• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Jammu and Kashmir: roots of the problem and politics since 1948

Describe the regions of Jammu and Kashmir, the roots of the issue in 1947-48, the external and internal disputes, and the course of politics from 1948 to 2019, strictly as the textbook presents them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the three regions and the events of 1947-48, including the UN resolution of 21 April 1948.
  • Explain the two opposite internal reactions to Article 370 and the three grievances the textbook lists.
  • Outline the main political developments from 1953 to 2019 given in the textbook.

The textbook says Jammu and Kashmir had a special status under Article 370, yet experienced violence, cross-border terrorism and political instability, with loss of many lives (civilians, security personnel and militants) and the large-scale displacement of Kashmiri Pandits from the valley. This lesson follows its account closely; where the book reports differing views, we report them as views.

Three regions

The three social and political regions
RegionDescription in the textbook
JammuFoothills and plains; predominantly Hindu, with Muslims, Sikhs and others
KashmirMainly the Kashmir valley; mostly Kashmiri Muslims, with Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists and others
LadakhMainly mountainous; very small population, almost equally divided between Buddhists and Muslims

Roots of the problem

Before 1947 J&K was a princely state. Its ruler, Maharaja Hari Singh, wanted independence rather than joining India or Pakistan. Pakistani leaders thought Kashmir 'belonged' to Pakistan because most of its people were Muslim, but, the book says, the people saw themselves as Kashmiris above all, a regional aspiration known as Kashmiriyat. The popular movement led by Sheikh Abdullah of the National Conference wanted to end the Maharaja's rule but opposed joining Pakistan; the National Conference was secular and long associated with the Congress.

1947-48 (textbook sequence)

  1. October 1947 Pakistan sends tribal infiltrators to capture Kashmir
  2. Instrument of Accession The Maharaja seeks Indian military help and signs it
  3. Infiltrators driven back But Pakistan continues to control a sizeable part
  4. UN resolution, 21 April 1948 Three-step process recommended; no progress achieved
  5. March 1948 Sheikh Abdullah becomes Prime Minister of J&K; provisional autonomy under Article 370

The UN resolution's three steps were: Pakistan to withdraw all its nationals who had entered Kashmir; India to progressively reduce its forces to the level needed for law and order; and then a free and impartial plebiscite. The textbook says no progress could be achieved under it.

External and internal disputes

Externally, Pakistan has always claimed the Kashmir valley. The textbook describes the part that came under Pakistani control after the 1947 invasion as Indian territory under illegal occupation of Pakistan, called Pakistan-occupied Jammu and Kashmir (POJK), and says Kashmir has remained a major issue between the two countries since 1947.

Internally, there was a dispute about Kashmir's status within the Union. The textbook records two opposite reactions to the special status:

Two opposite internal views on Article 370 (as reported in the textbook)

  • A section outside J&K
    • Special status prevented full integration
    • Article 370 should be revoked
    • J&K should be treated like any other state
  • Another section, mostly Kashmiris
    • Autonomy under Article 370 was not enough
    • Promise of referring accession to the people unfulfilled: demand for plebiscite
    • Special status eroded in practice: demand for 'Greater State Autonomy'
    • Democracy not institutionalised as in the rest of India

Politics since 1948

Political developments in J&K, as stated in the textbook
PeriodDevelopments according to the textbook
1948-1953Sheikh Abdullah carried out major land reforms; differences with the Centre over Kashmir's status; dismissed in 1953 and detained for years
1953-1974Successors ruled mainly with the Centre's support; serious allegations of malpractice and rigging; Congress influence grew; National Conference (without Sheikh Abdullah) later merged with the Congress
1965Head of government renamed from Prime Minister to Chief Minister; Ghulam Mohammed Sadiq of the Congress became first Chief Minister
1974-1982Agreement between Indira Gandhi and Sheikh Abdullah; he became Chief Minister; National Conference won the 1977 elections; he died in 1982
1982-1986Farooq Abdullah became Chief Minister but was dismissed by the Governor; a breakaway faction ruled briefly; resentment grew; in 1986 the NC allied with the Congress
1987NC-Congress alliance officially won massively, but it was widely believed the election was rigged
1989 onwardsMilitant movement for a separate Kashmiri nation, supported by Pakistan; years of President's rule and extraordinary violence from insurgents and army action
1996-2008Assembly elections in 1996 (NC returned, seeking regional autonomy); a PDP-Congress coalition from 2002; President's rule in July 2008
2009-2018Further coalition governments; the 2014 election recorded the highest turnout in 25 years; President's rule from June 2018
5 August 2019Article 370 abolished by the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act 2019; the state reconstituted into two Union Territories, Jammu and Kashmir, and Ladakh

The textbook ends by describing Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh as living examples of India's plural society, with diversities of every kind and divergent political and developmental aspirations, which the 2019 Act sought to address.

Kashmiriyat: the regional aspiration and identity by which the people of the state saw themselves as Kashmiris above all.

Worked example 1: sorting grievances

Match each made-up statement to one of the three grievances the textbook lists. (a) 'The people were promised a say on accession.' (b) 'Powers given under the special status were reduced over time.' (c) 'Elections here have not been as free as elsewhere.' Working: (a) is the unfulfilled promise, leading to the plebiscite demand. (b) is the erosion of special status, leading to the demand for Greater State Autonomy. (c) is the feeling that democracy was not institutionalised in the state as in the rest of India.

Worked example 2: tracing the crisis of the late 1980s

Explain, step by step, how the textbook links events of the 1980s to the insurgency. Working: (1) Farooq Abdullah's government was dismissed after central intervention, setting back confidence in democratic processes. (2) The 1986 NC-Congress alliance strengthened the feeling that the Centre was intervening. (3) The 1987 election was widely believed to be rigged, adding to resentment over inefficient administration. (4) This political crisis became severe with the rise of insurgency by 1989, supported by Pakistan.

Key takeaways

  • J&K had three regions: Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh; Kashmiriyat expressed a distinct regional identity.
  • October 1947: tribal invasion, Instrument of Accession; UN resolution of 21 April 1948 made no progress.
  • Internally, some wanted Article 370 revoked, while many Kashmiris felt autonomy was insufficient.
  • After the disputed 1987 election, insurgency grew from 1989; on 5 August 2019 Article 370 was abolished and two Union Territories formed (textbook).

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What does the textbook mean by 'Kashmiriyat'?

    1. The demand to merge Kashmir with Pakistan
    2. The regional aspiration by which people saw themselves as Kashmiris above all
    3. A tax levied by the Maharaja
    4. The name of the UN resolution of 1948
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The book says the people of the state thought of themselves as Kashmiris above all, and this regional aspiration is known as Kashmiriyat.

  2. 2. Which was NOT one of the three steps recommended in the UN resolution of 21 April 1948?

    1. Pakistan to withdraw all its nationals who had entered Kashmir
    2. Immediate division of the state between India and Pakistan
    3. A free and impartial plebiscite
    4. India to progressively reduce its forces to maintain law and order
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The three steps were withdrawal of Pakistani nationals, progressive reduction of Indian forces, and a free and impartial plebiscite. Division of the state was not one of them.

  3. 3. In which year was the head of government of J&K redesignated from Prime Minister to Chief Minister?

    1. 1948
    2. 1953
    3. 1965
    4. 1974
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A change in the Constitution of J&K in 1965 designated the Prime Minister of the state as Chief Minister; Ghulam Mohammed Sadiq became the first Chief Minister.

  4. 4. According to the textbook, what happened on 5 August 2019?

    1. The UN held a plebiscite
    2. The first Assembly election was held
    3. Sheikh Abdullah became Chief Minister
    4. Article 370 was abolished and the state was reconstituted into two Union Territories
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook says that on 5 August 2019 Article 370 was abolished by the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act 2019 and the state was constituted into two Union Territories, Jammu and Kashmir, and Ladakh.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The 1987 Assembly election added to the political crisis in Kashmir. Reason (R): It was widely believed that the results did not reflect popular choice and that the election process was rigged.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the widespread belief that the 1987 election was rigged deepened resentment and the feeling that democratic processes were being undermined, feeding the crisis that grew into insurgency.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery