- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
The EU as a power: its influence and its limits
Assess the economic, political and diplomatic, and military influence of the European Union, and explain the divisions and Euro-scepticism that limit its ability to act together.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the sources of the EU's economic, diplomatic and military influence.
- Describe how the EU prefers diplomacy and negotiation to force.
- Identify the limits on the EU's power, including divergent policies and Euro-scepticism.
The textbook argues that the EU has economic, political and diplomatic, and military influence, which is why it counts as an alternative centre of power. But it is a union of states, and its members do not always agree. This lesson weighs both sides.
Economic influence
- The EU's economy is very large; the textbook gives a projected figure for 2024 to show its size (figures like this change every year, so learn the idea, not the number).
- Its currency, the euro, can pose a threat to the dominance of the US dollar.
- Its share of world trade is much larger than that of the US, which lets it be more assertive in trade disputes with the US and China.
- Its economic power gives it influence over its neighbours and in Asia and Africa, and it functions as an important bloc in bodies such as the World Trade Organisation (WTO).
Political and diplomatic influence
- One EU member, France, holds a permanent seat on the UN Security Council, and the EU includes several non-permanent members of the Council.
- This has enabled the EU to influence some US policies; the textbook's example is the US position on Iran's nuclear programme.
- The EU prefers diplomacy, economic investment and negotiation to coercion and military force. The textbook cites its dialogue with China on human rights and environmental degradation as effective.
Military and technological influence
According to the textbook, the EU's combined armed forces are the second largest in the world and its total defence spending is second only to the US. One member, France, has nuclear weapons. The EU is also described as the world's second most important source of space and communications technology.
Sources of EU influence
-
Economic
- Large economy
- The euro as a rival to the dollar
- Large share of world trade
- Bloc in the WTO
-
Political and diplomatic
- France a permanent UNSC member
- Several non-permanent UNSC members
- Diplomacy and negotiation over force
-
Military and technological
- Large combined armed forces
- High defence spending
- France a nuclear power
- Space and communications technology
Limits: a union of sovereign states
As a supranational organisation, the EU can intervene in economic, political and social areas. But in many areas its members keep their own foreign relations and defence policies, and these often clash. The textbook gives these examples:
- Over the Iraq invasion, Britain's Prime Minister Tony Blair was America's partner, and many newer EU members joined the US-led 'coalition of the willing', while Germany and France opposed American policy.
- There is deep-seated Euro-scepticism in parts of Europe about the EU's integrationist agenda. Britain's former Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher kept the UK out of the European Market.
- Denmark and Sweden resisted the Maastricht Treaty and the adoption of the euro.
- In 2016, according to the textbook's timeline, 51.9 per cent of voters in a British referendum chose to leave the EU (Brexit).
These divisions, the textbook concludes, limit the EU's ability to act in foreign relations and defence. A cartoon in the chapter compares the EU to the Titanic after the 2003 failure of the draft common constitution, suggesting a grand project at risk.
The EU's strengths and limits
-
Strengths
- Economic weight and the euro
- Seats and votes in the UN Security Council
- Effective diplomacy and negotiation
- Large military and technology base
-
Limits
- Members keep their own foreign and defence policies
- Split over the Iraq invasion
- Euro-scepticism in some countries
- Some members stayed out of the euro
Euro-scepticism: doubt or opposition, within European countries, towards handing more powers to the EU and deepening integration.
Worked example 1: what makes the EU influential?
Question: A made-up student says, 'The EU is only a trading club.' Use the chapter to show it has more than economic weight. Model answer: (1) Economic: a very large economy, a big share of world trade and the euro, which can challenge the dollar; this lets it stand up to the US and China in trade disputes. (2) Diplomatic: France's permanent seat and other members' seats in the Security Council, and a record of effective negotiation, as in its dialogue with China. (3) Military: according to the textbook, the second largest combined armed forces and defence spending in the world, plus France's nuclear weapons. Each reason is stated, then explained in one line.
Worked example 2: a source-based reading
Source (written for this lesson): 'When the war in Iraq began, London stood with Washington, while Paris and Berlin said no.' Question: What limitation of the EU does this show? Reasoning: the three capitals belong to EU members (Britain was then a member) but took opposite positions on a major war. Answer: EU members keep their own foreign and defence policies, which often clash and limit the EU's ability to act as one.
Key takeaways: the EU's influence is economic (size, trade, the euro, WTO weight), political and diplomatic (Security Council seats, preference for negotiation) and military (large forces and spending, a nuclear member). Its limits come from members' separate foreign and defence policies, as over Iraq, and from Euro-scepticism, as in Britain, Denmark and Sweden.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which EU member holds a permanent seat on the UN Security Council, as the chapter notes?
- Germany
- Spain
- Italy
- France
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says one member of the EU, France, holds a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.
-
2. The EU's preferred method of influence, according to the textbook, is:
- coercion and military force
- diplomacy, economic investment and negotiation
- trade embargoes only
- withdrawing from international bodies
Show answer
Answer: B. The chapter says its use of diplomacy, economic investments and negotiations rather than coercion has been effective, as in its dialogue with China.
-
3. Over the Iraq invasion, which two EU members opposed American policy?
- Britain and Poland
- Denmark and Sweden
- Germany and France
- Spain and Italy
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says Britain's Prime Minister was America's partner and many newer members joined the coalition, whereas Germany and France opposed American policy.
-
4. Which countries resisted the Maastricht Treaty and the adoption of the euro, according to the chapter?
- Denmark and Sweden
- France and Germany
- Greece and Portugal
- Belgium and the Netherlands
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter names Denmark and Sweden as having resisted the Maastricht Treaty and the euro, an example of Euro-scepticism.
-
5. Assertion (A): The EU's ability to act together in foreign relations and defence is limited. Reason (R): In many areas EU member states have their own foreign relations and defence policies that are often at odds with each other.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because members keep separate, often conflicting foreign and defence policies, the EU's ability to act as one in these areas is limited.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.