• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Investigating like a scientist: the puri experiment

Plan a fair investigation of an everyday kitchen puzzle by choosing what to change, what to keep the same and what to observe or measure, then record results and ask new questions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Name the variable you change, the variables you keep the same and what you observe or measure.
  • Explain why a fair test changes only one thing at a time.
  • Record observations and use them to ask better questions.

You do not need a fancy laboratory to investigate. A kitchen is full of puzzles. Think of a puri puffing up like a balloon in hot oil, often with one side thinner than the other. Why does that happen? Let us plan an investigation the way a scientist would. (Hot oil is dangerous: any frying must be done by an adult, with you watching from a safe distance.)

Step 1: ask a scientific question

A good starting question is: 'What things change the way a puri puffs up when it is fried?' This is broad, so we list what we could change and what we could observe.

Step 2: what can we change, and what can we observe?

Planning the puri investigation
Things we can change (control)Things we can observe or measure
Thickness of the rolled doughDoes it puff up? (yes or no)
Size of the dough circleTime taken to puff up (seconds)
Type of flour (atta, maida and so on)Is one side thinner than the other?
Temperature of the oilDid the oil splatter, smoke or smell?
How the dough is put in (flat, sliding, at an angle)Colour of the fried puri

The things we change are called variables. The one we deliberately change is the changed (independent) variable. What we observe or measure is the measured (dependent) variable. Everything else must stay the same: these are the controlled variables.

Step 3: change only one thing at a time

If we change both the oil temperature and the dough thickness together, and the puri puffs faster, we cannot tell which change caused it. So we change one thing at a time. To test oil temperature, we use dough circles of the same flour, size and thickness, and slide them in the same way; only the oil temperature differs. This is called a fair test.

Steps of a systematic investigation

  1. Ask Turn curiosity into a focused question
  2. Plan Choose one variable to change, what to measure, what to keep the same
  3. Test Do the experiment safely, changing only that one variable
  4. Record Write down every observation and measurement
  5. Conclude Say what the results show, and what they do not
  6. Ask again Results lead to new questions

Worked example 1: identifying variables

Question: 'Does the temperature of the oil affect how quickly a puri puffs?' Working: changed variable = oil temperature (for example 'very hot', 'hot', 'not very hot'). Measured variable = time to puff up, in seconds. Controlled variables = type of flour, size and thickness of the dough, how it is put into the oil, and how long the dough rested.

Worked example 2: spotting an unfair test

Kabir fries a thick maida puri in very hot oil and a thin atta puri in warmer oil, and says, 'Hotter oil makes puris puff faster.' Is his conclusion fair? Working: he changed three things at once: thickness, flour and oil temperature. Any one of them could explain the difference. His conclusion is not supported. He should repeat with identical dough and change only the oil temperature.

Step 4: record, then ask again

Keep notes of everything you see, hear and smell, not only the numbers you planned to measure. Did the oil splatter? Did it smoke? Recorded notes let you compare results and spot patterns. After one round, new questions appear: do puris puff better from fresh dough or stored dough? What happens if you prick a hole before frying? Scientists say even the puffing of a puri is not fully understood yet, which shows how much there is still to investigate.

In a fair test, change only one variable at a time, measure the result, and keep everything else the same.

Key takeaways: investigation starts with a focused question. Decide the one variable you will change, what you will observe or measure, and what you will keep the same. Change one thing at a time so you know what caused any difference. Record all observations, draw conclusions only from your evidence, and use the results to ask new questions. Always do cooking experiments with an adult.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Pooja tests whether the size of a dough circle affects how fast a puri puffs. What is the changed (independent) variable?

    1. The time taken to puff up
    2. The type of flour
    3. The temperature of the oil
    4. The size of the dough circle
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The changed variable is the one Pooja deliberately alters: the size of the dough circle. The time to puff up is what she measures, and flour and oil temperature must be kept the same.

  2. 2. Why should only one thing be changed at a time in an experiment?

    1. So that any difference in the result can be linked to that one change
    2. Because changing things is not allowed in science
    3. To make the experiment finish faster
    4. So that no observations need to be written down
    Show answer

    Answer: A. If several things change together, you cannot tell which one caused the difference. Changing one variable while keeping the rest the same makes the test fair.

  3. 3. In an investigation of oil temperature and puffing time, which must be kept the same?

    1. The oil temperature
    2. The thickness of the dough
    3. The puffing time
    4. Nothing needs to be kept the same
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Oil temperature is the variable being changed and puffing time is what is measured. Dough thickness (and flour, size, method of dropping) must be kept the same so the test is fair.

  4. 4. Which is a measurement that can be recorded as a number in the puri investigation?

    1. Whether the cook liked the puri
    2. The name of the flour mill
    3. The time taken for the puri to puff up, in seconds
    4. The colour of the kitchen walls
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Time in seconds is a number that can be measured and compared. Liking is opinion, and the other two have nothing to do with puffing.

  5. 5. Arjun finds that puris puff faster in hotter oil. What is the best next step for a young scientist?

    1. Stop investigating because the answer is now known forever
    2. Change all the variables together in the next test
    3. Throw away the notes
    4. Repeat the test to check it, and ask new questions such as whether fresh dough behaves differently
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Repeating checks that the result is reliable, and each answer leads to new questions. Changing many variables at once would make the next test unfair.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery