trusts most - she shares her secrets with him first. He travels to the far side of the city for work and seems to know places and people she has never seen. His silence makes him mysterious. For Sophie he symbolises freedom, adulthood and the wider world; she even imagines riding behind him on his motorcycle into a world that applauds them.
The family's background
- They are working class and poor.
- The father does physical work and comes home grimy and sweaty.
- The house is small and cluttered, with washing piled in a corner.
- The mother wishes for 'a decent house to live in' if they ever came into money.
- The girls' expected future is factory work; shop jobs pay too little to please the father.
A striking detail is the incongruity Sophie notices: a delicate bow tied on her mother's apron above a bent, tired back - a small sign of beauty against a hard life, much like Sophie's own dreams against her circumstances.
Is it all in her mind?
Yes - the meeting, the date and the disappointment all happen in Sophie's imagination. Yet her feelings are real: she feels pride, doubt and sadness as if it had all happened. Fantasy can comfort and motivate a young person; it becomes harmful when it replaces effort, or when a person can no longer tell dreams from reality. Sophie seems to be close to that edge.
Teenage fantasising
-
Benefits
- Gives hope and motivation
- Sparks creativity
- Comforts in hard times
- Helps imagine possible futures
-
Dangers
- Can replace real effort
- Leads to disappointment
- Blurs the line with reality
- Can isolate a person from others
Worked example: describing the father
Question: how would you describe Sophie's father? Model answer: he is a hard-working, practical labourer, worn down by work, who is impatient and often scornful of Sophie's dreams. He is quick to anger, looking at her with disdain and warning her aggressively. Yet he is passionate about football; he speaks reverently of a famous player and follows United devotedly, which shows that he too has heroes.
Dreams can light the way - or take the place of the road.
Key takeaways: Sophie is a dreamer, Jansie a realist; the father is practical and scornful; Geoff stands for the wider world. The family is poor and working class. Fantasy can help or harm depending on whether it leads to action.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which word best describes Jansie compared with Sophie?
- Dreamy
- Practical
- Rich
- Silent
Show answer
Answer: B. Jansie accepts their likely factory future and urges Sophie to be sensible - she is practical.
-
2. How does Sophie's father react to her story about Danny Casey?
- He is delighted
- He is disdainful and warns her about her wild stories
- He asks for an autograph
- He ignores football
Show answer
Answer: B. He looks at her with disdain and says her stories will get her into trouble.
-
3. What does Geoff symbolise for Sophie?
- Strict authority
- Football
- Poverty
- Freedom and the wider world beyond her home
Show answer
Answer: D. He travels across the city and seems to know places and people she longs to see.
-
4. Which detail shows the family is poor?
- The house is small and cluttered, and the mother wishes for a decent house
- They own a boutique
- They travel abroad
- They have servants
Show answer
Answer: A. The cramped home and the wish for a better house show their limited means.
-
5. Why was Sophie relieved after talking to Jansie?
- Jansie promised to buy a boutique
- Danny had called
- Geoff had not told anyone about the 'date', so he had kept her secret
- Her father had forgiven her
Show answer
Answer: C. She realised Geoff had not mentioned the date, so he had not let her down.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.