- Advanced
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Two plans, two minds: what Mayer's and Le Corbusier's ideas tell us
Compare the fan-shaped plan of Albert Mayer with the grid of Le Corbusier, link the choices to history and geography, and answer statement-type questions on the planners.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced questions on the people of Chandigarh seldom ask only for a name. They ask what a person's idea was, how it differed from another's and why a decision was taken. To answer them you need to connect the people with the history and the geography you have studied in other courses. This lesson compares the two planning minds and shows how to turn the comparison into answers.
Why there were two plans
Partition in 1947 left East Punjab without Lahore, its capital. The government decided to build a new city at the foot of the Shivalik hills, on a gently sloping plain between two seasonal streams. The first planner, Albert Mayer, worked with Matthew Nowicki. After Nowicki died in an air crash in 1950, the Punjab government engaged Le Corbusier in 1951. The second plan therefore grew from the first, but it was not the same.
| Feature | Mayer and Nowicki | Le Corbusier |
|---|---|---|
| Overall shape | Fan-shaped | Grid of rectangular sectors |
| Roads | Curving, following the land | Straight, graded into seven kinds (7 Vs) |
| Neighbourhood | Large neighbourhood units | Sectors meant to be self-contained |
| Head of the city | A capitol complex | The Capitol Complex in Sector 1 |
| Main buildings designed by | Nowicki | Le Corbusier |
What stayed the same is as important as what changed. Both plans kept the idea of neighbourhood units, a government centre at the head of the city and a city centre. Le Corbusier kept the Capitol in the north-east near the hills, which suited the land because the site falls from north-east to south-west.
Same and different
-
Common to both plans
- Neighbourhood units
- A capitol at the head
- A city centre
- A site at the foot of the Shivaliks
-
Changed by Le Corbusier
- Fan shape to grid
- Curving roads to graded straight roads
- New chief designer
- Capitol buildings by one architect
Linking with geography and history
- Geography: the gentle slope from the hills lets rain drain towards the seasonal streams, and the Capitol Complex sits at the higher end against the Shivaliks.
- History: the need for the city came from Partition, and Nehru's support for a modern city explains why bold new designs were accepted.
- Administration: Indian officials, P. N. Thapar and P. L. Varma, turned the plans into streets and buildings.
A note on status
Chandigarh serves as the capital of Punjab and of Haryana. After Punjab was reorganised in 1966 and Haryana created, Chandigarh was made a Union Territory. Questions on its legal and administrative position should be read with the current legal position in mind, and you should check the current legal position before relying on an old fact.
Worked example 1: statement
Statements: (i) Albert Mayer's plan was fan-shaped. (ii) Le Corbusier's plan was drawn before Nowicki died. (iii) Le Corbusier kept the idea of neighbourhood units. Working: (i) is true. (ii) is false, because Le Corbusier was engaged in 1951 after Nowicki's death in 1950. (iii) is true. Answer: (i) and (iii) only.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
A: Le Corbusier's plan made Chandigarh a grid of sectors. R: Mayer's plan had been a grid of sectors. Working: A is true; R is false because Mayer's plan was fan-shaped. Answer: A is true, but R is false.
Worked example 3: a link
Question: 'Why does the Capitol Complex stand at the north-eastern end of the city?' Working: that is the higher end near the Shivalik hills, which form its backdrop, and the land slopes away to the south-west. Answer: because it is the higher end near the hills.
Compare in a table: shape, roads, neighbourhood, head, designer. Link to Partition, slope and Nehru.
Key takeaways: the two plans shared neighbourhood units and a capitol at the head, but Mayer's was fan-shaped and Le Corbusier's a grid. Choices were tied to Partition, the Shivalik slope and Nehru's vision. Check the current legal position when a question touches the status of the city.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which feature was common to Mayer's and Le Corbusier's plans?
- A fan shape
- Seven grades of roads
- Neighbourhood units
- The Open Hand
Show answer
Answer: C. Both plans kept neighbourhood units; the fan shape was Mayer's only, and the 7 Vs were Le Corbusier's.
-
2. Statement: 'Le Corbusier was engaged before Nowicki died.' It is:
- false
- true
- true only for housing
- true only for the Capitol
Show answer
Answer: A. Nowicki died in 1950; Le Corbusier was engaged in 1951.
-
3. A: Le Corbusier's real name was Jeanneret. R: Pierre Jeanneret was his cousin.
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: B. Both statements are true, but the cousin's name does not explain why Le Corbusier's birth name was Jeanneret. It was a family name that both men carried.
-
4. The roads of Mayer's plan were:
- graded into 7 Vs
- all straight
- absent
- curving
Show answer
Answer: D. His plan used curving roads that followed the land.
-
5. Which person's support helps explain the bold modern design?
- Pierre Jeanneret
- Jawaharlal Nehru
- P. L. Varma
- Matthew Nowicki
Show answer
Answer: B. Nehru supported a new city free of the old traditions.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.