• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Mind the mistake, make your own equations, and a pinch of history

Spot and correct common mistakes in solving equations, build equations with a given solution, use Brahmagupta's rule for Ax + B = Cx + D, and learn how algebra grew from bījagaṇita.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Find and correct common errors in worked solutions of equations.
  • Build chains of equations that share a given solution.
  • Use Brahmagupta's rule x = (D − B) ÷ (A − C) and describe the Indian roots of algebra.

Checking someone else's working, including your own, is one of the best ways to become accurate. This lesson collects the most common slips, shows how to build equations backwards from an answer, and ends with the long history of algebra in India and beyond.

Mind the mistake, mend the mistake

Common slips and their corrections
Wrong workingThe mistakeCorrect working
5x + 7 = 22, so 5x = 22 + 7+7 crossed over without changing sign5x = 22 − 7 = 15, so x = 3
3x + 2 = 20, so x + 2 = 20 ÷ 3Divided only part of the LHS by 33x = 18, so x = 6
4(2y + 1) = 36, so 8y + 1 = 36Did not multiply the 1 by 48y + 4 = 36, 8y = 32, so y = 4
9 − 2z = 3, so 2z = 9 + 3Moved the 3 with the wrong sign9 − 3 = 2z, so 2z = 6 and z = 3
6x = 18, so x = 18 − 6Subtracted instead of dividingx = 18 ÷ 6 = 3

A quick substitution catches every one of these: in the first row, x = 29/5 from the wrong working gives 5 × 29/5 + 7 = 36, not 22.

Equations with a chosen solution

Start from y = 4 and do the same thing to both sides again and again. Every equation in the chain still has the solution y = 4.

A chain of equations, all solved by y = 4

  1. y = 4 Start
  2. 3y = 12 Multiply both sides by 3
  3. 3y + 5 = 17 Add 5 to both sides
  4. 5y + 5 = 2y + 17 Add 2y to both sides

The last step puts the unknown on both sides: adding 2y to both sides of 3y + 5 = 17 gives 5y + 5 = 2y + 17. Check with y = 4: LHS = 20 + 5 = 25 and RHS = 8 + 17 = 25. Reading the chain upwards solves the equation, because each step is undone by its inverse.

Brahmagupta's rule

Many equations have the form Ax + B = Cx + D, where A, B, C and D are known numbers. Subtract Cx and B from both sides: (A − C)x = D − B. Dividing gives a ready-made rule, which Brahmagupta described in his Brāhmasphuṭasiddhānta (628 CE).

If Ax + B = Cx + D, then x = (D − B) ÷ (A − C), provided A ≠ C.

Worked example 1: using the rule

For 7y + 5 = 3y + 29: A = 7, B = 5, C = 3, D = 29. So y = (29 − 5) ÷ (7 − 3) = 24 ÷ 4 = 6, the same answer as solving step by step.

Worked example 2: an old-style puzzle

Indian texts such as Bhāskarācārya's Bījagaṇita (1150 CE) pose puzzles about traders with animals and money. Here is one in that style: one trader has ₹500 and 4 cows; another has 9 cows but owes ₹250. If they are equally rich and all cows cost the same, what is the price of a cow? Let it be ₹x. Then 500 + 4x = 9x − 250. By the rule: x = (−250 − 500) ÷ (4 − 9) = (−750) ÷ (−5) = 150. Check: 500 + 600 = 1,100 and 1,350 − 250 = 1,100.

A pinch of history

In India, solving problems with unknown numbers was called bījagaṇita. Bīja means seed: the answer lies hidden in the unknown as a tree lies in a seed. Brahmagupta explained how to add, subtract and multiply unknowns written with symbols. Indian mathematicians named unknowns with syllables such as yā (short for yāvat-tāvat, "as much as") and kā, nī (from words for colours), much as we use x and y today.

Indian mathematical ideas reached Arabic scholars around the 8th century. Al-Khwarizmi wrote a book around 825 CE whose title includes al-jabr, meaning restoring or balancing. Translated into Latin in the 12th century, that word gave us algebra.

Key takeaways: check each step's sign and make sure you divide or multiply the whole side. Substituting your answer exposes any slip. Doing the same thing to both sides of y = 4 builds equations with that solution. For Ax + B = Cx + D, x = (D − B) ÷ (A − C).

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A student writes: 5x + 7 = 22, so 5x = 22 + 7. What is the mistake?

    1. Nothing is wrong
    2. The 7 should change sign when it moves: 5x = 22 − 7
    3. The 5 should have been moved first
    4. Both sides should be multiplied by 7
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Moving +7 to the other side makes it −7, so 5x = 15 and x = 3. Check: 5 × 3 + 7 = 22.

  2. 2. Use Brahmagupta's rule to solve 5x + 4 = 3x + 10.

    1. x = 7
    2. x = 2
    3. x = 1.75
    4. x = 3
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A = 5, B = 4, C = 3, D = 10. x = (10 − 4) ÷ (5 − 3) = 6 ÷ 2 = 3. Check: 15 + 4 = 19 and 9 + 10 = 19.

  3. 3. Starting from y = 5, which equation could appear in a chain made by doing the same thing to both sides?

    1. 3y + 2 = 17
    2. 3y + 2 = 15
    3. 2y = 12
    4. y + 5 = 5
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Multiply both sides of y = 5 by 3 to get 3y = 15, then add 2 to get 3y + 2 = 17. Substituting y = 5 confirms 15 + 2 = 17.

  4. 4. Given 4k + 1 = 13, what is 8k + 2?

    1. 24
    2. 15
    3. 26
    4. 16
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 8k + 2 = 2 × (4k + 1). Multiplying both sides of 4k + 1 = 13 by 2 gives 8k + 2 = 26.

  5. 5. Which word gave us the name 'algebra'?

    1. bīja
    2. al-jabr
    3. yāvat-tāvat
    4. rūpa
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Al-Khwarizmi's book title included al-jabr (restoring or balancing), which became 'algebra'. Bīja is the Sanskrit word for seed, in bījagaṇita.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery