- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Famines and the drain of wealth
Explain how Company revenue policy contributed to the Bengal famine of 1770-1772 and later famines, and describe the 'drain of wealth' identified by Dadabhai Naoroji and R. C. Dutt.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain how revenue policies made the Bengal famine of 1770-1772 so deadly.
- Describe how the 'free market' policy and grain exports worsened later famines.
- Explain the idea of the 'drain of wealth' and who documented it.
After Plassey, the East India Company gained the right to collect revenue in Bengal, Bihar and Odisha, among India's richest regions. Clive called Bengal 'the paradise of the earth'. Within a few years it suffered one of the worst famines in its history. This lesson asks why.
The Bengal famine of 1770-1772
The Company's agents collected as much revenue as possible while spending little on government or development. Farmers had to pay a high cash tax on their land's produce whatever the harvest. After two years of crop failure, these harsh targets led to a catastrophic famine in 1770-1772. According to the textbook, it killed nearly one-third of Bengal's population, an estimated 10 million people, and the Company kept its demands high and even raised the land tax during the famine. Later, Indian leaders as well as some British officials and writers condemned this cruelty.
How the Bengal famine became a catastrophe
- Revenue rights after Plassey The Company collects taxes in Bengal, Bihar and Odisha.
- High cash taxes regardless of harvest Farmers must pay even when crops fail.
- Two years of crop failure Food runs short.
- Taxes kept high, even raised Farmers sell cattle, tools and seed grain.
- Famine of 1770-1772 About one-third of the population dies, by estimates.
Famines under British rule
Such famines recurred. In the Great Famine of 1876-1878, up to 8 million Indians died, mostly in the Deccan. Several factors made it worse. Some traders hoarded grain hoping for higher prices; the British administration kept exporting grain to Britain, about a million tonnes of rice a year during the famine, by the textbook's account; and the 'free market' policy left food prices to rise freely. The Viceroy, Lord Lytton, ordered that the government must not interfere to bring food prices down; in the same year he held a lavish durbar in Delhi. Relief camps were few and poorly supplied.
The textbook notes that estimates of the number of severe famines under British rule range from a dozen to over 20, and that estimates of the total deaths range between 50 and 100 million. India had always faced famines from droughts, floods and wars, but never on such a scale. Rural India sank into deep poverty.
Free-market policy (in this context): the government leaving food prices to rise and fall without any control, even during a famine, so that grain went to those who could pay the most.
The drain of wealth
Economic exploitation was at the heart of colonial policy. Writers such as the American historian Brooks Adams argued that wealth taken from Bengal after Plassey helped pay for the start of Britain's Industrial Revolution. Building on such studies, Dadabhai Naoroji, the first Indian elected to the British House of Commons, published Poverty and Un-British Rule in India (1901), calculating from British reports the wealth taken out of India. The historian Romesh Chunder Dutt did similar work in his Economic History of India. These studies showed that the colonisers had extracted many billions of pounds.
Wealth was drained not only through taxes. Indians were also charged for the colonial power's spending on railways, the telegraph and even wars. A recent estimate cited in the textbook (by the economist Utsa Patnaik) puts the drain from 1765 to 1938 at about 45 trillion US dollars in today's value. Had this wealth stayed in India, the country would have been very different at Independence.
Ways wealth was drained from India
- Taxes Heavy land revenue collected in cash.
-
Charges for colonial spending
- Railways
- Telegraph
- Wars
- Trade policy Raw materials out, British goods in.
- Plunder and profits Wealth sent to Britain after Plassey.
Reading a painting as a source
A 1778 painting made for the Company's London headquarters, 'The East offering its riches to Britannia', shows Britannia (a figure for Britain) seated high, while figures for India and China bow lower and 'offer' pearls, jewels, cotton and other riches. The textbook asks us to question it: did the colonies really offer their wealth, or was it taken by force and trickery? The higher position of Britannia and the darker skin of the Indian figures reflect a belief in British superiority. Paintings show how their makers wanted events to be seen.
Worked example 1: working with an estimate
The textbook says the 1770-1772 famine killed nearly one-third of Bengal's population, about 10 million people. What population does this imply? If one-third is about 10 million, the whole is about 3 × 10 = 30 million. Checking estimates against each other like this helps us understand their scale. (These are historians' estimates, not exact counts.)
Worked example 2: explaining 'un-British rule'
Why did Dadabhai Naoroji call British rule in India 'un-British'? As a member of the British Parliament, he knew British ideals of fair government and the rule of law. He argued that British rule in India broke these very ideals by draining the country's wealth and impoverishing its people. The title is a clever argument: it judges British rule by Britain's own standards.
Key takeaways
- High cash taxes regardless of harvest turned crop failure into the Bengal famine of 1770-1772.
- Grain exports, hoarding and a free-market policy worsened later famines such as 1876-1878.
- Dadabhai Naoroji and R. C. Dutt documented the drain of India's wealth to Britain.
- Indians paid for railways, the telegraph and even wars through taxes and charges.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which factor does the textbook give for the severity of the Bengal famine of 1770-1772?
- The Company lowered taxes during the famine
- High cash taxes were collected regardless of the harvest, and were even raised during the famine
- Farmers grew too much grain
- The Marathas invaded Bengal
Show answer
Answer: B. Farmers had to pay high cash taxes whatever the harvest, and the Company even raised the land tax during the famine, turning crop failure into catastrophe.
-
2. Who wrote 'Poverty and Un-British Rule in India' (1901)?
- R. C. Dutt
- Brooks Adams
- Dadabhai Naoroji
- Thomas Macaulay
Show answer
Answer: C. Dadabhai Naoroji, the first Indian elected to the British House of Commons, wrote it, compiling estimates of the wealth drained from India.
-
3. How did the 'free market' policy make famines worse?
- Food prices were left to rise freely, so the poor could not buy grain
- The government gave free food to everyone
- Grain exports were banned
- Farmers were paid fixed high prices
Show answer
Answer: A. Leaving prices uncontrolled meant grain went to those who could pay. Lord Lytton even ordered no government action to reduce food prices.
-
4. If about 10 million people were one-third of a population, roughly how large was the whole population?
- 13 million
- 3 million
- 20 million
- 30 million
Show answer
Answer: D. One-third is 10 million, so the whole is 3 × 10 = 30 million (an estimate).
-
5. Assertion (A): Indians paid for much of the colonial railway and telegraph network.
Reason (R): The costs were charged to India through taxes, as part of the drain of wealth.- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
- Both A and R are false
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook says wealth was extracted not only through taxes but also by charging Indians for railways, the telegraph and even wars.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.