• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

How the three sectors depend on each other: the AMUL story

Use the story of the AMUL milk cooperative and the making of a textbook to show how the primary, secondary and tertiary sectors are interconnected and support each other.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain what a cooperative is and why the farmers of Anand formed one.
  • Identify primary, secondary and tertiary activities in the AMUL story and in the making of a book.
  • Explain what would happen if one sector stopped working.

The three sectors are not separate worlds. Natural raw materials become finished products only when all three work together. The textbook shows this through a real story from Anand district in Gujarat.

The problem: milk and middlemen

In the early 1940s, dairy farmers in Anand district had to walk or cycle in the heat to sell milk in nearby villages, hurrying before it spoiled. For all this effort they earned little. Many depended on middlemen, people who buy goods from producers and sell them to consumers, charging for this service. The middlemen bought milk in bulk at very low prices, and the farmers often felt cheated.

The solution: a cooperative

The farmers took their problem to the national leader Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, who advised them to form a cooperative so that they could collect, process and sell their milk themselves without middlemen. AMUL (Anand Milk Union Limited) was set up in 1946 under the leadership of Tribhuvandas Patel, a lawyer and freedom fighter, and Dr Varghese Kurien, an engineer then working at a dairy in Mumbai. Farmers, including women, now controlled production, pasteurisation and sale, shared the work, and saw their incomes rise. As the cooperative grew, it set up a factory in Anand to make butter and milk powder; today it makes many products in plants across India, sells them all over the country and exports them too.

A cooperative is a group of people who voluntarily come together to meet their economic and social needs in a formal way; they own it, and decisions are taken by the members together.

Two more terms: pasteurisation is heating milk to a set temperature to kill harmful bacteria so it keeps longer; retail is selling goods in small quantities to the people who will use them. There are many other milk cooperatives in India, such as Nandini (Karnataka), Aavin (Tamil Nadu), Verka (Punjab) and Sudha (Bihar).

From farm to plate: the three sectors in the milk story

  1. Primary: milking Farmers milk their cows and buffaloes; milk comes directly from livestock.
  2. Secondary: processing Milk is pasteurised and made into butter, ghee, cheese and milk powder in factories.
  3. Tertiary: transport Lorries, trucks, railways, air and shipping carry the products.
  4. Tertiary: trade and retail Products are sold in shops across India and exported.

Worked example 1: labelling the stages of a textbook

Question: how is the book you study made? Primary: trees are grown and cut, and wood is obtained from the forest. Secondary: the wood is turned into pulp, the pulp into paper, and the paper is printed and bound into books. Tertiary: the books are transported, stored and sold in shops or delivered to schools. Conclusion: none of this would be possible without all three sectors working together.

According to the textbook, recycling used paper helps too: recycling one tonne of paper saves about 17 trees and 2.5 cubic metres of landfill space, and uses 70 per cent less energy and water than making new paper from wood pulp. Using paper carefully in school is a small way to protect forests.

Worked example 2: what if one sector stopped?

Case: a transport strike stops all trucks for a week. Effect on the tertiary sector: shops run short of milk products. Effect on the secondary sector: the dairy plant fills up with products it cannot send out, so it must slow down. Effect on the primary sector: the plant cannot accept as much milk, so farmers struggle to sell it, and fresh milk may spoil. Conclusion: a break in one sector spreads to the others - the sectors are interdependent.

How each sector depends on the others
SectorDepends onFor
PrimaryTertiaryTransport to markets, banks, repair of tractors
SecondaryPrimaryRaw materials such as milk, wood and cotton
SecondaryTertiaryTransport, banking, electricity repairs, sales
TertiaryPrimary and secondaryGoods to transport, store and sell

Key takeaways: The three sectors are interconnected. In the AMUL story, set up in 1946 at Anand under Tribhuvandas Patel and Dr Varghese Kurien after Sardar Patel's advice to form a cooperative, milking is primary, making butter and milk powder is secondary, and transport and retail are tertiary. The making of a textbook follows the same chain. If one sector stops, the others are affected.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why did the dairy farmers of Anand want to stop depending on middlemen?

    1. Middlemen paid very high prices
    2. Middlemen bought their milk at very low prices and the farmers felt cheated
    3. Middlemen made butter for free
    4. Middlemen were part of the cooperative
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Middlemen bought milk in bulk at meagre prices; the farmers felt cheated and harassed, so they sought another way.

  2. 2. Who advised the farmers to form a cooperative?

    1. Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel
    2. Kautilya
    3. Dr A.P.J. Abdul Kalam
    4. Swami Vivekananda
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The farmers approached Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, who advised them to form a cooperative and stop relying on middlemen.

  3. 3. In the AMUL story, making butter and milk powder in a factory is which kind of activity?

    1. Primary
    2. Tertiary
    3. Non-economic
    4. Secondary
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Processing milk from one form into another (butter, milk powder, ghee, cheese) in factories is a secondary activity.

  4. 4. When was AMUL set up?

    1. In the early 1940s
    2. In 1950
    3. In 1946
    4. In 1688
    Show answer

    Answer: C. AMUL was set up in 1946 under Tribhuvandas Patel and Dr Varghese Kurien. The early 1940s is when the farmers' problems with middlemen are described.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The three economic sectors are interdependent. Reason (R): Raw materials from the primary sector are processed by the secondary sector and delivered and sold through tertiary services.

    1. A is true but R is false
    2. A is false but R is true
    3. Both A and R are true, and R explains A
    4. Both A and R are false
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Both are true, and R shows why A is true: each sector needs the others to turn natural materials into products people can buy.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery