- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Reading: The fair way to share
Read an original story in which a grandmother settles a quarrel fairly, answer questions, and say who spoke to whom.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Read a story and answer questions about it.
- Explain why a solution is fair.
- Say who said each line and to whom.
The panchayat in the chapter was fair to both sides. Here is another story about fairness, written for this lesson.
The story
Only one big piece of coconut barfi was left in the box, and the twins Ishaan and Isha both wanted it. 'I saw it first!' cried Ishaan. 'But I am older by five minutes!' argued Isha. Their grandmother put down her knitting. 'I have an idea,' she said to them. 'Ishaan, you will cut the barfi into two pieces. Isha, you will choose your piece first.' Ishaan picked up the knife and cut very, very carefully, measuring with his eyes again and again. He knew that if one piece was bigger, Isha would take it! Isha chose one, and both pieces were almost exactly the same size. The twins laughed and shared the barfi. 'Dadi,' said Isha, 'you are as wise as a panchayat!'
How Dadi solved the quarrel
- Both twins want the last piece
- Dadi gives a rule
- One twin cuts
- The other twin chooses first
- Both get a fair share
Let us try
Example 1: Why did Ishaan cut so carefully? Think: Isha would choose first. Answer: because if one piece was bigger, Isha would take it, so he made them equal.
Example 2: Who said 'I have an idea', and to whom? Answer: Dadi said it to Ishaan and Isha.
Being fair
Being fair means treating everyone equally and listening to both sides. If two friends, Radha and Sita, both want your spare paint box, you could let them share it, take turns, or ask them to choose a fair rule together.
A fair solution listens to both sides and gives each person an equal chance.
Try at home with a grown-up: cut and choose
- Ask a grown-up to give you and a family member one roti or a fruit to share.
- The grown-up cuts it (no knives for you), then you choose your half first.
- Talk about whether both pieces looked equal, and why that rule is fair.
For the grown-up: Do the cutting yourself; the child only chooses.
Key takeaways: a fair solution treats both sides equally. Dadi's rule (one cuts, the other chooses) made the sharing fair. Look for names and quotation marks to find who said what to whom.
Check your understanding
-
1. What did both twins want?
- A toy
- A bicycle
- A book
- The last piece of coconut barfi
Show answer
Answer: D. Only one piece of coconut barfi was left, and both wanted it.
-
2. Who cut the barfi?
- Ishaan
- Isha
- Dadi
- Their mother
Show answer
Answer: A. Dadi said Ishaan would cut and Isha would choose first.
-
3. Why was Dadi's rule fair?
- Dadi ate the barfi
- The cutter wanted equal pieces because the other chose first
- Isha got both pieces
- Nobody got any
Show answer
Answer: B. Since Isha chose first, Ishaan made the pieces equal so he would not lose out.
-
4. Who said 'you are as wise as a panchayat!', and to whom?
- Ishaan to Isha
- Dadi to Ishaan
- Isha to Dadi
- Isha to Ishaan
Show answer
Answer: C. Isha said it to Dadi, praising her wise idea.
-
5. Which is a fair way to settle who uses one paint box?
- The loudest friend keeps it
- Throw it away
- Take turns or share it
- Give it to nobody forever
Show answer
Answer: C. Taking turns or sharing gives each friend an equal chance.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.