- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Towns, trade, coins and reading inscriptions
Describe the new cities, urban people and guilds, trade routes and coinage, explain how Brahmi and Kharosthi were deciphered, and evaluate the limitations of inscriptional evidence.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe early historic cities, urban occupations, guilds and trade networks.
- Trace the history of coinage from punch-marked coins to Gupta gold coins, and the debate after c. sixth century CE.
- Explain how Brahmi and Kharosthi were deciphered and list the limitations of inscriptions.
From c. sixth century BCE, cities grew again in many parts of the subcontinent, many as capitals of mahajanapadas. Almost all major towns lay on routes of communication: Pataliputra on a river route, Ujjayini on land routes, and Puhar on the coast where sea routes began. Cities like Mathura were busy centres of commerce, culture and politics.
Urban populations
Kings and elites lived in fortified cities. Unlike Harappan sites, these are hard to excavate because people still live there, but finds include Northern Black Polished Ware (fine glossy bowls and dishes, probably used by the rich) and objects of gold, silver, copper, bronze, ivory, glass, shell and terracotta. By the second century BCE, short votive inscriptions (records of gifts to religious institutions) name donors and sometimes their occupations: washing folk, weavers, scribes, carpenters, potters, goldsmiths, blacksmiths, officials, religious teachers, merchants and kings. An image from Mathura, for example, records that Nagapiya, wife of a goldsmith, installed it in a shrine. Guilds or shrenis, organisations of craft producers and merchants, probably procured raw materials, regulated production and marketed products.
Each city had its own history. Pataliputra began as the village Pataligrama; the Magadhan rulers moved their capital there from Rajagaha and renamed it; it became the Mauryan capital and one of Asia's largest cities, then declined, so that the Chinese pilgrim Xuan Zang found it in ruins in the seventh century CE.
Trade in the subcontinent and beyond
From the sixth century BCE, land and river routes criss-crossed the subcontinent, extending into Central Asia, across the Arabian Sea to East and North Africa and West Asia, and through the Bay of Bengal to Southeast Asia and China. Rulers tried to control routes, possibly by offering protection for a price. Traders included peddlers on foot, merchants with caravans of bullock carts and pack-animals, and seafarers whose ventures were risky but very profitable. Rich merchants were called masattuvan in Tamil and setthis and satthavahas in Prakrit. Goods included salt, grain, cloth, metal ores and products, stone, timber and medicinal plants; pepper, textiles and medicinal plants were in high demand in the Roman Empire. The Greek Periplus of the Erythraean Sea (c. first century CE) lists goods traded on the Malabar coast, and Kodumanal (Tamil Nadu) has evidence of a bead-making industry.
Coins and kings
| Coins | What is notable |
|---|---|
| Punch-marked coins of silver and copper, c. sixth century BCE onwards | Among the earliest; symbols punched onto metal; probably issued by kings, possibly also by merchants, bankers and townspeople |
| Indo-Greek coins, c. second century BCE | First coins to bear the names and images of rulers |
| Kushana gold coins, c. first century CE | First gold coins on a large scale; weights virtually identical with Roman and Parthian coins |
| Roman coin hoards in south India | Trade networks crossed political boundaries |
| Yaudheya copper coins, c. first century CE | Issued by a tribal republic of Punjab and Haryana; several thousand found |
| Gupta gold coins | Some of the most spectacular; early issues remarkably pure |
Numismatics is the study of coins: their scripts, images, metals and find-contexts. From c. sixth century CE, finds of gold coins taper off. Historians are divided: some say long-distance trade declined after the collapse of the Western Roman Empire; others point to new towns and trade networks, note that coins are still mentioned in texts and inscriptions, and ask whether fewer finds mean coins were circulating rather than hoarded.
