• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Natural indicators: red rose, turmeric and onion

Prepare and use natural indicators such as red rose extract and turmeric paper, explain what each can and cannot tell you, and describe how an onion works as a smell (olfactory) indicator.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe how to prepare a red rose extract and turmeric paper safely.
  • Predict the colours of red rose extract and turmeric with acidic, basic and neutral samples.
  • Explain what an olfactory indicator is and why it helps a person who cannot see colours.

If you have no litmus at home, your kitchen and garden can still help. Many flowers, fruits and spices contain coloured substances that change colour with acids and bases. These are natural indicators. This lesson looks at three: red rose petals, turmeric and onion.

Red rose extract

Making a red rose indicator

  1. Collect fallen petals Pick up petals that have dropped; do not pluck flowers.
  2. Wash and crush Wash a fistful of petals and crush them in a mortar and pestle.
  3. Soak in hot water Cover with hot water in a tumbler, with an adult's help, and put a lid on.
  4. Wait 5-10 minutes The water takes on the colour of the petals.
  5. Filter The clear coloured liquid (the filtrate) is the indicator.

When a few drops of the extract are mixed with an acidic sample such as lemon juice, it shows a red colour. With a basic sample such as soap solution, it turns green. A neutral sample does not change its colour. The groups match exactly with the litmus groups, so red rose extract is also an acid-base indicator. Extracts of beetroot, purple cabbage, jamun, red hibiscus (gudhal) and turmeric can be prepared in a similar way.

Turmeric paper

Make a paste of turmeric (haldi) with a little water, dip a filter paper in it until it is yellow, let it dry and cut it into strips. This is turmeric paper. A drop of a basic sample turns it red (reddish-brown). A drop of an acidic or neutral sample leaves it yellow.

Colours of indicators in this chapter
IndicatorIn acidicIn basicIn neutral
Blue litmusRedBlue (no change)Blue (no change)
Red litmusRed (no change)BlueRed (no change)
Red rose extractRedGreenNo change
TurmericYellow (no change)RedYellow (no change)

Turmeric turns red in basic solutions but stays yellow in acidic and neutral ones, so it can find bases but cannot tell an acid from a neutral substance.

Worked example 1: what can turmeric tell you?

Three jars in a kitchen hold lemon juice, lime water and salt solution, but their labels have come off. Only turmeric paper is available. Working: put a drop from each jar on a separate strip. The one that turns the paper red is lime water (basic). The other two leave the paper yellow, because one is acidic (lemon juice) and one is neutral (salt solution). Turmeric alone cannot separate them. But you can be clever: put a drop of the lime water on a fresh strip so that the spot turns red, then add a few drops of one of the other liquids to that red spot. Lemon juice turns the red spot back to yellow, because it cancels the basic nature of the lime water; salt solution leaves it red. You will learn why in the next lesson.

Worked example 2: the secret message

At a science fair, a plain white sheet is sprayed with a liquid and red words suddenly appear. How could this work? Working: suppose the message was written earlier with soap solution (basic), which dries almost invisibly. The spray contains turmeric solution. Where turmeric meets the dried soap, it turns red; everywhere else it stays yellow, so the words appear in red on a yellow sheet. Writing with lemon juice would not work with turmeric, because turmeric does not change colour with acids.

Olfactory (smell) indicators

Some substances change their smell rather than their colour. These are called olfactory indicators. Keep strips of clean cloth with finely chopped onion in a closed container overnight so they take on the onion smell. Put a basic solution such as baking soda solution on one strip: the onion smell fades or disappears. Put an acidic solution such as tamarind water on another: the onion smell stays. An olfactory indicator is useful for a person who cannot see colours, for example someone who is visually impaired or colour-blind.

Onion strip as an olfactory indicator

  • With an acidic solution
    • Onion smell remains
    • Example: tamarind water
  • With a basic solution
    • Onion smell fades or disappears
    • Example: baking soda solution

Key takeaways: many flowers, fruits and spices are natural indicators. Red rose extract turns red in acids and green in bases. Turmeric turns red only in bases, so it cannot separate acids from neutral substances. Onion is an olfactory indicator: its smell disappears in a basic solution. Prepare extracts with hot water only with an adult present, and use only fallen petals.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Red rose extract is added to a sample and turns green. The sample is:

    1. Acidic
    2. Basic
    3. Neutral
    4. Pure water
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Red rose extract shows red in acidic solutions and green in basic solutions, so green means the sample is basic.

  2. 2. Turmeric paper stays yellow when a drop of a liquid is put on it. What can you conclude?

    1. The liquid is definitely acidic
    2. The liquid is definitely basic
    3. The liquid is definitely neutral
    4. The liquid is either acidic or neutral
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Turmeric changes colour (to red) only with bases. Staying yellow means the liquid is not basic, but it could be acidic or neutral.

  3. 3. Which liquid could be used to write an invisible message that turns red when sprayed with turmeric solution?

    1. Lemon juice
    2. Sugar solution
    3. Vinegar
    4. Soap solution
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Turmeric turns red only with basic substances. Soap solution is basic; lemon juice and vinegar are acidic and sugar solution is neutral, so they would leave turmeric yellow.

  4. 4. An onion-scented cloth strip loses its onion smell when a drop of a solution is added. The solution is most likely:

    1. Acidic, such as tamarind water
    2. Basic, such as baking soda solution
    3. Neutral, such as sugar solution
    4. Acidic, such as vinegar
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Onion is an olfactory indicator: its smell fades in a basic solution and stays in an acidic one.

  5. 5. Why is an olfactory indicator helpful to a visually impaired student?

    1. It glows in the dark
    2. It changes the taste of the substance
    3. It shows the nature of a substance by a change in smell instead of colour
    4. It makes a sound in acids
    Show answer

    Answer: C. An olfactory indicator works through smell, so a person who cannot see a colour change can still identify the nature of a substance.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Neutralisation: when acids meet bases

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery