Revision notes

Chapter 7 Regional Aspirations: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Region and nation: the Indian approach and the Dravidian movement

Two approaches to diversity (as the textbook contrasts them)

  • Indian approach
    • Regions and language groups keep their own culture
    • Unity balanced with diversity
    • Regional aspirations expressed democratically, not treated as anti-national
  • Approach seen in many European countries
    • Cultural diversity seen as a threat to the nation
    • Pressure towards a single national culture

The Indian approach, in the textbook's words summarised: the nation does not negate the region; unity is pursued together with diversity, through democratic accommodation.

The course of the Dravidian movement (textbook)

  1. Dravidar Kazhagam (DK) Led by E.V. Ramasami 'Periyar'; against Brahmin dominance and northern domination
  2. Limited to Tamil Nadu Little support from other southern states
  3. DMK takes over the legacy After the DK split
  4. 1953-54 agitations Railway station name, Tamil cultural history in curricula, against the craft education scheme
  5. 1965 anti-Hindi agitation Adds to the DMK's popularity
  6. 1967 DMK comes to power; Dravidian parties dominate Tamil Nadu since
  • The Indian approach: the nation does not negate the region; diversity is accommodated democratically.
  • Democracy both strengthens regional aspirations and accommodates them in policy.
  • Areas of tension included Kashmir, the North-East, language disputes, linguistic states and Punjab.
  • The Dravidian movement used democratic means and, the book says, shows regionalism and nationalism can be compatible.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Jammu and Kashmir: roots of the problem and politics since 1948

The three social and political regions
RegionDescription in the textbook
JammuFoothills and plains; predominantly Hindu, with Muslims, Sikhs and others
KashmirMainly the Kashmir valley; mostly Kashmiri Muslims, with Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists and others
LadakhMainly mountainous; very small population, almost equally divided between Buddhists and Muslims

1947-48 (textbook sequence)

  1. October 1947 Pakistan sends tribal infiltrators to capture Kashmir
  2. Instrument of Accession The Maharaja seeks Indian military help and signs it
  3. Infiltrators driven back But Pakistan continues to control a sizeable part
  4. UN resolution, 21 April 1948 Three-step process recommended; no progress achieved
  5. March 1948 Sheikh Abdullah becomes Prime Minister of J&K; provisional autonomy under Article 370

Two opposite internal views on Article 370 (as reported in the textbook)

  • A section outside J&K
    • Special status prevented full integration
    • Article 370 should be revoked
    • J&K should be treated like any other state
  • Another section, mostly Kashmiris
    • Autonomy under Article 370 was not enough
    • Promise of referring accession to the people unfulfilled: demand for plebiscite
    • Special status eroded in practice: demand for 'Greater State Autonomy'
    • Democracy not institutionalised as in the rest of India
Political developments in J&K, as stated in the textbook
PeriodDevelopments according to the textbook
1948-1953Sheikh Abdullah carried out major land reforms; differences with the Centre over Kashmir's status; dismissed in 1953 and detained for years
1953-1974Successors ruled mainly with the Centre's support; serious allegations of malpractice and rigging; Congress influence grew; National Conference (without Sheikh Abdullah) later merged with the Congress
1965Head of government renamed from Prime Minister to Chief Minister; Ghulam Mohammed Sadiq of the Congress became first Chief Minister
1974-1982Agreement between Indira Gandhi and Sheikh Abdullah; he became Chief Minister; National Conference won the 1977 elections; he died in 1982
1982-1986Farooq Abdullah became Chief Minister but was dismissed by the Governor; a breakaway faction ruled briefly; resentment grew; in 1986 the NC allied with the Congress
1987NC-Congress alliance officially won massively, but it was widely believed the election was rigged
1989 onwardsMilitant movement for a separate Kashmiri nation, supported by Pakistan; years of President's rule and extraordinary violence from insurgents and army action
1996-2008Assembly elections in 1996 (NC returned, seeking regional autonomy); a PDP-Congress coalition from 2002; President's rule in July 2008
2009-2018Further coalition governments; the 2014 election recorded the highest turnout in 25 years; President's rule from June 2018
5 August 2019Article 370 abolished by the Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act 2019; the state reconstituted into two Union Territories, Jammu and Kashmir, and Ladakh

Kashmiriyat: the regional aspiration and identity by which the people of the state saw themselves as Kashmiris above all.

  • J&K had three regions: Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh; Kashmiriyat expressed a distinct regional identity.
  • October 1947: tribal invasion, Instrument of Accession; UN resolution of 21 April 1948 made no progress.
  • Internally, some wanted Article 370 revoked, while many Kashmiris felt autonomy was insufficient.
  • After the disputed 1987 election, insurgency grew from 1989; on 5 August 2019 Article 370 was abolished and two Union Territories formed (textbook).
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Punjab: from the Anandpur Sahib Resolution to the Punjab Accord

Anandpur Sahib Resolution (1973): an Akali resolution asserting regional autonomy and seeking to redefine Centre-state relations; described in the textbook as a plea for strengthening federalism.