How inscriptions were deciphered
Two decipherments
-
Brahmi
- Ancestor of most scripts of modern Indian languages
- From the late eighteenth century, European scholars and Indian pandits worked backwards from Bengali and Devanagari
- Scholars at first wrongly assumed the language was Sanskrit; it was Prakrit
- Prinsep deciphered Asokan Brahmi in 1838
-
Kharosthi
- Used in the northwest
- Indo-Greek coins carried kings' names in Greek and Kharosthi
- Scholars compared letters, e.g. in names such as Apollodotus
- Prinsep identified the language as Prakrit, so longer inscriptions could be read
Asoka's name is absent from many inscriptions, which use titles: devanampiya ('beloved of the gods') and piyadassi ('pleasant to behold'). Inscriptions that name Asoka carry the same titles; matching content, style, language and palaeography convinced epigraphists that one ruler issued them all. Historians must also judge whether claims are true, plausible or exaggerated: Asoka claims earlier rulers had no arrangements to receive reports. Words in brackets in translations are added by epigraphists to make meaning clear, carefully, without changing it. Asoka's inscription expressing anguish over the Kalinga war is missing from Kalinga itself (present-day Orissa), although other Asokan inscriptions are found there.
Limitations of inscriptional evidence
- Technical: letters faintly engraved, damaged or missing, so readings are uncertain.
- Meaning: words may be specific to a place or time; scholars keep debating readings.
- Survival and publication: several thousand inscriptions are known, but not all are deciphered, published and translated, and many have perished.
- Selection: routine farming and the joys and sorrows of daily life are not recorded; inscriptions focus on grand, unique events.
- Perspective: inscriptions project the view of those who commissioned them, so they must be set beside other perspectives.
Worked example 1: same ruler or not?
Inscription X says 'Devanampiya Piyadassi'; inscription Y says 'Devanampiya Asoka'. How do epigraphists decide both belong to one king? Working: compare content (same dhamma themes), style, language (Prakrit) and palaeography (same letter forms of the same period). When all four match, they conclude a single ruler issued them.
Worked example 2: why gold coins might seem to vanish
Two explanations for fewer gold coin finds after c. sixth century CE. Working: (1) decline: Rome's collapse cut long-distance trade and prosperity; (2) circulation: coins kept moving in use and were not buried in hoards, so fewer survive to be found, while texts still mention coins. The book leaves the question open, so an answer should present both.
Inscriptions are invaluable but partial: they record what their patrons chose to record, in their own perspective, and only a fraction survive and are read.
Key takeaways: towns grew on routes; NBPW, votive inscriptions and guilds reveal urban life. Trade reached Central Asia, West Asia, Africa, Southeast Asia, China and Rome. Coins run from punch-marked silver and copper to Indo-Greek portrait coins, Kushana and Gupta gold, and Yaudheya copper. Brahmi was deciphered in 1838 by Prinsep; Kharosthi via bilingual Indo-Greek coins. Epigraphy alone cannot give a full history.
Check your understanding
-
1. The first coins to bear the names and images of rulers were issued by the:
- Mauryas
- Kushanas
- Yaudheyas
- Indo-Greeks
Show answer
Answer: D. The Indo-Greeks, who controlled the north-west c. second century BCE, issued the first coins with rulers' names and images. Kushanas issued gold coins on a large scale later.
-
2. How was Kharosthi deciphered?
- By comparing letters on Indo-Greek coins that carried names in both Greek and Kharosthi
- By working backwards from Devanagari manuscripts
- By reading a long Sanskrit inscription
- By using Chinese pilgrims' accounts
Show answer
Answer: A. Indo-Greek coins carried kings' names in Greek and Kharosthi. Scholars who read Greek compared letters, for instance in names like Apollodotus; Prinsep then identified the language as Prakrit.
-
3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'We, the weavers of this town, buy cotton together, fix the quality of our cloth and sell it through our own agents.' Which organisation does this describe?
- A gana
- A shreni or guild
- A samanta household
- An agrahara
Show answer
Answer: B. Guilds or shrenis were organisations of craft producers and merchants that probably procured raw materials, regulated production and marketed the finished product.
-
4. Assertion (A): Fewer gold coins are found from c. sixth century CE onwards. Reason (R): All historians agree this proves a severe economic crisis.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: C. A is true. R is false: historians are divided; some link it to the decline of trade after the Western Roman Empire collapsed, while others point to new towns and suggest coins circulated rather than being hoarded.
-
5. Which of these is a limitation of inscriptions as historical sources, according to the textbook?
- They usually record routine agricultural practices in great detail
- They can never be dated
- They always present many different perspectives
- They project the perspective of those who commissioned them
Show answer
Answer: D. Inscriptions almost invariably project the view of their patrons and focus on grand events, not daily life. Many can be dated, some by palaeography.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.