• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Participatory democracy and why cities need their own government

Explain participatory democracy, see why governing a city is more complex than governing a village, and place urban local bodies in India's pyramid of government.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain what participatory democracy means.
  • Give reasons why cities are more complex to govern than villages.
  • Place urban local bodies and Panchayati Raj institutions on the pyramid of government.

The last chapter showed how villages govern themselves through Panchayati Raj. This chapter moves to towns and cities. Its big questions are: what are urban local bodies and what do they do, and why are they important for governance and democracy?

Participatory democracy

In a democracy, good governance aims to empower citizens so that they can actively take part in running their country - at the rural, regional, urban, State or national level. This broad idea is called participatory democracy. It is not enough to vote once every few years; citizens also take part in local decisions and look after their area.

Participatory democracy: good governance empowers citizens to take an active part in how their village, town, city, State and country are run.

This idea goes back to the making of the Constitution. In the Constituent Assembly debates in October 1949, a member, Rustom K. Sidhwa, argued that full local bodies should be set up at once so that people could learn, in their own towns and villages, what administration, voting rights, powers and privileges really mean.

Why cities are more complex

A big city such as Kolkata, Chennai or Mumbai has far more people than a village, living close together, speaking many languages and belonging to many communities. It needs huge systems for water supply, drainage, roads, traffic, waste collection and public health. People are also more independent and may not even know their neighbours. Because urban life is more complex and diverse, urban governance also needs to be more complex - though this chapter keeps to the basic principles.

The pyramid of government

Picture India's system of government as a pyramid. The national (Union) government is at the top, State governments below it, and local government at the base, closest to the people. At the base, the pyramid has two sides: the rural side (Panchayati Raj) and the urban side (urban local bodies).

Two sides of local government

  • Rural: Panchayati Raj
    • Zila Panchayat (district)
    • Panchayat Samiti (block)
    • Gram Panchayat (village)
    • Gram Sabha (the village's voters)
  • Urban: urban local bodies
    • Municipal Corporation, Municipal Council or Nagar Panchayat
    • Ward Committee
    • People of the ward
Both sit at the base of the pyramid, below the State and Union governments.

Worked example 1: comparing a village and a city

Question: why does a city need more complex government than a village? Step 1 - size: a city has lakhs of people, a village a few hundred or thousand. Step 2 - services: a city must manage piped water, sewers, many roads, traffic and tonnes of waste each day. Step 3 - diversity: people from many regions, communities and languages live side by side. Conclusion: more people, more services and more diversity call for a bigger and more layered system of local government.

Worked example 2: reading the pyramid

Question: on the urban side of the pyramid, which unit is closest to the people, and what is its rural counterpart? Step 1: at the very base of the urban side are the people of the ward, organised through a ward committee. Step 2: on the rural side, the base is the Gram Sabha, the village's voters. Answer: the ward and its people on the urban side correspond to the Gram Sabha and the village on the rural side - both are where citizens take part directly.

Key takeaways: Participatory democracy means empowering citizens to take part in governance at every level. Cities are larger, more diverse and need many more services than villages, so their local government is more complex. In the pyramid of government, local government forms the base, with Panchayati Raj on the rural side and urban local bodies on the urban side.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What is 'participatory democracy'?

    1. Rule by a single leader
    2. A system where only judges decide
    3. Good governance that empowers citizens to take an active part at every level
    4. Voting only in national elections
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Participatory democracy means citizens are empowered to actively take part in their country's functioning - rural, urban, State or national.

  2. 2. Why does a large city need more complex local government than a village?

    1. Because cities have fewer people
    2. Because cities are larger and more diverse and need many more services
    3. Because cities have no elections
    4. Because villages have no needs
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Cities have far more people, more diversity and need large systems for water, drains, roads and waste, so their governance must be more complex.

  3. 3. On the pyramid of government, where are urban local bodies placed?

    1. At the base, as local government, on the urban side
    2. At the top, above the Union government
    3. In the judiciary
    4. Between the State and the Union government
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Local government is the base of the pyramid. Urban local bodies form its urban side, and Panchayati Raj its rural side.

  4. 4. Which unit on the rural side corresponds most closely to the 'people of the ward' on the urban side?

    1. The Zila Panchayat
    2. The State Assembly
    3. The Panchayat Samiti
    4. The Gram Sabha
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Both the Gram Sabha and the people of the ward are at the very base, where citizens take part directly.

  5. 5. Rustom K. Sidhwa, speaking in the Constituent Assembly in 1949, wanted local bodies to be formed so that:

    1. People could learn about administration, rights and powers in their own towns and villages
    2. The national government could be abolished
    3. Only cities would have elections
    4. Villages would be merged into cities
    Show answer

    Answer: A. He argued for local bodies so people would know, in a small sphere in their own town or village, what administration, voting rights and powers mean.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery