• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

From the idea of atoms to the electron and Thomson's model

Trace the idea of the atom from Kanada and Democritus to Dalton, explain how cathode rays revealed the electron, and describe Thomson's model of the atom and its key idea.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the early ideas of parmanu and atomos and how Dalton's theory differed from them.
  • Explain how J. J. Thomson's cathode ray experiments showed that atoms contain electrons.
  • Describe Thomson's model of the atom and use it to reason about the balance of charges.

You, your desk and the air you breathe are all made of atoms, far too small to see. But is an atom the smallest thing there is, or does it have parts? For more than two thousand years people have wondered about this. This lesson follows the first steps of the journey, from pure reasoning to experiments that broke the atom open.

An idea older than experiments

In ancient India, Acharya Kanada reasoned that if matter (dravya) is divided again and again, we must reach particles that cannot be divided further. He called them parmanu. His ideas are recorded in the Vaisesika Sutras: parmanus are too small to be sensed, and they combine in pairs (dyads), threes (triads) and larger groups to make everything in the material world, including living bodies. In ancient Greece, Leucippus and Democritus had a similar idea and called the smallest particles atomos, meaning "indivisible". These were ideas reached by thinking, not by experiment, and they did not say in what proportions particles combine.

In 1808 John Dalton put forward an atomic theory based on the experimental results of his time. He proposed that all matter is made of indivisible atoms, the basic building blocks that cannot be broken down. It was the first scientific description of how matter is made, and it raised new questions: what are atoms made of, what do they look like, and what makes atoms of one element different from those of another?

How the picture of the atom developed

  1. Parmanu and atomos Indivisible particles, imagined by reasoning (ancient India and Greece).
  2. Dalton, 1808 Indivisible atoms, based on experiments.
  3. Thomson, 1897 Atoms contain electrons: positive sphere with electrons in it.
  4. Rutherford, 1911 A tiny positive nucleus with electrons around it.
  5. Bohr, 1913 Electrons in fixed energy levels.
  6. Today Quantum mechanical model, still being explored.

Atoms are not indivisible after all

Late in the 19th century, scientists found that some elements give out invisible energy and particles on their own, a property called radioactivity. Particles coming out of atoms meant that atoms must have smaller parts.

In 1897 J. J. Thomson passed electricity through a gas at very low pressure in a sealed glass tube with two metal plates (electrodes) connected to a high voltage. Rays travelled from the negative electrode (cathode) towards the positive one (anode): these were called cathode rays. By bending them with electric and magnetic fields, Thomson showed that they are streams of negatively charged particles with a mass much smaller than that of any atom. These particles were named electrons.

Crucially, the cathode rays were the same whatever metal the cathode was made of and whatever gas filled the tube. So electrons must be a part of every atom. The charge of an electron is extremely small (−1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ coulomb); for convenience it is simply taken as −1. Thomson received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1906 for his work on the conduction of electricity through gases.

Thomson's model of the atom

Atoms are electrically neutral, so if they contain negative electrons they must also contain an equal amount of positive charge. Thomson proposed that an atom is a sphere of positive charge with electrons embedded in it, like plums in a pudding, so it was called the plum pudding model. A familiar picture is a watermelon: the red pulp is the positive charge and the seeds scattered through it are the electrons. In this model the positive charge is spread evenly through the whole atom.

Thomson's model: an atom is a sphere of uniformly spread positive charge with electrons embedded in it; the total positive charge equals the total negative charge, so the atom is neutral.

Worked example 1: balancing charges

In Thomson's picture, an atom contains 8 electrons. Each electron has a charge of −1, so the total negative charge is 8 × (−1) = −8. For the atom to be neutral, the positive sphere must carry a total charge of +8. If a model atom had a positive sphere of +7 with 8 electrons, its overall charge would be +7 − 8 = −1: it would not represent a neutral atom.

Worked example 2: testing a model of your own

Suppose you picture Thomson's atom as a besan ladoo studded with raisins. It matches the model in one way: small particles (the raisins, standing for electrons) are spread through a larger body (the ladoo, standing for positive charge). It falls short in others: the raisins are not guaranteed to be spread evenly, nothing in a ladoo carries electric charge, and a ladoo has a definite crust while Thomson's sphere does not. Every model matches the real thing only in some ways, which is why scientists keep testing and improving models.

Early milestones
Thinker or scientistKey idea
KanadaMatter is made of indivisible parmanus that combine in groups
Leucippus and DemocritusSmallest particles called atomos (indivisible)
John Dalton (1808)Experimental atomic theory: indivisible atoms
J. J. Thomson (1897)Discovered the electron; plum pudding model

Key takeaways: The atom began as an idea of reasoning (parmanu, atomos) and became a scientific theory with Dalton. Radioactivity and Thomson's cathode ray experiments showed that atoms have parts: electrons, negatively charged and very light, present in all atoms. Thomson pictured the atom as a positive sphere with electrons embedded, the charges balancing.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What did Acharya Kanada call the smallest indivisible particles of matter?

    1. Atomos
    2. Parmanu
    3. Electrons
    4. Nucleons
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Kanada called them parmanu, as recorded in the Vaisesika Sutras. Atomos was the Greek word used by Leucippus and Democritus.

  2. 2. Cathode rays turned out to be the same whatever metal the cathode was made of and whatever gas filled the tube. What did this show?

    1. Electrons are present in all atoms
    2. Electrons exist only in metals
    3. Cathode rays are positively charged
    4. Atoms are indivisible
    Show answer

    Answer: A. If the same particles come from every material, they must be a common part of all atoms. That is why Thomson concluded electrons are found in every atom.

  3. 3. In Thomson's model, how is the positive charge of an atom arranged?

    1. Packed into a tiny central nucleus
    2. Carried only by the electrons
    3. Spread evenly through a sphere, with electrons embedded in it
    4. Arranged in fixed shells
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Thomson pictured a sphere of uniformly spread positive charge with electrons scattered through it, like seeds in a watermelon. A tiny nucleus came later, from Rutherford.

  4. 4. A model atom in Thomson's style has a positive sphere of +5 and 6 electrons. What is its overall charge?

    1. +11
    2. 0
    3. +1
    4. −1
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Total charge = +5 + 6 × (−1) = +5 − 6 = −1. It would not represent a neutral atom; for neutrality the sphere would need +6.

  5. 5. What is the charge of an electron when written in the usual relative form?

    1. +1
    2. −1
    3. 0
    4. −2
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The actual charge, about −1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ coulomb, is taken as −1 by convention, which makes it easy to count charges in an atom.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery