- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Traditional wisdom, modern farming and today's challenges
Compare traditional farming systems with the Green Revolution, explain sustainable farming, and describe the government's support and the main challenges Indian farmers face.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe traditional farming systems such as terrace farming, kulagar and gokrishi.
- Explain what the Green Revolution introduced, what it achieved and its harmful effects.
- Describe sustainable farming, the government's support and the challenges farmers face.
Indian farmers have always experimented. Some methods come from ancient knowledge, others from modern science, and many farmers mix both. The big question for the future is how to grow enough food without harming the soil, water and people that farming depends on.
Traditional farming systems
Traditional farming treats the plant and the whole soil ecosystem as one system. Soil is the main source of nutrients, topped up with farmyard manure. Bacteria and fungi in the soil turn nutrients into forms plants can absorb, and plants feed these organisms through their roots. Such farming is usually small-scale, uses local resources and follows natural cycles such as the ritu chakra (cycle of seasons).
- Terrace farming: steps cut into hill slopes create flat land, preventing soil erosion and saving water (seen, for example, in Uttarakhand).
- Kulagar: from Konkani words for family and storehouse; a homestead system in the Konkan (Goa) where families grow food crops, cash crops, fruits, spices and medicinal plants around the home with planned irrigation.
- Gokrishi: a holistic method in which cows provide manure as organic fertiliser and bullocks plough the fields.
According to the textbook, ICAR has documented almost 5,000 traditional practices and tested over a hundred; more than 85 per cent of those tested were found to be supported by modern science and could reduce chemical use and improve soil health.
The Green Revolution
A major turning point came with the Green Revolution of the 1960s and 1970s. It introduced high-yielding varieties (HYV) of seeds, more irrigation, chemical fertilisers and pesticides, and machines such as tractors and harvesters. Food grain production, especially of wheat and rice, rose sharply and India became self-sufficient in food. The agricultural scientist M. S. Swaminathan is known as its architect.
Over later decades its limits became clear: soil became poorer over time, groundwater was used up, pesticides and fertilisers polluted soil and water, and human and animal health was harmed. Chemicals also hurt useful creatures such as bees, which are needed for pollination. Many agricultural scientists around the world now question whether this kind of farming can last.
Traditional and Green Revolution farming: the trade-off
-
Traditional methods
- Work with nature; resilient and sustainable
- Use manure, local seeds, mixed crops
- Often give lower yields
-
Green Revolution methods
- HYV seeds, irrigation, chemicals, machines
- High yields quickly; food self-sufficiency
- Long-term harm to soil, water and health
Sustainable pathways
Sustainable agriculture tries to combine the productivity of modern methods with the wisdom of traditional ones, inspired by Indian Knowledge Systems. Organic farming avoids chemical fertilisers and pesticides and uses compost, seed cake (what remains after oil is pressed from seeds) and animal manure. Neem-based pesticides are natural and far less harmful than chemical ones. The textbook notes that Sikkim became the world's first fully organic state, having banned chemical fertilisers and pesticides in 2014. The Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) has recognised three globally important agricultural heritage systems in India: saffron farming in Kashmir, forest-linked farming in Odisha, and below-sea-level farming with fishing in Kerala. Another new method, hydroponics, grows plants in nutrient-rich water without soil, useful in cities or where soil is poor.
Sustainable agriculture: farming that meets today's food needs while keeping soil, water and living things healthy for the future.
The role of the government and the challenges
Governments help farmers obtain seeds, fertilisers and pesticides, weather forecasts, research and training. They supply cheaper electricity for irrigation, run crop insurance schemes, and buy important crops from farmers so they can sell at fair prices. Cold storage and digital access to information and markets help farmers get better prices.
Yet farmers face serious challenges. Land is divided among family members over generations, so holdings keep shrinking; the average is about three-quarters of a hectare, roughly a football field. Small farms earn little and find large machines too costly. Climate change brings untimely rain, droughts and floods. Rivers such as the Ganga are under stress from melting glaciers, heavy water use and dams. Hardship can push farmers into loans they cannot repay, a debt trap, and many have left farming.
Worked example 1: working with land units
One hectare is 10,000 square metres. An average holding of about three-quarters of a hectare is 0.75 × 10,000 = 7,500 square metres. If such a farm is split equally between two children, each gets 7,500 ÷ 2 = 3,750 square metres. Split again in the next generation, each share becomes 1,875 square metres. This shows how quickly landholdings shrink.
Worked example 2: cause and effect
How a farmer can fall into a debt trap
- Hardship Small farm, failed rains or low prices.
- Loan Farmer borrows to buy seed, fertiliser or meet needs.
- Another bad season Harvest fails or earns too little.
- Cannot repay Debt grows; more borrowing follows.
- Leaves farming Some farmers give up agriculture.
Key takeaways: Traditional systems such as terrace farming, kulagar and gokrishi work with nature. The Green Revolution brought high yields and food self-sufficiency but harmed soil, water and health. Sustainable farming blends both. Governments support farmers with inputs, information, insurance and purchases, but small landholdings, climate change and debt remain big challenges.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these was NOT introduced by the Green Revolution?
- High-yielding varieties of seeds
- Chemical fertilisers and pesticides
- Hydroponics in cities
- Mechanised equipment
Show answer
Answer: C. The Green Revolution of the 1960s-70s brought HYV seeds, more irrigation, chemical fertilisers and pesticides and machines. Hydroponics is a separate, newer soil-free method.
-
2. In the kulagar system of the Konkan, what does a family do?
- Grow many kinds of crops around the home with planned irrigation
- Grow only rice on a large estate
- Rear fish in the open sea
- Grow crops in water without soil
Show answer
Answer: A. Kulagar (family storehouse) is a homestead system where families grow food crops, cash crops, fruits, spices and medicinal plants around their homes.
-
3. Which state does the textbook call the world's first 100 per cent organic state?
- Punjab
- Kerala
- Goa
- Sikkim
Show answer
Answer: D. Sikkim banned chemical fertilisers and pesticides in 2014 and adopted organic farming across the state.
-
4. Read: 'Ramesh's father and uncle divided their father's farm. Now Ramesh and his sister will divide his father's share.' What challenge does this show?
- Climate change
- Shrinking landholdings
- Groundwater depletion
- Pest attacks
Show answer
Answer: B. Land is divided among family members in each generation, so each holding becomes smaller, which makes farming less profitable and machines harder to use.
-
5. Assertion (A): Many scientists question whether Green Revolution farming is sustainable. Reason (R): Over time it has led to poorer soil, falling groundwater and pollution from chemicals.
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. The long-term harm to soil, water and health described in R is exactly why scientists doubt the approach can last, so R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.