• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Thinking like a scientist: asking good questions and fair tests

Turn an answer back into interesting questions, tell testable questions from untestable ones, and plan a fair test that changes only one thing at a time.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Practise the 'question the answer' game to build curiosity.
  • Decide whether a question can be tested by observation or experiment.
  • Plan a fair test by changing one thing and keeping everything else the same.

In school we are usually given questions and asked for answers. Scientists often work the other way round: the hardest and most important part is asking a good question. A well-asked question tells you what to observe and what to test. This lesson is about building that skill.

The 'question the answer' game

Here is a fun way to practise. Someone gives you an answer, and you invent as many different questions as you can that could lead to it. There are no wrong questions; the aim is to stretch your imagination. Suppose the answer is 'Put it in the shade'. Possible questions are: 'My chocolate is melting, what should I do?', 'How can I keep my bicycle seat from getting too hot?', 'Where should I keep the curd so it does not turn sour quickly?' Each question leads to a different piece of science: melting, heating by sunlight and the effect of warmth on curd.

Worked example 1: one answer, many questions

Answer: 'Add a little salt.' Questions that could lead to it: (1) 'How can I make ice melt faster on a cold road?' (2) 'How can I make the dal taste better?' (3) 'How can I make an egg float in a glass of water?' Working through the science: salt lowers the temperature at which ice melts, salt changes taste, and salty water is denser than fresh water, which helps an egg float. One short answer has opened three different topics. Notice that the best questions are specific and could lead to a test.

Testable and untestable questions

A testable question can be answered by observing, measuring or doing an experiment. 'Does a seed sprout faster in warm or cold water?' is testable: you can try it. 'Which flower is the most beautiful?' is not testable, because the answer depends on personal taste. Science deals with testable questions.

Testable or not?

  • Testable
    • Can be checked by observing or measuring
    • Different people doing it carefully get similar results
    • Example: does salt dissolve faster in hot water?
  • Not testable by science
    • Depends on opinion or taste
    • No measurement can settle it
    • Example: is blue a nicer colour than green?

Fair tests

Suppose you want to know whether sunlight helps a money plant cutting grow roots. You put one cutting in a glass of water on a sunny window and another in a dark cupboard. If the window glass also has more water and a different kind of cutting, you cannot tell which change caused any difference. A fair test changes only one thing (the thing you are testing) and keeps everything else the same.

Three parts of a fair test
Part of the testMeaningIn the money plant test
The thing you changeThe one factor being testedLight: sunny window or dark cupboard
The thing you measureThe result you observeNumber and length of roots after 10 days
Things kept the sameEverything else that could affect the resultSame kind and size of cutting, same glass, same amount of water

Worked example 2: fixing an unfair test

Ravi wants to find out whether hot water dissolves sugar faster. He stirs 1 spoon of sugar in a cup of hot water and 3 spoons in a cup of cold water, and finds the hot cup clears first. Is this fair? No. He changed two things: the temperature and the amount of sugar. The fair version: take two identical cups with the same amount of water, one hot and one cold (with an adult handling the hot water), add exactly 1 spoon of sugar to each, stir both the same way and time how long the sugar takes to disappear. Now only the temperature differs, so any difference in time can be linked to temperature.

A fair test changes only one thing at a time and keeps everything else the same.

Why repeat a test?

Even a fair test can give an odd result once, because of small mistakes in timing or measuring. Scientists repeat a test several times and see whether the results agree. If three repeats give similar results, we can trust them more. And as the chapter points out, even an experiment that confirms what we expected often raises new questions that need more experiments.

Key takeaways: asking good questions is as important as finding answers. Testable questions can be settled by observation or experiment; questions of taste cannot. A fair test changes one factor, measures one result and keeps everything else the same. Repeating a test makes the result more trustworthy, and every result can lead to new questions.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which question can be tested by a science experiment?

    1. Do bean seeds sprout faster in moist cotton or in dry cotton?
    2. Is a rose prettier than a lotus?
    3. Which festival is the most enjoyable?
    4. Is cricket a better game than football?
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Sprouting speed can be observed and measured, so this question is testable. The other questions depend on personal opinion.

  2. 2. Priya tests whether the colour of a cloth affects how warm it gets in the sun. Which of these should she keep the SAME for both cloths?

    1. The colour of the cloths
    2. Nothing; everything can be different
    3. Only the colour of the thermometer
    4. The size and kind of cloth and the time left in the sun
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Colour is the one thing she is changing. For a fair test, everything else (size, material, time in the sun, place) must be kept the same.

  3. 3. A test changes both the type of soil and the amount of water given to two plants. What is wrong with it?

    1. Nothing is wrong; changing more things gives faster answers
    2. Two things are changed, so the cause of any difference cannot be known
    3. Plants do not need water
    4. Soil cannot be tested
    Show answer

    Answer: B. If two factors change, a difference in growth could be due to either one. A fair test changes only one factor at a time.

  4. 4. Why do scientists usually repeat an experiment several times?

    1. To check that the result is reliable and not due to a one-time mistake
    2. To use up extra materials
    3. Because the first result is always wrong
    4. To change the question each time
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Small errors can affect a single trial. If repeated trials agree, the result can be trusted more.

  5. 5. In the 'question the answer' game, the answer is 'Keep it in a closed box'. Which question fits best and also leads to science?

    1. What is 5 + 5?
    2. What is your name?
    3. How can I stop my biscuits from becoming soft in humid weather?
    4. Which day comes after Monday?
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A closed box keeps moist air away from biscuits, so they stay crisp. This question links the answer to a real scientific idea (moisture in air); the others do not lead to it at all.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery