• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Rural-urban migration and the problem of slums

Explain the push and pull factors behind rural-urban migration, analyse the textbook's case study of a migrant worker, and describe the conditions and problems of slums in Indian cities.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the causes of rural-urban migration in terms of push and pull factors.
  • Analyse the costs and benefits of migration for a migrant and his family.
  • Describe the conditions of slums and explain why slum dwellers face social exclusion.

Cities grow in three ways: natural increase (births exceed deaths), net in-migration (more people arrive than leave), and reclassification of rural settlements as urban. According to the textbook, a little over half of the world's people live in cities, a share expected to rise to about two-thirds by 2050, which will put pressure on governments to make cities good places to live.

Why people move from villages to cities

Rural-urban migration is caused by high demand for labour in cities, low job opportunities in villages and an unbalanced pattern of development between rural and urban areas. Because smaller and medium cities offer few opportunities, poor migrants often bypass them and go directly to mega cities.

Push and pull factors of rural-urban migration

  • Push factors (in villages)
    • Few jobs and low incomes
    • Small, shared landholdings
    • Debt and poverty
    • Lack of services
  • Pull factors (in cities)
    • Demand for labour
    • Higher wages
    • Examples of successful migrants
    • Better services

A migrant's story

The textbook's case study follows a young man, called Ramesh in the book, from a poor family whose several brothers shared a small plot of land and were deep in debt. He left school after Class IX. Seeing villagers who had gone to Ludhiana and sent money home, he went there with a friend and worked in a woollen factory for a very low daily wage (according to the textbook, ₹20 a day in 1988), struggling with expenses and with a new culture. He then moved to Surat, learnt welding, and has since followed a contractor to work sites in several states. His remittances pay for food, health care and schooling at home, and part goes into farming, land and housing, so the family's standard of living has improved greatly. But he lives apart from his family because the job is temporary and transferable.

Costs and benefits of migration in the case study
GainsCosts
Regular income and remittances homeSeparation from family
Family's food, health and schooling improveLow wages at first; hard to manage expenses
New skill (welding) learntDifficulty adjusting to a new culture
Investment in land and housingInsecure, temporary, transferable jobs

The textbook comments that in developing countries, poor, semi-literate and unskilled migrants often end up in menial, low-wage jobs in the informal sector. Wages are too low to support a family in the city, so spouses stay behind to care for children and the elderly; hence the rural-urban migration stream is dominated by males.

Worked example 1: the case study's figures

According to the textbook, the migrant earned ₹20 a day in 1988 and now sends home ₹20,000 a year. Working: at ₹20 a day for 30 days, monthly earnings in 1988 were ₹600. Today's remittance is 20,000 ÷ 12 ≈ ₹1,667 a month. Answer: the money he now sends home each month is nearly three times his entire 1988 monthly wage, though prices have also risen since 1988, so not all of this is a real gain.

The problem of slums

Indian cities are far from uniform. At one extreme are high-income localities with wide roads, street lights, water and sanitation, parks and security. At the other are slums, jhuggi-jhopri clusters and shanty colonies, inhabited by people who migrated in search of livelihood but could not afford proper housing because of high rents and land costs. They occupy environmentally incompatible and degraded areas.

Slums are residential areas of the least choice: dilapidated housing, poor hygiene and ventilation, and a lack of basic amenities such as drinking water, light and toilets.

Open defecation, unregulated drainage and overcrowded narrow lanes create serious health and environmental hazards. Most slum dwellers work in low-paid, high-risk, unorganised sectors, so they are often undernourished, prone to illness, and unable to educate their children properly. Poverty makes them vulnerable to drug abuse, alcoholism, crime and ultimately social exclusion. The textbook describes Dharavi in Mumbai, often called Asia's largest slum, through a writer's account: extremely narrow lanes, crowded rooms shared by large families, uncollected garbage and foul water, yet workshops producing fine pottery, embroidery, leather goods, garments, metalwork and furniture for rich markets. It also notes a national cleanliness mission as part of urban renewal to improve life in slums.

The cycle of slum poverty

  1. Low-paid, insecure informal work
  2. Cannot afford proper housing; live in degraded areas
  3. Poor sanitation and nutrition cause illness
  4. Children miss schooling; skills stay low

Then back to step 1: Low-paid, insecure informal work

Worked example 2: why slum children miss school

Question: Why are many children of slum dwellers deprived of schooling? Working: parents earn little in unorganised work, so children may be needed to earn or to look after younger siblings; illness from poor sanitation causes absence; families may move often. Answer: poverty, poor health and insecure livelihoods keep children out of school, continuing the cycle of exclusion.

Key takeaways: Rural-urban migration is driven by city demand for labour, lack of rural jobs and unbalanced development; poor migrants often go straight to mega cities. The textbook's case study shows remittances improving a family's life at the cost of separation and insecure work; the migration stream is male-dominated. Migrants who cannot afford housing end up in slums: dilapidated, unhygienic, lacking water and toilets, on degraded land, with low-paid informal work, poor health and social exclusion, as in Dharavi.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Push and pull factors are responsible for:

    1. migration
    2. land degradation
    3. slum formation only
    4. air pollution
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Push factors at the origin and pull factors at the destination explain migration.

  2. 2. Why is the rural-urban migration stream in India dominated by males, according to the textbook?

    1. Women are not allowed to move
    2. Low wages in cities cannot support a family, so spouses stay back to care for children and the elderly
    3. Cities have no jobs for men
    4. Villages pay higher wages
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Migrants often get menial low-wage jobs; since these cannot support a whole family in the city, spouses stay in the village.

  3. 3. Which is NOT a characteristic of slums described in the textbook?

    1. Dilapidated houses
    2. Poor ventilation
    3. Lack of drinking water and toilets
    4. Wide roads and well-developed green belts
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Wide roads and green belts describe high-income localities, the opposite extreme from slums.

  4. 4. Poor migrants often bypass small and medium cities and go directly to mega cities because:

    1. mega cities are closer
    2. small cities ban migrants
    3. opportunities in small and medium cities are low
    4. mega cities have no slums
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook says low opportunities in smaller and medium cities lead the poor to go straight to mega cities.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Slum dwellers often suffer social exclusion. Reason (R): Poverty makes them vulnerable to drug abuse, alcoholism, crime and apathy.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true; the textbook traces a chain from poverty to these vulnerabilities and ultimately to social exclusion, so R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery