- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Why the Union governs: Parliament's power and the constitutional layers
Explain the constitutional reasons for direct Union control of Chandigarh, and apply Articles 239, 246(4), 231 and 241 to mixed questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced questions do not ask only what the Administrator is called. They ask why the arrangement exists and what follows from it. This lesson goes one level down, to the constitutional reasoning, so that you can answer a statement or an assertion-reason question on Chandigarh with confidence.
Two sources of Union power
The Constitution divides law-making between the Union and the states through lists. In the case of a state, Parliament may legislate only on the Union and Concurrent lists, and the state legislature on the State and Concurrent lists. A Union Territory is not part of any state. Article 246(4) therefore gives Parliament power to make laws on any matter for any part of India not included in a state, even if that matter is in the State List. This is the constitutional reason why Parliament can legislate for Chandigarh on matters that, in a state, belong to the state legislature.
The second source is Article 239, which provides that a Union Territory is administered by the President through an Administrator, unless Parliament provides otherwise. The first source is about laws; the second is about administration. A good answer keeps them apart.
| Question | Source | Result for Chandigarh |
|---|---|---|
| Who can make laws on a State List matter? | Article 246(4) | Parliament, since the territory is not part of a state |
| Who administers the territory? | Article 239 | The President, through an Administrator |
| How can a common High Court be set up? | Article 231 | By Parliament, for states (and a Union Territory with them) |
| How can a court be made a High Court for a territory? | Article 241 | Parliament may constitute one or declare a court to be one |
| How does a territory choose Lok Sabha members? | Parliament's law on representation | One member from Chandigarh |
Constitutional layers over Chandigarh
- Constitution Part VIII on Union Territories
- Parliament Makes laws under Article 246(4)
- President Administers under Article 239
- Administrator Acts for the President in the territory
The common High Court in detail
Article 231 lets Parliament, by law, establish a common High Court for two or more states, or for two or more states and a Union Territory. Article 241 allows Parliament to constitute a High Court for a Union Territory or to declare a court there to be a High Court for all or any of the purposes of the Constitution. The Punjab and Haryana High Court, sitting in Chandigarh, is an example of a common court that serves two states and a Union Territory.
Limits to remember
- Parliament may change the arrangement by law. Examples include granting a territory an assembly, as was done for Delhi and Puducherry. Treat every statement on the legal position as 'as at the date of the source' and check the current position.
- The Administrator acts for the President. The Administrator is not a Governor and does not hold the position of a state's constitutional head.
- Union control does not mean the people have no vote. They elect a Lok Sabha member and the Municipal Corporation.
Worked example 1: which Article
Question: 'On what Article can Parliament make laws on State List subjects for Chandigarh?' Working: the State List is closed to Parliament only for states. A Union Territory is outside any state, so Article 246(4) applies. Answer: Article 246(4).
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Assertion: 'Parliament can legislate on State List subjects for Chandigarh.' Reason: 'Chandigarh is not part of any state.' Working: both are true, and the reason is the exact ground for the assertion. Answer: both true, reason explains assertion.
Worked example 3: separate the sources
Question: 'Which Article lets the President administer a Union Territory through an Administrator?' Working: the administration point is Article 239. Article 246(4) is about laws. Answer: Article 239.
Laws: Article 246(4). Administration: Article 239. Common High Court: Article 231. Court for a territory: Article 241.
Key takeaways: the Union's control of Chandigarh rests on its being outside any state. Parliament makes the laws under Article 246(4); the President administers under Article 239. Common courts come from Articles 231 and 241. Where a law may have changed, check the current position.
Check your understanding
-
1. Parliament can legislate for Chandigarh on State List matters under
- Article 239
- Article 246(4)
- Article 164
- Article 153
Show answer
Answer: B. Union Territories lie outside any state, so Article 246(4) applies.
-
2. The administration of a Union Territory through an Administrator is provided by
- Article 246(4)
- Article 231
- Article 241
- Article 239
Show answer
Answer: D. Administration is Article 239.
-
3. A common High Court for two or more states is provided under
- Article 231
- Article 239
- Article 241
- Article 243Q
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 231 allows it.
-
4. Which statement is correct?
- A Union Territory is part of the nearest state
- The Administrator is a Governor
- Parliament may by law change the arrangement of a Union Territory
- Chandigarh elects a Chief Minister
Show answer
Answer: C. Parliament has the power to change the arrangement.
-
5. Assertion: Parliament can make laws on State List matters for Chandigarh. Reason: Chandigarh is not part of any state.
- The assertion is false but the reason is true
- Both the assertion and the reason are true, and the reason correctly explains the assertion
- Both are true, but the reason does not explain the assertion
- The assertion is true but the reason is false
Show answer
Answer: B. Both are true and the reason is the ground (Article 246(4)).
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.