- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Types of democracy and democracies around the world
Distinguish direct from representative democracy and parliamentary from presidential systems, and compare how India, Canada, the UK, Switzerland and the USA organise democracy.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish direct democracy from representative democracy.
- Distinguish parliamentary democracy from presidential democracy.
- Compare the democratic systems of India, Canada, the UK, Switzerland and the USA.
All democracies share values such as freedom, equality, participation, rule of law, rights and duties. Yet there is no single model. Countries organise democracy differently depending on how citizens take part and how power is arranged. This lesson sorts out the main types.
Direct and representative democracy
In a direct democracy, citizens themselves take part in most decisions, though some representative features also exist. It is hard to run in a large country. The textbook's example is Switzerland. In a representative (indirect) democracy, people elect representatives who govern; elections are periodic and the government is accountable to the people. India is an example.
Parliamentary and presidential democracy
Two forms of representative democracy
-
Parliamentary
Examples: India, Canada
- Members of the executive are also part of the legislature
- Executive is accountable to the legislature
- People elect the legislature, not the executive directly
-
Presidential
Example: USA
- Executive is independent of the legislature
- President is elected by the people
- President is accountable to the people
Direct democracy: citizens decide most matters themselves. Representative democracy: citizens elect representatives who govern and are accountable to them.
A school council thought experiment
Imagine four visiting student councils, each run differently (an activity in the spirit of the textbook). Council 1: all students meet and vote on big decisions such as the canteen menu, with a weak president: close to direct democracy. Council 2: each class elects a representative, and the representatives choose a president and decide together: parliamentary-style representative democracy. Council 3: students directly elect both a president, who is the chief decision-maker, and council members: presidential-style. Council 4: elections are held, but only approved candidates may stand, the president holds most power and opposition is discouraged: elections without real choice or checks, so it is not a genuine democracy. Systems differ in how power is shared, who decides and whether checks exist.
Democracies around the world
| Country | Type | Head of State / Head of Government | Key features |
|---|---|---|---|
| India | Representative, parliamentary | President (Head of State); Prime Minister (Head of Government) | Multi-party, written Constitution, Fundamental Rights and Duties, federalism |
| Canada | Representative, parliamentary | Governor-General appointed by the Monarch on the Prime Minister's advice; Prime Minister heads government | Federalism, multi-party |
| United Kingdom | Parliamentary with constitutional monarchy | Monarch (Head of State); Prime Minister (Head of Government) | Unwritten constitution, parliamentary sovereignty, multi-party |
| Switzerland | Direct democracy | Executive power with the Federal Council | Written constitution, multiple parties |
| United States | Representative, presidential | President heads the government and holds executive power | Written constitution, two major parties |
Federalism is a system in which power is shared between the Union and the States; in India this is set out in the Union, State and Concurrent Lists, with residuary powers remaining with the Union.
Worked example 1: Classifying a system
Clues: 'The head of government is elected directly by the people, the executive is separate from the legislature, and there is a written constitution.' Step 1: direct election of the executive and separation from the legislature point to a presidential system. Step 2: the textbook example is the USA. Contrast: in India, people elect the legislature and the Prime Minister's council of ministers comes from it and is accountable to it.
Worked example 2: Evaluating a system
Is a country democratic if it holds elections but only approved candidates may stand? Test against principles: popular sovereignty needs real choice; a multi-party system and freedom to criticise are needed; checks and balances must exist. Conclusion: elections alone are not enough; such a system is at best partially democratic. This answers the textbook's question whether voting alone makes a country democratic.
Key takeaways: Democracy has no single model. In direct democracy (Switzerland) citizens decide most matters; in representative democracy (India) they elect representatives. Parliamentary systems (India, Canada, UK) draw the executive from the legislature and make it accountable to it; presidential systems (USA) have a separately elected, independent executive. Holding elections is not enough without real choice, freedom and checks.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which country does the textbook give as an example of direct democracy?
- Switzerland
- United States
- India
- Canada
Show answer
Answer: A. Switzerland is the textbook's example of direct democracy, where citizens take part directly in many decisions.
-
2. In a parliamentary democracy:
- The executive is independent of the legislature
- Members of the executive are also part of the legislature and accountable to it
- There is no legislature
- The President holds all executive power
Show answer
Answer: B. In a parliamentary system such as India's, the executive comes from the legislature and is accountable to it.
-
3. Which country is a parliamentary democracy with a constitutional monarchy and an unwritten constitution?
- Switzerland
- United States
- United Kingdom
- India
Show answer
Answer: C. The UK has a Monarch as Head of State, a Prime Minister as Head of Government and an unwritten constitution.
-
4. A council holds elections, but only approved candidates may contest and opposition is discouraged. This is best described as:
- A direct democracy
- A presidential democracy
- A parliamentary democracy
- Not a genuine democracy, as real choice and checks are missing
Show answer
Answer: D. Elections without free choice of candidates, a real opposition or checks on power do not meet democratic principles.
-
5. Assertion: Direct democracy is difficult to practise in very large countries. Reason: In a direct democracy citizens themselves take part in most decisions.
- Both Assertion and Reason are true, and the Reason correctly explains the Assertion
- Both Assertion and Reason are true, but the Reason does not explain the Assertion
- The Assertion is true, but the Reason is false
- The Assertion is false, but the Reason is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true; when every citizen must take part in most decisions, the size of a large country makes it hard, so the Reason explains the Assertion.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.