• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Who sees what: To, CC, BCC, Reply all and Forward puzzles

Solve e-mail recipient puzzles quickly: who can see which addresses, who gets a reply, how many people receive a message, and what happens to attachments.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Recipient questions are favourites in tests because they look simple and hide a trap. Four rules settle almost all of them. Learn the rules, then practise on the puzzles below until you can answer in a few seconds.

The four rules

  1. Everyone sees To and CC. All recipients, including those in BCC, can see the To and CC addresses.
  2. Nobody sees BCC except the sender. A BCC recipient is hidden from all other recipients.
  3. Reply goes to the sender; Reply all adds To and CC. BCC addresses are never included, because the replier cannot see them.
  4. Forward goes to new people and carries the attachments; a reply normally does not carry them.
Visibility at a glance
RecipientSees To and CC addresses?Seen by others?
Person in ToYesYes
Person in CCYesYes
Person in BCCYesNo

Trap: a BCC recipient clicks Reply all

If a person in BCC clicks Reply all, the reply goes to the sender and everyone in To and CC. Those people now find out that this person received the original mail secretly. Tip: if you were in BCC, reply only to the sender, or not at all.

Counting recipients

To count how many people receive a message, list every distinct address in To, CC and BCC together. An address written twice still gets only one copy. The sender does not receive a copy in the Inbox, but keeps one in Sent.

Worked example 1: what each person sees

Meera sends a mail. To: Naveen, Omkar. CC: Pooja. BCC: Qasim, Rekha. Working: Naveen, Omkar and Pooja each see Naveen and Omkar in To and Pooja in CC; none of them sees Qasim or Rekha. Qasim sees Naveen, Omkar and Pooja, but not Rekha - BCC recipients are hidden from each other too. Total recipients = 2 + 1 + 2 = 5.

Worked example 2: whose inbox does a reply reach?

Same mail, different actions
Who actsActionReply reaches
NaveenReplyMeera only
PoojaReply allMeera, Naveen, Omkar
Rekha (in BCC)Reply allMeera, Naveen, Omkar, Pooja - revealing Rekha
OmkarForward to SanjaySanjay only, with any attachments

Working for Pooja's Reply all: the original sender (Meera) plus every visible recipient except herself (Naveen and Omkar). Qasim and Rekha are not included because Pooja cannot see them.

Worked example 3: the subject line tells the story

A mail arrives with the subject Fwd: Re: Seminar timings. Working: read from the right. Someone sent Seminar timings; someone replied (Re:); then the conversation was forwarded (Fwd:) to you. So you are a new person brought into an existing exchange.

Everyone sees To and CC; nobody sees BCC. Reply = sender; Reply all = sender + To + CC; Forward = new people + attachments. Count distinct addresses once each.

Key takeaways: BCC hides recipients from everyone, including other BCC recipients. Reply all never reaches BCC addresses unless a BCC recipient presses it, which exposes them. Count recipients by adding distinct addresses across all three fields. Forward is the only one of the three that carries attachments on.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A mail is sent To: 3 people, CC: 2 people, BCC: 4 people, all different. How many people receive it?

    1. 9
    2. 5
    3. 4
    4. 7
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Every distinct address in To, CC and BCC receives a copy: 3 + 2 + 4 = 9.

  2. 2. Tanya is in BCC on a mail with two people in To. Which statement is true?

    1. The To recipients can see Tanya's address
    2. Tanya can see the two To addresses
    3. Tanya cannot see who else got the mail
    4. Tanya's reply all would go only to the sender
    Show answer

    Answer: B. All recipients, including those in BCC, see the To and CC lines. Others cannot see Tanya, and her Reply all would reach the To recipients too.

  3. 3. Uday sends a mail To: Vani, CC: Wasim, BCC: Yash. Wasim clicks Reply all. Who receives it?

    1. Only Uday
    2. Uday, Vani and Yash
    3. Vani and Yash
    4. Uday and Vani
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Reply all goes to the sender (Uday) and the visible recipients other than Wasim himself (Vani). Yash is hidden in BCC, so he is left out.

  4. 4. Which action normally sends the original attachments to the new recipient?

    1. Reply
    2. Reply all
    3. Forward
    4. Mark as read
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Forward carries the original message and its attachments to new recipients. Replies normally do not include attachments.

  5. 5. A subject line reads Re: Fwd: Library dues. What happened, in order?

    1. The mail was replied to, then forwarded
    2. The mail was forwarded, then someone replied to the forwarded copy
    3. It was sent in BCC
    4. It was saved as a draft twice
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Prefixes are added at the front, so read them from right to left: Library dues was first forwarded (Fwd:), and then someone replied to that forward (Re:).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery