- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
How the mahājanapadas were governed: kings and early republics
Describe the role of the sabhā and samiti, compare monarchies with the gaṇas or saṅghas of Vajji and Malla, and explain why scholars call these 'early republics'.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the role of the assemblies called sabhā and samiti.
- Describe the duties of a rājā in a monarchy.
- Compare monarchies with gaṇas or saṅghas and explain the term 'early republics'.
Who made decisions in these early states, and could a ruler do whatever he liked? The evidence suggests that, in many places, rulers were expected to listen to assemblies, and that in a few states the assembly itself chose the ruler. That makes this period important in the long history of shared decision-making.
Assemblies: sabhā and samiti
Each janapada had an assembly or council, called a sabhā or samiti, where the clan's affairs were discussed. These words first appear in the Vedas, India's most ancient texts. Members were probably mostly clan elders. A good rājā was expected not to rule alone or by whim, but to take advice from these assemblies as well as from ministers and officials. Some texts even say an incompetent ruler could be removed by the assembly. Historians are careful here: such mentions are significant, but they do not prove it was an established law, because our evidence from such distant times is incomplete.
Sabhā and samiti: assemblies of (mostly) elders that discussed a clan's affairs and advised the ruler; the words first appear in the Vedas.
Monarchies
In many mahājanapadas the rājā was the final authority, supported by ministers and an assembly of elders. These were in effect monarchies. The position was hereditary: a rājā was usually the son of the previous one. The king's duties were to:
- collect taxes or revenue;
- maintain law and order;
- build strong fortifications around the capital;
- keep an army to defend the territory or fight neighbouring states.
Magadha (part of today's Bihar), Kosala (part of today's Uttar Pradesh) and Avanti (part of today's Madhya Pradesh) were among the most powerful monarchies.
Gaṇas or saṅghas: early republics
At least two mahājanapadas, Vajji (Vṛijji) and its neighbour Malla, worked differently. There, the sabhā or samiti had more power. It took important decisions through discussion and, if needed, by vote, and it even selected the rājā. These states, called gaṇas or saṅghas, were not monarchies. Because the members of the assembly chose the ruler and made major decisions, scholars often call them early republics, among the earliest such systems in the world.
Two systems of government
-
Monarchy (e.g. Magadha, Kosala, Avanti)
- Rājā is the final authority
- Position usually hereditary
- Advised by ministers and an assembly of elders
- Collects taxes, keeps an army, builds forts
-
Gaṇa or saṅgha (Vajji, Malla)
- Assembly has more power
- Decisions by discussion and, if needed, voting
- Assembly selects the rājā
- Called 'early republics' by scholars
Worked example 1: classifying a state
Question (made-up description): 'In this state, when the old ruler died, the assembly met, debated for three days and then voted to choose a new ruler.' Is it a monarchy or a gaṇa? Working: in a monarchy the position passes by heredity, usually to the son. Here the assembly chose the ruler by vote, which matches the gaṇa or saṅgha system, as in Vajji and Malla.
Worked example 2: being careful with evidence
Question: a student writes, 'In ancient India, the law said that the assembly must remove a bad king.' What is wrong with this? Working: the chapter says only that some texts mention an incompetent ruler being removed by the assembly. That is important evidence, but it does not show that it was an established law everywhere, and our evidence for such early times is incomplete. A better sentence: 'Some ancient texts suggest that an assembly could remove an incompetent ruler.'
Key takeaways: Janapadas had assemblies called sabhā or samiti, mostly of elders, whose advice a good ruler was expected to take. Most mahājanapadas were monarchies with hereditary rājās who collected taxes, kept order, built forts and kept armies. Vajji and Malla were gaṇas or saṅghas, where the assembly decided by discussion and vote and chose the rājā; scholars call them early republics.
Check your understanding
-
1. In which ancient texts do the words 'sabhā' and 'samiti' first appear?
- The Arthaśhāstra
- Buddhist Jātaka stories
- The Vedas
- Tamil Sangam poems
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter reminds us that sabhā and samiti first appear in the Vedas, India's most ancient texts.
-
2. Which two mahājanapadas had the gaṇa or saṅgha system?
- Magadha and Kosala
- Vajji and Malla
- Avanti and Vatsa
- Gandhāra and Kamboja
Show answer
Answer: B. Vajji (Vṛijji) and its neighbour Malla were gaṇas or saṅghas, where the assembly took decisions and selected the rājā.
-
3. Why do scholars call the gaṇas 'early republics'?
- Because they had no ruler at all
- Because they were the largest states
- Because they had the strongest armies
- Because the assembly made major decisions and selected the ruler
Show answer
Answer: D. In the gaṇas the members of the assembly chose the rājā and took important decisions by discussion and vote, so the system was not a monarchy.
-
4. Which was a usual duty of a rājā in a monarchy?
- Collecting taxes and maintaining law and order
- Writing the Vedas
- Choosing members of other kingdoms' assemblies
- Running monasteries
Show answer
Answer: A. The king collected taxes, kept law and order, built fortifications and maintained an army.
-
5. How was the rājā usually chosen in a monarchy among the mahājanapadas?
- By a vote of all the people
- By a lottery
- By heredity, usually the son of the previous rājā
- By the neighbouring kings
Show answer
Answer: C. The chapter says the position was hereditary: a rājā would usually be the son of the previous one.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.