• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Multiplying integers with tokens

Model products such as 3 × (−4), (−3) × 4 and (−3) × (−4) with tokens in a bag, and explain why a negative times a negative gives a positive.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Use the bag-of-tokens model to multiply a positive integer by a negative one.
  • Model a negative multiplier as taking tokens out, using zero pairs.
  • Explain why the product of two negative integers is positive.

We know that 3 × 4 means 4 added three times. But what could 3 × (−4) or (−3) × (−4) mean? Tokens give a clear answer, and the answer explains a rule that surprises many people: a negative times a negative is positive.

The bag model

Start every multiplication with an empty bag. In a × b, the first number a is the multiplier and the second number b is the multiplicand.

  • The multiplicand says which tokens are moved each time: b greens if b is positive, or the matching number of reds if b is negative.
  • The multiplier says how many times, and in which direction: if it is positive we put tokens in; if it is negative we take tokens out.
  • To take out tokens that are not in the bag, first put in enough zero pairs. Zero pairs do not change the value.

In a × b, the multiplier a says how many times and whether to put in (a positive) or take out (a negative); the multiplicand b says which tokens.

The four cases

3 × 4: put 4 greens in, 3 times. The bag holds 12 greens, so 3 × 4 = 12.

3 × (−4): put 4 reds in, 3 times. The bag holds 12 reds, so 3 × (−4) = −12.

(−3) × 4: take 4 greens out, 3 times. The bag is empty, so each time we first put in 4 zero pairs and then remove the 4 greens, leaving 4 reds. After 3 rounds there are 12 reds, so (−3) × 4 = −12.

(−3) × (−4): take 4 reds out, 3 times. Each time we put in 4 zero pairs and remove the 4 reds, leaving 4 greens. After 3 rounds there are 12 greens, so (−3) × (−4) = +12.

Multiplying with tokens: four cases

  • 3 × 4
    • Put 4 greens in, 3 times
    • 12 greens: +12
  • 3 × (−4)
    • Put 4 reds in, 3 times
    • 12 reds: −12
  • (−3) × 4
    • Take 4 greens out, 3 times, using zero pairs
    • 12 reds left: −12
  • (−3) × (−4)
    • Take 4 reds out, 3 times, using zero pairs
    • 12 greens left: +12

Worked example 1: (−5) × 2

  1. The multiplier −5 is negative, so we take tokens out, 5 times. The multiplicand 2 is positive, so we take out 2 greens each time.
  2. Round 1: the bag is empty, so put in 2 zero pairs (2 greens, 2 reds), then remove the 2 greens. 2 reds remain.
  3. Repeat four more times. Each round leaves 2 more reds: 2, 4, 6, 8, 10 reds.
  4. 10 reds = −10, so (−5) × 2 = −10.

Worked example 2: (−2) × (−6)

  1. The multiplier −2 says take out, 2 times; the multiplicand −6 says 6 reds each time.
  2. Round 1: put in 6 zero pairs, remove the 6 reds. 6 greens remain.
  3. Round 2: put in 6 more zero pairs, remove 6 reds. Now 12 greens remain.
  4. 12 greens = +12, so (−2) × (−6) = 12.

Another way to see a negative multiplier

Taking out 2 greens has the same effect as putting in 2 reds, because removing a number is the same as adding its inverse. So (−5) × 2 can also be done by putting 2 reds in, 5 times, giving −10 again. And taking out reds is the same as putting in greens, which is why two negatives give a positive.

Same magnitude, different signs
ProductToken actionResult
4 × (−2)Put 2 reds in, 4 times−8
(−4) × 2Take 2 greens out, 4 times−8
(−4) × (−2)Take 2 reds out, 4 times8
4 × 2Put 2 greens in, 4 times8

Key takeaways: a positive multiplier puts tokens in; a negative multiplier takes them out after adding zero pairs. Taking out greens leaves reds (a negative answer), and taking out reds leaves greens (a positive answer). The magnitude of the product is always the product of the magnitudes.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Using tokens, what is 6 × (−3)?

    1. 18
    2. −18
    3. −9
    4. 3
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Put 3 reds into the bag 6 times: 6 × 3 = 18 reds, which is −18.

  2. 2. What is (−4) × (−5)?

    1. −20
    2. −9
    3. 20
    4. 9
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Take 5 reds out, 4 times, adding zero pairs first each time. Each round leaves 5 greens, so 4 × 5 = 20 greens remain: (−4) × (−5) = 20.

  3. 3. In the token model, how do we show (−3) × 5?

    1. Put 5 greens into the bag 3 times
    2. Put 3 reds into the bag 5 times
    3. Take 3 greens out of the bag 5 times
    4. Take 5 greens out of the bag 3 times, after adding zero pairs
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The multiplier −3 means take out, 3 times; the multiplicand 5 means 5 greens each time. Zero pairs are added first, and the reds left behind give −15.

  4. 4. Given that 23 × 17 = 391, what is (−23) × 17?

    1. −391
    2. 391
    3. −40
    4. 6
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The magnitude stays 23 × 17 = 391. One factor is negative and one positive, so the product is −391.

  5. 5. Why does taking reds out of the bag give a positive answer?

    1. Because red tokens are worth more than green ones
    2. Because removing a red from a zero pair leaves a green behind
    3. Because the bag was full of greens at the start
    4. Because reds and greens cannot be in the bag together
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The bag starts empty, so we add zero pairs first. Removing the red token of each zero pair leaves its green partner, so the result is positive.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery