- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Why barter was difficult: five problems
Use the farmer-and-ox story to explain the five problems of barter: double coincidence of wants, no common measure of value, divisibility, portability and durability.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the double coincidence of wants and why it is hard to achieve.
- Explain the problems of no common measure of value, divisibility, portability and durability.
- Identify these problems in a new barter situation.
Barter works neatly when two classmates swap a pencil and an eraser. But what happens when you need many different things from many different people, and all you have to offer is one large item? Let us follow a farmer and find out.
A farmer with an ox
Imagine a farmer living where everyone barters. He needs new shoes, a sweater and medicine for his grandmother, and the only thing he can spare is an ox. First, he must find someone who actually wants an ox. Swapping an ox for just a pair of shoes would be unfair, and he cannot cut off part of the ox. So he might trade the ox for many bags of wheat, then carry the wheat from place to place, bargaining over how much wheat a pair of shoes, a sweater or the medicine is worth. He must then store the leftover wheat, which may rot or be eaten by rats, and carry it again the next time he needs something.
The five problems of barter
| Problem | What it means | In the farmer's story |
|---|---|---|
| Double coincidence of wants | Each person must have exactly what the other wants, at the same time | He needs someone who wants an ox AND can give him shoes, a sweater and medicine |
| No common standard measure of value | There is no agreed way to compare the worth of different goods | How many bags of wheat equal one sweater? Every deal needs long bargaining |
| Divisibility | Some goods cannot be split into smaller parts | He cannot exchange part of an ox for a sweater |
| Portability | Some goods are hard to carry or move | Taking an ox or many bags of wheat everywhere is difficult |
| Durability | Some goods spoil and cannot be stored for long | Stored wheat may rot or be eaten by rats |
Double coincidence of wants: an exchange can happen only when two people each have something the other wants and are willing to swap directly.
Why barter became difficult
-
Finding a partner
- Double coincidence of wants
-
Agreeing a fair deal
- No common standard measure of value
-
Handling the goods
- Divisibility
- Portability
- Durability
Even when two people do want each other's goods, a deal may fail if one of them feels the exchange is unfair, because without a common measure of value it is hard to agree. These problems grew as more types of goods were traded and as people traded over longer distances.
Worked example 1: spotting the problems
Situation: A potter has 30 clay pots and wants a goat. The goat owner does not need pots; she wants a blanket. Which problems appear? Step 1, the goat owner does not want pots, so there is no double coincidence of wants. Step 2, even if she did, how many pots equal one goat? There is no common measure of value. Step 3, carrying 30 fragile pots to the market is a problem of portability, and pots may break, a problem of durability. Step 4, he cannot hand over part of a goat in change, a problem of divisibility.
Worked example 2: counting the steps
Question: Using barter, how many separate exchanges does the farmer need to get shoes, a sweater and medicine from three different people? Step 1, ox for wheat: 1 exchange. Step 2, wheat for shoes, wheat for a sweater, wheat for medicine: 3 exchanges. Total: 1 + 3 = 4 exchanges, each with its own bargaining, plus carrying and storing the wheat. With money he could sell the ox once and make 3 simple purchases, with prices already set.
Key takeaways: Barter suffers from five problems: the double coincidence of wants is hard to find; there is no common standard measure of value; many goods cannot be divided; many are hard to carry; and many spoil if stored. As trade grew in variety and distance, these problems made a better system necessary.
Check your understanding
-
1. A fisherman wants rice, but the rice farmer wants a pair of sandals, not fish. Which barter problem is this?
- Durability
- Portability
- Lack of double coincidence of wants
- Divisibility
Show answer
Answer: C. The two do not each want what the other has, so the double coincidence of wants is missing.
-
2. The farmer cannot exchange 'part of an ox' for a sweater. This is the problem of:
- divisibility
- durability
- double coincidence of wants
- portability
Show answer
Answer: A. Divisibility is the capacity of a good to be split into portions; an ox cannot be divided for small purchases.
-
3. Stored wheat may rot or be eaten by rats. Which problem does this show?
- Portability
- Divisibility
- Common measure of value
- Durability
Show answer
Answer: D. Durability is the ability of a good to last without damage; wheat cannot be stored for long.
-
4. Two people want each other's goods but cannot agree how many bags of wheat equal one sweater. What is missing?
- Portability
- A common standard measure of value
- Divisibility
- Durability
Show answer
Answer: B. Without an agreed measure of value, comparing the worth of different goods is difficult.
-
5. Using barter, the farmer swaps his ox for wheat and then swaps wheat separately for shoes, a sweater and medicine. How many exchanges is that in all?
- 4
- 3
- 2
- 5
Show answer
Answer: A. One exchange (ox for wheat) plus three (wheat for each item) = 4 exchanges.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.