• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Propositions and the 'if X then Y' form

Tell a proposition from a question, command or opinion, split an 'if X then Y' statement into its condition and conclusion, and recognise the same statement written in other words.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Decide whether a sentence is a proposition (a statement that is either true or false).
  • Pick out the condition X and the conclusion Y in an 'if X then Y' proposition.
  • Rewrite an 'if X then Y' proposition as 'X implies Y', 'Y when X' or 'every X is Y'.

Mathematics is built from sentences that make a clear claim. 'The angles of a triangle add up to 180°' is such a sentence: it is either true or false, and we can try to check which. This chapter studies these claims, how to turn them around, and how to test them. Everything starts with the idea of a proposition.

What is a proposition?

A proposition is a statement that is either true or false. It does not have to be true. '2 + 2 = 5' is a proposition: it is a clear claim, and it happens to be false. What matters is that the sentence can be judged true or false.

Many sentences are not propositions. A question ('Is 21 a prime number?') asks something; it claims nothing. A command ('Draw a circle of radius 3 cm') tells you to act. An opinion ('Cricket is the best sport') depends on the person speaking. A sentence with an unknown, such as 'x + 4 = 10', is called an open sentence: it becomes true or false only after we know the value of x (true for x = 6, false otherwise), so on its own it is not a proposition.

Sentences

  • Propositions
    • 7 is a prime number (true)
    • A triangle has four sides (false)
  • Not propositions
    • Questions: Is 21 prime?
    • Commands: Draw a circle
    • Opinions: Cricket is the best sport
    • Open sentences: x + 4 = 10
Only a statement that can be judged true or false is a proposition.

The 'if X then Y' form

Many propositions in mathematics join two parts with 'if ... then'. In 'If a number ends in 0, then it is divisible by 10', the first part, X = 'a number ends in 0', is the condition (also called the hypothesis). The second part, Y = 'it is divisible by 10', is the conclusion. The proposition promises: whenever X happens, Y must also happen.

A proposition is a statement that is either true or false. In 'if X then Y', X is the condition and Y is the conclusion. 'If X then Y' is also written 'X implies Y'.

An 'if X then Y' proposition makes a promise only about cases where X happens. It is broken only by a case in which X happens and Y does not. Keep this in mind: it is the key to testing propositions in later lessons.

Worked example 1: splitting a proposition

Proposition: 'If a triangle has a right angle, then its other two angles add up to 90°.'

Step 1: find the word 'if'. What follows it, up to 'then', is the condition: X = 'a triangle has a right angle'.

Step 2: what follows 'then' is the conclusion: Y = 'its other two angles add up to 90°'.

Step 3: check it. The three angles add to 180°. If one is 90°, the other two add to 180° − 90° = 90°. So whenever X holds, Y holds: the proposition is true.

The same proposition in other words

Everyday language has many ways to say 'if X then Y'. All of the forms in the table carry exactly the same meaning, so learn to spot X and Y whatever the sentence looks like.

Ways of writing 'if X then Y'
FormExample (X = a number is a multiple of 4, Y = it is even)
If X, then YIf a number is a multiple of 4, then it is even.
X implies YA number being a multiple of 4 implies that it is even.
Y when XA number is even when it is a multiple of 4.
Y whenever XA number is even whenever it is a multiple of 4.
Every X is YEvery multiple of 4 is even.

Worked example 2: rewriting in if-then form

Rewrite 'Every square is a rhombus' in if-then form.

Step 1: the sentence talks about squares, so the condition is X = 'a quadrilateral is a square'.

Step 2: it says squares are rhombuses, so the conclusion is Y = 'it is a rhombus'.

Step 3: join them: 'If a quadrilateral is a square, then it is a rhombus.' A square has four equal sides, which is what a rhombus needs, so the proposition is true.

A common slip is to write 'If a quadrilateral is a rhombus, then it is a square.' That swaps X and Y and says something different (and false: a rhombus need not have right angles). Swapping X and Y is the subject of the next lesson.

Worked example 3: 'Y when X'

Sentence: 'Water boils at sea level when it is heated to 100 °C.' The word 'when' introduces the condition. So X = 'water at sea level is heated to 100 °C' and Y = 'it boils'. In if-then form: 'If water at sea level is heated to 100 °C, then it boils.' Notice that the conclusion came first in the original sentence; the order of words does not decide which part is X.

Key takeaways

  • A proposition is a statement that is true or false; questions, commands, opinions and open sentences are not propositions.
  • In 'if X then Y', X is the condition and Y is the conclusion.
  • 'X implies Y', 'Y when X', 'Y whenever X' and 'every X is Y' all mean 'if X then Y'.
  • An if-then proposition is broken only by a case where X happens and Y does not.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these sentences is a proposition?

    1. Please solve this sum.
    2. Is 15 a multiple of 4?
    3. 15 is a multiple of 4.
    4. What a beautiful rangoli!
    Show answer

    Answer: C. '15 is a multiple of 4' is a statement that can be judged: it is false, because 15 ÷ 4 is not a whole number. A false statement is still a proposition. The others are a request, a question and an exclamation, which claim nothing true or false.

  2. 2. In 'If a number ends in 5, then it is divisible by 5', what is the condition X?

    1. The number is divisible by 5
    2. The number ends in 5
    3. The number is odd
    4. 5 is a prime number
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The condition is the part after 'if' and before 'then': 'a number ends in 5'. The part after 'then', 'it is divisible by 5', is the conclusion.

  3. 3. Which sentence has the same meaning as 'If a shape is a square, then it has four equal sides'?

    1. A shape has four equal sides when it is a square.
    2. A shape is a square when it has four equal sides.
    3. If a shape has four equal sides, then it is a square.
    4. No square has four equal sides.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 'Y when X' means 'if X then Y'. Here X = 'a shape is a square' and Y = 'it has four equal sides', so 'a shape has four equal sides when it is a square' keeps X and Y in their places. The two sentences that start from 'four equal sides' have swapped X and Y, and the last one contradicts the statement.

  4. 4. Write 'Every prime number greater than 2 is odd' in if-then form.

    1. If a number is odd, then it is a prime greater than 2.
    2. If a number is a prime greater than 2, then it is odd.
    3. If a number is not prime, then it is even.
    4. If a number is even, then it is prime.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 'Every X is Y' means 'if X then Y'. The sentence is about primes greater than 2 (X) and says they are odd (Y), so it becomes 'If a number is a prime greater than 2, then it is odd'. Starting from 'odd' swaps the parts: 9 is odd but not prime.

  5. 5. Which of these is NOT a proposition on its own?

    1. The angles of a triangle add up to 180°.
    2. 2 + 2 = 5
    3. Every rectangle has four right angles.
    4. x + 4 = 10
    Show answer

    Answer: D. 'x + 4 = 10' is an open sentence: it is true when x = 6 and false for any other value, so until x is known it cannot be judged. '2 + 2 = 5' is a false proposition, and the other two are true propositions.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → The converse of a proposition

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery