- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The moving night sky: stars, the Pole Star and Aryabhata
Explain why the stars and Moon appear to rise in the East and set in the West, why the Pole Star seems fixed while the Big Dipper circles it, and describe Aryabhata's explanation.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the apparent motion of stars and the Moon across the night sky.
- Explain why the Pole Star appears almost stationary and other stars seem to move around it.
- Describe Aryabhata's boat comparison and his value for the time of one rotation.
If the Earth's rotation makes the Sun appear to move, the same should be true for the stars and the Moon at night. Careful observation over a few hours shows exactly that.
Stars and the Moon also seem to move
Because the Earth rotates from West to East, the stars appear to rise in the East, move across the sky and set in the West, just like the Sun. The Moon also appears to rise in the East and set in the West for the same reason. None of this is the stars actually racing around us; it is our own spinning Earth.
The Pole Star and the Big Dipper
The Earth's axis, extended into the sky in the Northern Hemisphere, points very close to the Pole Star (Dhruva Tara). Because of this, the Pole Star appears to stay almost in one place, while all the other stars seem to turn in circles around it. On an evening between March and May, find the Big Dipper (Saptarishi) in the northern sky and sketch its position compared with the Pole Star, or with a tree or building if the Pole Star is hard to see. Two hours later, sketch it again, and again two hours after that: the Big Dipper has moved round, circling the Pole Star.
Tracking the Big Dipper on one night
- Early evening Sketch the Big Dipper and note the time.
- Two hours later It has turned part of the way round the Pole Star.
- Two more hours later It has turned further in the same direction.
- Conclusion Stars appear to circle the Pole Star because the Earth rotates.
The Pole Star appears nearly fixed because the Earth's axis points almost towards it; all other stars appear to circle around it as the Earth rotates.
Worked example 1: how far do the stars turn?
The stars appear to make one full circle (360°) around the Pole Star in about 24 hours. About how many degrees do they turn in 1 hour, and in 4 hours? Working: 360° ÷ 24 = 15° per hour. In 4 hours: 15 × 4 = 60°. So between sketches 2 hours apart, the Big Dipper turns about 15 × 2 = 30°, a clearly visible change.
Photographers who keep a camera's shutter open for a long time at night capture each star's apparent motion as a curved line. These arcs, all centred near the Pole Star, are called star trails.
Aryabhata's insight
Ancient Indian astronomers carefully observed the daily apparent motion of the Sun, Moon, planets and stars. Aryabhata, a great mathematician and astronomer, wrote the Aryabhatiya around the fifth century CE. He compared our view of the sky to a person in a boat moving forward, who sees the trees on the stationary bank appear to move backwards. In the same way, he explained, the fixed stars appear to move westwards because the Earth turns. His value for the time of one full rotation of the Earth, in modern units about 23 hours 56 minutes 4.1 seconds, is remarkably close to the value accepted today.
Worked example 2: comparing with 24 hours
How much shorter than 24 hours is Aryabhata's value of 23 h 56 min 4.1 s? Working: 24 h = 23 h 60 min. Difference = 23 h 60 min − 23 h 56 min 4.1 s = 3 min 55.9 s, which is about 4 minutes. That small difference is real: one rotation measured against the stars takes about 4 minutes less than 24 hours, while our 24-hour day is measured from noon to noon by the Sun. It also explains why a given star rises about 4 minutes earlier each night.
Real and apparent motion
-
What really moves
- The Earth rotates West to East
- The observer turns with the Earth
-
What appears to move
- Sun, Moon and stars rise in the East and set in the West
- Stars circle the Pole Star
- Star trails in long photographs
Key takeaways: because the Earth rotates from West to East, the stars and the Moon appear to rise in the East and set in the West. The Earth's axis points almost at the Pole Star, so it seems fixed while other stars, such as the Big Dipper, appear to circle it at about 15° each hour. Aryabhata explained this apparent motion with a moving-boat comparison and gave a very accurate time for one rotation.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why do stars appear to rise in the East and set in the West?
- Because the Earth rotates from West to East
- Because the stars orbit the Earth every night
- Because the Moon pulls them westwards
- Because the Sun pushes them
Show answer
Answer: A. The apparent motion of the stars is caused by the Earth's rotation, just as for the Sun.
-
2. Why does the Pole Star appear almost stationary in the sky?
- It is the closest star to the Earth
- It is the brightest star
- It moves at the same speed as the Earth
- The Earth's axis of rotation points very close to it
Show answer
Answer: D. Since the axis points almost at the Pole Star, it hardly seems to move while other stars appear to circle it.
-
3. The Big Dipper is sketched at 8 pm and again at 10 pm on the same night. What is observed?
- It is in exactly the same place
- It has moved part of the way round the Pole Star
- It has disappeared for ever
- It has moved to the southern sky
Show answer
Answer: B. As the Earth rotates, the Big Dipper appears to circle the Pole Star, about 15° each hour.
-
4. About how many degrees do the stars appear to turn around the Pole Star in 3 hours?
- 45°
- 15°
- 90°
- 360°
Show answer
Answer: A. They appear to turn 360° in about 24 hours, which is 15° per hour; 15 × 3 = 45°.
-
5. Which comparison did Aryabhata use to explain the apparent motion of the stars?
- A ball rolling down a hill
- A pendulum swinging in a church
- A person in a moving boat sees objects on the bank appear to move backwards
- A candle burning in a room
Show answer
Answer: C. He explained that just as a boat traveller sees stationary objects move backwards, people on the rotating Earth see the stationary stars move westwards.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.