• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Name traps: Jeanneret twice, Mayer versus Le Corbusier and other look-alikes

Avoid the commonest wrong answers by spotting four traps: the two Jeannerets, the first planner, the architect versus the engineer, and the planner versus the artist.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Exam setters do not need to invent difficult facts. They usually take the same few facts you know and set the wrong answers so that a careless reader falls into one. This lesson lists the traps that appear most often in questions on Chandigarh's personalities, with the habit that avoids each.

Trap 1: two Jeannerets

Le Corbusier's real name was Charles-Edouard Jeanneret. His cousin Pierre Jeanneret also worked in Chandigarh. A question may ask for 'Jeanneret' and give both Le Corbusier and Pierre as options. The habit: if the question gives a first name, use it. If it says 'whose real name was Jeanneret', the answer is Le Corbusier. If it says 'furniture' or 'chief architect on the spot', the answer is Pierre Jeanneret.

Trap 2: Le Corbusier as the first planner

Many candidates answer 'Le Corbusier' for any question about the plan. The first master plan was by Albert Mayer with Matthew Nowicki. Le Corbusier came later, in 1951, and changed the plan to a grid. The habit: look for the word 'first' or 'fan-shaped', which points to Mayer, and for 'grid of sectors' or 'Capitol Complex', which point to Le Corbusier.

Trap 3: architect versus engineer versus administrator

The Indian side of the project had an administrator, P. N. Thapar, and a chief engineer, P. L. Varma. Neither designed the buildings. A question asking who designed the High Court should not be answered with either name. The habit: ask what kind of work the person did. Design belongs to architects, construction to engineers, and direction of the project to the administrator.

Trap 4: planner versus artist

Nek Chand made the Rock Garden, which is an important place in the city, so some candidates think he was part of the planning team. He was a road inspector in the Public Works Department and was never one of the planners. The habit: link him with 'waste' and 'self-taught', not with 'plan'.

Trap table
TrapWrong answer often chosenRight answer
Real name JeanneretPierre JeanneretLe Corbusier (Charles-Edouard Jeanneret)
First master planLe CorbusierAlbert Mayer
Designed the Capitol ComplexP. L. VarmaLe Corbusier
Built the Rock GardenPierre JeanneretNek Chand
Chief engineerP. N. ThaparP. L. Varma

Mayer's plan and Le Corbusier's plan

  • Albert Mayer (with Nowicki)
    • Came first
    • Fan-shaped
    • Curving roads and large neighbourhood units
  • Le Corbusier
    • Came in 1951
    • Grid of sectors
    • Straight roads in seven grades
Two plans, two shapes

Trap 5: foreign or Indian?

Many questions ask which of a list was an Indian official. Mayer was American, Nowicki Polish, Le Corbusier Swiss-born and later French, Jeanneret Swiss, and Fry and Drew British. The Indian names in the story are Thapar, Varma and Nek Chand. The habit: sort every list by country first.

Worked example 1: the real name

Question: 'Whose real name was Charles-Edouard Jeanneret?' Working: Le Corbusier took a professional name. The cousin Pierre Jeanneret kept his own name. Answer: Le Corbusier.

Worked example 2: designed by

Question: 'The High Court of Chandigarh was designed by?' Working: the options are Albert Mayer, P. L. Varma, Le Corbusier and Nek Chand. Mayer did the first plan, Varma was an engineer, Nek Chand a road inspector. The Capitol buildings were by the chief architect. Answer: Le Corbusier.

Worked example 3: the Indian name

Question: 'Which of the following was an Indian who headed the capital project?' Working: Maxwell Fry and Matthew Nowicki were foreign architects. The Indian administrator was P. N. Thapar. Answer: P. N. Thapar.

Read the verb: planned, designed, built, administered. Then pick the person.

Key takeaways: two Jeannerets, one real name; Mayer planned first, Le Corbusier changed the plan; Thapar administered and Varma engineered; Nek Chand was an artist and not a planner. Sort lists by country and by verb.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 'Whose real name was Jeanneret?' is best answered:

    1. Pierre Jeanneret
    2. Maxwell Fry
    3. Albert Mayer
    4. Le Corbusier
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Le Corbusier was born Charles-Edouard Jeanneret.

  2. 2. A fan-shaped first plan points to:

    1. Albert Mayer
    2. Le Corbusier
    3. Jane Drew
    4. P. L. Varma
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Fan-shaped refers to Mayer's plan.

  3. 3. A grid of sectors points to:

    1. Albert Mayer
    2. Nek Chand
    3. Le Corbusier
    4. Matthew Nowicki
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Le Corbusier redrew the city as a grid of sectors.

  4. 4. Which of these was never an architect of the team?

    1. Pierre Jeanneret
    2. Maxwell Fry
    3. Jane Drew
    4. P. L. Varma
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Varma was the chief engineer.

  5. 5. Which pair contains only Indian names from the story?

    1. Mayer and Nek Chand
    2. P. N. Thapar and Nek Chand
    3. Fry and Thapar
    4. Drew and Varma
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Thapar and Nek Chand were Indian; Mayer, Fry and Drew were not.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery