• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Canvas of Soil: the garden as a painting

Appreciate Maya Anthony's poem Canvas of Soil: its extended metaphor of a garden as a painting, imagery, alliteration, AABB rhyme, tone, mood and reading as an allegory; meet Toru Dutt's garden sonnet.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the comparisons that turn a garden into a painting.
  • Identify metaphor, imagery, alliteration, rhyme scheme, tone, mood and speaker.
  • Explain what an allegory is and read the poem as one.
  • Say what Toru Dutt's sonnet describes.

The unit moves from fans to gardens, and from craft to art. Canvas of Soil by Maya Anthony is a short poem of three four-line stanzas that pictures a garden as a work of art. Before reading, learn three painting words: a palette is the board on which a painter mixes colours, a hue is a shade of colour, and a canvas is the cloth on which a picture is painted (here, the painting itself).

What the poem says (in our own words)

Stanza 1: the rich earth is like a painter's palette, where a gardener's dreams sink in; seeds are planted like brushstrokes, waiting for spring to bring colour. Stanza 2: flowers open like a painted picture, moving in the morning light; their greens, reds and blues are nature's ever-new artwork. Stanza 3: each garden plot is a broad canvas where art and life meet, and in the hands of those who work the soil, gardens become living paintings.

The extended metaphor

An extended metaphor is one comparison carried through a whole poem. Here gardening is painting from start to finish.

Each part of painting matched with a part of gardening
PaintingGardeningWhy the comparison works
The painterThe gardenerBoth create beauty with care and skill
The paletteThe earthBoth hold the material from which colour comes
BrushstrokesSeedsEach is a small act that, added up, makes the picture
The canvasThe garden plotBoth are the space where the work appears
The finished paintingThe garden in bloomBoth are works of art to be admired

Appreciating the poem

Features of Canvas of Soil
FeatureIn this poem
Rhyme schemeAABB in each stanza (lines rhyme in pairs)
ImageryColours, brushstrokes, blossoms, shades of green, morning light
AlliterationBlossoms bloom: the b sound is repeated
MetaphorGarden as painting, plot as canvas, seeds as brushstrokes
ToneAppreciative
MoodJoyful
SpeakerBest read as a gardener, or someone who loves gardens

Reading the poem as an allegory

An allegory works on two levels: a surface meaning and a deeper one. On the surface, this is a poem about a garden. At a deeper level, the garden can stand for life's journey and growth (seasons, planting, blooming, a cycle), or for harmony in diversity (many colours together make the picture beautiful, as many kinds of people make a society rich).

The garden's cycle as a picture of life

  1. Seeds planted Beginnings and hopes
  2. Waiting for spring Patience and effort
  3. Blossoms Growth and achievement
  4. Seasons turn Change, then new beginnings

Then back to step 1: Seeds planted

Worked example 1: a metaphor test

Question: Which original sentence uses a metaphor: (a) 'He has a heart of gold' or (b) 'He has a very kind heart'? Working: a metaphor calls one thing another without 'like' or 'as'. (a) calls his heart gold, meaning precious and good. (b) is a plain statement. Answer: (a).

Worked example 2: why 'hue', not 'colours'?

Question: Why might the poet say spring's 'hue' rather than 'colours'? Working: 'hue' is a painter's word for a shade, so it fits the painting metaphor; it also rhymes with the line before. Answer: the word keeps the art comparison going and supports the rhyme.

Extra reading: Toru Dutt's garden sonnet

Toru Dutt (1856-1877) was a Bengali poet who wrote in English and French and died very young. The unit ends with her poem that begins A Sea of Foliage Girds Our Garden Round, a sonnet (a poem of 14 lines) describing her family garden in Bengal. In our words: the garden is surrounded by trees, not in one dull green but in sharp contrasts: light-green tamarinds, deep-green mangoes, grey palm trunks like pillars, and silk-cotton trees whose bright red flowers startle like a trumpet. Loveliest of all is the moon seen through bamboos, turning a white lotus silver, a scene so beautiful it seems like a first, untouched paradise. The simile comparing a colour to a trumpet's sound mixes sight and hearing.

Extended metaphor: one comparison carried through a whole poem. Allegory: a surface story with a deeper meaning.

Key takeaways: Canvas of Soil compares gardening to painting throughout, with AABB rhyme, rich colour imagery, alliteration, an appreciative tone and a joyful mood. Read as an allegory, the garden stands for life's growth or for harmony in diversity.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In Canvas of Soil, the seeds are compared to ______.

    1. brushstrokes
    2. a palette
    3. a canvas
    4. a frame
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The poet calls the seeds brushstrokes: small marks that together create the picture. The earth is the palette and each plot the canvas.

  2. 2. What is the rhyme scheme of each stanza?

    1. ABAB
    2. ABBA
    3. AABB
    4. ABCD
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The lines rhyme in pairs: the first two lines rhyme with each other and so do the last two, which is AABB.

  3. 3. 'Blossoms bloom' is an example of ______.

    1. simile
    2. alliteration
    3. rhetorical question
    4. hyperbole
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Two nearby words start with the same consonant sound, b, so it is alliteration. There is no comparison, question or exaggeration.

  4. 4. Reading the poem as an allegory, the variety of colours in the garden can stand for ______.

    1. the cost of paint
    2. harmony in diversity
    3. a storm
    4. the end of spring
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Many colours together make the garden beautiful, just as many kinds of people together enrich the world. That deeper meaning is harmony in diversity.

  5. 5. Toru Dutt's poem about her garden is a sonnet. What does that tell you?

    1. It has 14 lines.
    2. It has three lines.
    3. It has no rhyme.
    4. It is written in prose.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A sonnet is a poem of 14 lines, usually with a set rhyme scheme. A three-line poem would be a haiku.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery