- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Same area, different perimeter
Discover that shapes with the same area can have different perimeters and shapes with the same perimeter can have different areas, and test the claim that a bigger area always means a bigger perimeter.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Make shapes with the same area but different perimeters.
- Make shapes with the same perimeter but different areas.
- Explain why a bigger area does not always mean a bigger perimeter.
Area and perimeter are different measures. Trisha says, "I made my rectangle bigger, and its perimeter grew too. So a bigger area always means a bigger perimeter." Is she right? Let us test it.
Same area, different perimeters
Use four 1 cm squares. Arrange them in a 2 by 2 square: the perimeter is 8 cm. Arrange them in a straight row: the perimeter is 10 cm. Arrange them in an L shape: the perimeter is also 10 cm. The area is 4 square cm every time.
| Shape made of 4 squares | Area | Perimeter |
|---|---|---|
| 2 by 2 square | 4 square cm | 8 cm |
| Row of 4 | 4 square cm | 10 cm |
| L shape | 4 square cm | 10 cm |
Same perimeter, different areas
Now draw rectangles with perimeter 12 cm. A 3 by 3 square has area 9 square cm. A 2 by 4 rectangle has area 8 square cm. A 1 by 5 rectangle has area only 5 square cm. Same perimeter, different areas!
Rectangles with perimeter 12 cm
-
1 cm by 5 cm
- Long and thin
- Area 5 square cm
-
2 cm by 4 cm
- In between
- Area 8 square cm
-
3 cm by 3 cm
A square
- Area 9 square cm, the largest
Area and perimeter are different: the same area can have different perimeters, and the same perimeter can enclose different areas.
Let us try: testing Trisha's claim
A 1 by 6 rectangle has area 6 square cm and perimeter 14 cm. A 3 by 3 square has area 9 square cm and perimeter 12 cm. The area went up from 6 to 9, but the perimeter went down from 14 to 12. So Trisha's claim is not always true.
Let us try: adding one square
Start with a 2 by 2 square: area 4, perimeter 8 cm. Add one square along a side. The area becomes 5 square cm. One edge of 1 cm is now hidden, but 3 new edges appear: 8 − 1 + 3 = 10 cm.
Notice that, for a fixed perimeter, the rectangle closest to a square has the biggest area. Long thin shapes have a lot of border but little inside.
For the grown-up: square tiles, biscuits or paper squares let your child build and rebuild shapes quickly. Ask them to predict the perimeter before counting edges.
Try at home with a grown-up
Cut out 6 paper squares of the same size. Make as many different shapes as you can, with squares joined along full sides. For each shape, count the area (6 squares) and the perimeter (outer edges). Which shape has the smallest perimeter?
Key takeaways
- Area and perimeter measure different things.
- Same area can give different perimeters.
- Same perimeter can give different areas.
- A bigger area does not always mean a bigger perimeter.
Check your understanding
-
1. Four 1 cm squares are placed in a straight row. What is the perimeter?
- 8 cm
- 10 cm
- 4 cm
- 16 cm
Show answer
Answer: B. The row is 4 cm long and 1 cm wide. Perimeter = 4 + 1 + 4 + 1 = 10 cm.
-
2. A 3 by 3 square and a 2 by 4 rectangle both have perimeter 12 cm. Which is true?
- They have the same area
- The rectangle has more area
- The square has less area
- They have the same perimeter but different areas
Show answer
Answer: D. The square has area 9 square cm and the rectangle 8 square cm. The perimeters are equal, but the areas are not.
-
3. Which rectangle with perimeter 12 cm has the largest area?
- 3 cm by 3 cm
- 1 cm by 5 cm
- 2 cm by 4 cm
- They all have the same area
Show answer
Answer: A. Areas: 3 × 3 = 9, 1 × 5 = 5, 2 × 4 = 8 square cm. The square, 3 cm by 3 cm, has the largest.
-
4. Trisha says, "If the area of a shape increases, its perimeter always increases." What is correct?
- Always true
- Never true
- Not always true: area can grow while the perimeter stays the same or shrinks
- True only for squares
Show answer
Answer: C. A 1 by 6 rectangle (area 6, perimeter 14 cm) changed to a 3 by 3 square (area 9, perimeter 12 cm) gains area but loses perimeter.
-
5. Which shape made of four 1 cm squares has the smallest perimeter?
- A row of 4
- An L shape
- A T shape
- A 2 by 2 square
Show answer
Answer: D. The 2 by 2 square has perimeter 8 cm. The row, L and T shapes all have 10 cm.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.