1980-1985 in Punjab (textbook sequence)

  1. 1980 Akali government dismissed; movement over river waters
  2. Extremists take over Armed insurgency; militants fortify the Golden Temple
  3. June 1984 Operation Blue Star: army action in the Golden Temple
  4. 31 October 1984 Prime Minister Indira Gandhi assassinated by her bodyguards
  5. Following days Violence against Sikhs in Delhi and parts of north India
  6. July 1985 Rajiv Gandhi-Longowal Accord (Punjab Accord)
Main provisions of the Punjab Accord, 1985
Provision of the Punjab AccordDetail (textbook)
ChandigarhTo be transferred to Punjab
Border disputeA separate commission to resolve the Punjab-Haryana border dispute
River watersA tribunal to decide sharing of Ravi-Beas waters among Punjab, Haryana and Rajasthan
Those affected by militancyCompensation and better treatment
Special lawWithdrawal of the Armed Forces Special Powers Act in Punjab
  • The Akali Dal (1920) led the Punjabi suba movement, achieved in 1966; Akali governments in 1967 and 1977 felt insecure.
  • The Anandpur Sahib Resolution (1973) sought regional autonomy; the book calls it a plea for stronger federalism with limited mass appeal.
  • June 1984 Operation Blue Star; 31 October 1984 Indira Gandhi assassinated; violence against Sikhs followed, with more than two thousand killed in Delhi (textbook).
  • The Punjab Accord of July 1985 was a step towards normalcy; peace returned by the mid-1990s.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

The North-East: autonomy, secession and movements against outsiders

Reorganisation of the North-East
YearChange (textbook)
1963Nagaland created
1972Manipur, Tripura and Meghalaya became states
1987Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh became states

Three issues in North-East politics (textbook)

  • Demands for autonomy
    • Tribal states carved out of Assam
    • District and autonomous councils within Assam
  • Movements for secession
    • Mizoram: settled by the 1986 accord
    • Nagaland: still awaits final resolution
  • Opposition to 'outsiders'
    • Assam Movement, 1979-1985
    • Tensions in Tripura; hostility to Chakma refugees

Two secessionist movements compared (textbook)

  • Mizoram
    • Some Mizos felt they were never part of British India
    • Support grew after Assam's inadequate response to the 1959 famine
    • Mizo National Front under Laldenga; armed campaign from 1966
    • Repressive measures increased alienation
    • 1986 accord: statehood with special powers; MNF gave up secession
  • Nagaland
    • Led by Angami Zapu Phizo
    • A section declared independence in 1951
    • Naga National Council's armed struggle
    • A section signed an agreement, not accepted by others
    • Still awaits a final resolution
  • The North-East: eight states, 4 per cent of population and about twice that share of area, linked by a corridor of about 22 km (textbook).
  • Autonomy demands led to new states (by 1972) and to District and Autonomous Councils within Assam.
  • Mizoram's 1986 accord ended secession; Nagaland's problem still awaits final resolution.
  • The Assam Movement (1979-85) led to the Assam Accord of 1985 and the AGP government; Sikkim became the 22nd state in 1975.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Accommodation and national integration: lessons from regional movements

Lessons from regional aspirations (textbook)

  • 1. Regional aspirations are normal Part of democratic politics, not an aberration; seen even in smaller countries
  • 2. Negotiate, do not suppress Accords reduced tensions; Mizoram shows political settlement can end separatism
  • 3. Share power Regional groups need a share of power in the state and in national decisions
  • 4. Address regional imbalance Uneven development breeds a feeling of discrimination
  • 5. Value constitutional flexibility A flexible federal system with special provisions and the Sixth Schedule

The textbook's central lesson: regional aspirations are a normal part of democracy, best met by negotiation, power sharing, balanced development and a flexible federal constitution, not by suppression.

Goa: from colony to state (textbook)

  1. Portuguese rule From the sixteenth century; not ended in 1947
  2. December 1961 Army action; liberated in about two days; Union Territory
  3. Merger debate MGP wants merger with Maharashtra; UGP wants a separate Goan identity
  4. January 1967 opinion poll Majority votes to stay outside Maharashtra
  5. 1987 Goa becomes a state
  • Regional aspirations are normal in a democracy; nation-building is ongoing.
  • Negotiation and power sharing work better than suppression; Mizoram shows how.
  • Regional imbalance feeds discrimination; the flexible Constitution and the Sixth Schedule help accommodate diversity.
  • Goa was liberated in December 1961, chose to stay outside Maharashtra in the January 1967 opinion poll, and became a state in 1987.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery