- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Both changes at once; reversible and desirable changes
Explain how a burning candle shows both physical and chemical changes, sort changes into those that can and cannot be reversed, and judge whether a change is desirable or undesirable.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Identify the physical and chemical changes in a burning candle.
- Sort changes into those that can be reversed and those that cannot.
- Give examples of desirable and undesirable changes, including effects on the environment.
Real events are often more interesting than neat categories. A single process can involve both kinds of change, and changes can also be sorted in other useful ways: can they be undone, and do we want them?
A burning candle
Watch a candle closely. The solid wax near the flame melts. The liquid wax is drawn up the wick, where the heat turns it into wax vapour. It is the vapour that burns, producing the flame, heat, light, carbon dioxide and water vapour. Meanwhile, some melted wax runs down the side and becomes solid again.
What happens in a burning candle
- Solid wax melts Physical change (solid to liquid).
- Liquid wax rises up the wick No new substance.
- Liquid wax turns to vapour Physical change (liquid to gas).
- Wax vapour burns Chemical change: new substances, heat and light.
- Dripping wax hardens Physical change (liquid to solid).
So the burning of a candle involves both physical and chemical changes. In the nineteenth century the scientist Michael Faraday gave a famous series of lectures, The Chemical History of a Candle, using just this object to explain melting, vaporisation and combustion.
Can the change be reversed?
Some changes can be reversed: we can get back the original object or substance. Melted ice can be frozen again; evaporated water can be condensed back. Others cannot: chopped vegetables do not become whole, popcorn does not turn back into corn kernels, and a cooked idli cannot become batter again.
| Change | Physical or chemical? | Can it be reversed? |
|---|---|---|
| Melting ice | Physical | Yes: freeze it |
| Dissolving sugar in water | Physical | Yes: evaporate the water |
| Rolling up a mat | Physical | Yes: unroll it |
| Grinding wheat into flour | Physical | No |
| Making idlis from batter | Chemical | No |
| Ripening of fruit | Chemical | No |
| Burning paper | Chemical | No |
Whether a change is physical or chemical depends on whether a new substance forms. Whether it can be reversed is a separate question.
Worked example 1: sorting carefully
Sort: knitting wool into a sweater, burning an agarbatti, and a puddle drying up in the sun. Working: knitting only changes the shape and arrangement of the wool, so it is physical, and the sweater can be unravelled, so it can be reversed (with effort). Burning an agarbatti forms ash, smoke and gases: chemical, and it cannot be reversed. A drying puddle is water evaporating, a physical change; in principle the vapour could be condensed back, but it spreads into the air, so in practice we do not get that water back. Some cases are not clear-cut, and it is fine to say so and explain why.
Is the change desirable?
Desirable and undesirable changes
-
Desirable
- Milk setting into curd
- Fruits ripening
- Cooking food
- Food waste turning into compost
-
Undesirable
- Rusting of iron
- Food spoiling in storage
- Pollution from fuels and drying paint
The same change can be desirable in one situation and undesirable in another. Decay of food in the kitchen cupboard is a loss, but decay of peels in a compost pit makes useful manure. Some changes caused by people have long-term effects on the environment: burning more fuel in vehicles increases the amount of carbon dioxide in the air, and paint drying on walls releases substances that pollute the air.
Worked example 2: making lemon rice
Lata makes lemon rice. She cuts a lemon, dissolves salt in the juice, cooks rice, sees steam form drops on the lid, and puts the peels in the compost bin. Working: cutting the lemon changes only its size and shape: physical. Dissolving salt forms no new substance: physical. Cooking changes the rice into something softer with a new taste that cannot be undone: chemical. Steam forming drops on the lid is condensation: physical. The peels slowly rotting into compost form new substances: chemical, and here a desirable one. One meal contains both kinds of change.
Key takeaways: a burning candle involves physical changes (melting, vaporising, solidifying wax) and a chemical change (burning wax vapour). Some changes can be reversed and some cannot; this is a separate question from physical versus chemical. Changes can also be desirable or undesirable depending on the situation, and some human-made changes affect the environment.
Check your understanding
-
1. In a burning candle, which change is a chemical change?
- The burning of wax vapour
- The melting of wax
- The hardening of dripping wax
- The rising of liquid wax up the wick
Show answer
Answer: A. Burning wax vapour forms new substances such as carbon dioxide and water, with heat and light. The others only change the state or position of wax.
-
2. Which change can be reversed?
- Ripening of a banana
- Dissolving sugar in water
- Making popcorn from corn
- Burning a matchstick
Show answer
Answer: B. Evaporating the water gives back the sugar. Ripening, popping and burning cannot be undone.
-
3. Grinding wheat into flour is:
- A physical change that cannot be reversed
- A chemical change that can be reversed
- A chemical change that cannot be reversed
- A physical change that can be reversed
Show answer
Answer: A. Flour is still wheat in tiny pieces (no new substance), so it is physical, but the grains cannot be put back together.
-
4. Which of these is generally an undesirable change?
- Ripening of mangoes
- Milk setting into curd
- Cooking rice
- Rusting of an iron gate
Show answer
Answer: D. Rusting damages iron objects. Ripening, curd-making and cooking are useful changes.
-
5. Why is decomposition of food waste in a compost pit considered desirable?
- It makes iron rust faster
- It produces fresh food
- It turns waste into compost that helps plants grow
- It turns waste into plastic
Show answer
Answer: C. Decay that spoils stored food is undesirable, but in a compost pit the same kind of change makes useful manure.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.