- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Indirect elections, challenges and the road ahead
Explain how members of the Rajya Sabha, the President and the Vice President are elected indirectly, and discuss the challenges facing India's elections.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish between direct and indirect elections.
- Explain how the Rajya Sabha, the President and the Vice President are elected.
- Identify challenges to elections and how aware voters help meet them.
Not every election is decided directly by the people's votes. Some are made by the people's elected representatives. These are called indirect elections. This lesson explains three of them and then looks at the health of our elections.
Direct and indirect elections
In a direct election, voters themselves choose the winner, as in Lok Sabha and assembly elections. In an indirect election, voters elect representatives, and those representatives then choose. For example, if every class in a school elects a class monitor, and the monitors together elect a school council, the council election is indirect.
The Rajya Sabha
Members of the Rajya Sabha (the Council of States) are also MPs, but they are chosen indirectly. Of its 245 members, 233 are elected by the elected MLAs of the state legislative assemblies, and 12 are nominated by the President for their distinction. Each state gets a number of seats based on its population, so a populous state such as Uttar Pradesh has more seats than a less populous one such as Arunachal Pradesh.
The Rajya Sabha is a permanent house: it is never dissolved. Each member serves six years, and one-third of the members retire every two years, so it always has continuity. MLAs vote using the single transferable vote system, ranking candidates by preference; this helps smaller groups get fair representation. (The details are studied in higher classes.)
| Feature | Lok Sabha | Rajya Sabha |
|---|---|---|
| How members are chosen | Directly by voters | Indirectly by elected MLAs (plus 12 nominated) |
| Voting system | First-Past-the-Post | Single transferable vote |
| Can it be dissolved? | Yes; it has a fixed term and can be dissolved earlier | No, it is a permanent house |
| Renewal | All members at each general election | One-third retire every two years; six-year terms |
Indirect election: an election in which the people's elected representatives, not the people themselves, choose the winner, as in elections to the Rajya Sabha and of the President.
Electing the President and Vice President
The President of India is elected by an electoral college made up of the elected MPs of both houses of Parliament and the elected MLAs of all states and of the union territories of Delhi and Puducherry. The single transferable vote is used, and the more populous states have a greater say. Not included: the 12 nominated Rajya Sabha members, nominated members of assemblies, members of Legislative Councils in states that have two houses (bicameral legislatures), and nominated members of Delhi and Puducherry. Only directly elected representatives vote, so the President represents the people's will indirectly but meaningfully, with support from both the Centre and the states.
The Vice President is elected by an electoral college of all members, elected and nominated, of both houses of Parliament, again by single transferable vote. The Vice President is the chairperson of the Rajya Sabha and steps in if the President cannot carry out the duties of the office.
Who elects the President and the Vice President?
-
President
- Elected MPs of Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha
- Elected MLAs of states, Delhi and Puducherry
- Nominated members excluded
- Single transferable vote
-
Vice President
- All MPs of both houses
- Elected and nominated members included
- MLAs not included
- Single transferable vote
Challenges and the road ahead
India's elections are celebrated as the world's largest democratic exercise, but they face challenges: the growing influence of money, a significant share of candidates with criminal records, and voter apathy, especially in cities. The way forward, says the textbook, is informed voters: media, education and awareness campaigns can help people, especially the young, to vote wisely. An aware and watchful voter is the strongest safeguard of democracy.
Worked example 1: sorting electors
Who votes in the President's election? (a) An elected Lok Sabha MP: yes. (b) A nominated Rajya Sabha member: no. (c) An elected MLA of Delhi: yes. (d) A member of a state Legislative Council: no. (e) An elected Rajya Sabha MP: yes. The rule: only elected members of Parliament and of state (and Delhi and Puducherry) assemblies vote. For the Vice President, (b) would vote too, but (c) would not, because only MPs vote.
Worked example 2: Rajya Sabha numbers
The Rajya Sabha has 245 members: 245 − 12 nominated = 233 elected. If one-third of members retire every two years, about 245 ÷ 3 ≈ 82 seats come up for election each time. With six-year terms, a member elected now will serve through three such rounds of elections (2 + 2 + 2 = 6 years). This rolling pattern means the house is never empty and never dissolved.
Key takeaways
- Indirect elections are made by elected representatives, not directly by voters.
- The Rajya Sabha has 233 members elected by MLAs and 12 nominated by the President; it is permanent, with one-third retiring every two years.
- The President is elected by elected MPs and elected MLAs (including Delhi and Puducherry); the Vice President by all MPs.
- Money power, criminal candidates and voter apathy are challenges; informed voters are the best safeguard.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these is an indirect election?
- Election of the President of India
- Election of a Lok Sabha MP
- Election of an MLA
- Election of a ward member in a city
Show answer
Answer: A. The President is chosen by an electoral college of elected representatives, not directly by voters. The others are direct elections.
-
2. How many members of the Rajya Sabha are nominated by the President?
- 233
- 245
- 12
- 543
Show answer
Answer: C. Of 245 members, 12 are nominated by the President and 233 are elected by MLAs.
-
3. Which group does NOT vote in the election of the President of India?
- Elected members of the Lok Sabha
- Elected MLAs of Puducherry
- Elected members of the Rajya Sabha
- Nominated members of the Rajya Sabha
Show answer
Answer: D. Only elected representatives vote for the President. Nominated Rajya Sabha members are excluded, though they do vote for the Vice President.
-
4. Why is the Rajya Sabha called a permanent house?
- Its members serve for life
- It is never dissolved; one-third of members retire every two years
- It meets every day of the year
- Its members are all nominated
Show answer
Answer: B. The Rajya Sabha is never dissolved. Members have six-year terms and one-third retire every two years, giving continuity.
-
5. Assertion (A): An aware voter is called the strongest safeguard of democracy.
Reason (R): Informed voters can resist money power and choose responsible representatives.- A is true but R is false
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- A is false but R is true
- Both A and R are false
Show answer
Answer: B. Challenges like money power and criminal candidates are best countered by voters who are informed and vigilant and who vote thoughtfully.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.