- Advanced
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
A lake as a system: inputs, storage, outputs and the sediment budget
Treat Sukhna Lake and its catchment as one system and reason about water and silt as flows in and out.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Earlier courses gave you the facts of Sukhna Lake. This lesson asks you to think like a hydrologist: a lake is not a bowl of water but a system with inflows, storage and outflows, and silt is one more thing flowing in. Once you see the system, hard questions about causes and cures become straightforward.
The water budget
The change in the water stored in a lake over a period equals what comes in minus what goes out. For Sukhna Lake the main inflow is the Sukhna Choe, carrying monsoon runoff from its Shivalik catchment, plus rain falling on the lake itself. The main outflows are evaporation, seepage into the ground and water let out over the dam when the lake is full. In symbols: change in storage = inflow - outflow. A lake rises when inflow is greater and falls when outflow is greater.
Inputs to storage to outputs
- Rain on catchment Falls on the Shivalik slopes
- Runoff in the choe Seasonal, strongest after heavy rain
- Lake storage Water held behind the dam
- Outflow Evaporation, seepage, release over the dam
The sediment budget
Silt has its own budget: silt in minus silt out equals silt stored. A dam lake traps most of the silt that enters, because the water slows down. So the silt stored is close to the silt supplied, and the only ways to reduce it are to supply less (hold soil in the catchment) or to take some out (dredging). This is why catchment protection is described as the cause-level cure and dredging as the symptom-level cure.
| Budget | In | Out | Store grows when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Water | Choe inflow, rain on lake | Evaporation, seepage, release | In is greater than out |
| Silt | Eroded soil from the catchment | Little, since the dam traps it | Almost always, unless supply is cut or silt is removed |
Nested catchments
Drainage areas nest inside one another. The catchment of the Sukhna Choe lies inside the drainage of the seasonal streams of the area, which in turn lie in the Ghaggar basin. A change at the top of a small catchment is felt downstream, but the reverse is not true: what happens in the Ghaggar basin far away does not alter the silt reaching the lake. So the right place to act depends on the scale of the problem.
Nested drainage areas
-
Ghaggar basin
- Seasonal river of the plains
- Receives the streams of the area
-
Seasonal streams of the area
- Sukhna Choe
- Patiali Rao
- N-Choe
-
Lake catchment
- Shivalik slopes above the dam
- Source of both water and silt
Worked examples
Example 1. Question: 'In a year the choe brings in 100 units of water and 18 units leave by evaporation, seepage and release (illustration). What is the change in storage?' Working: 100 - 18 = 82. Answer: an increase of 82 units.
Example 2. Question: 'If the lake traps nearly all silt entering, why does dredging alone fail to keep the lake deep for long?' Working: dredging removes what has arrived but does nothing to the supply from the catchment, so the bed fills again. Answer: it treats the symptom; the supply continues unless erosion is reduced.
Example 3. Question: 'Would soil conservation in the Ghaggar basin far downstream reduce silt entering Sukhna Lake?' Working: silt reaching the lake comes only from its own catchment above the dam. Answer: no; only conservation in the lake's catchment helps.
Storage change = in - out. A dam lake traps silt, so cut the supply (catchment) before dredging. Act at the right scale.
Key takeaways: A lake is a system with a water budget and a silt budget. Because the dam traps silt, supply from the catchment decides how fast the lake fills. Catchments nest inside basins, and only upstream action affects what arrives at the dam.
Check your understanding
-
1. Change in storage of a lake equals
- outflow divided by inflow
- inflow plus outflow
- inflow minus outflow
- rainfall only
Show answer
Answer: C. Storage rises when more comes in than goes out.
-
2. A dam lake traps most silt because
- the dam makes silt heavier
- silt never enters the lake
- silt dissolves in the dam
- the water slows down in the lake
Show answer
Answer: D. Slow water drops its load.
-
3. To reduce silt supply to Sukhna Lake, action is most effective in
- the lake's own catchment
- the far end of the Ghaggar basin
- the sea
- the city's centre only
Show answer
Answer: A. Silt reaching the dam comes from the catchment above it.
-
4. Dredging is best described as a
- cause-level cure
- symptom-level cure
- way of increasing erosion
- type of check dam
Show answer
Answer: B. It removes silt that has arrived but does not stop supply.
-
5. If inflow is 70 units and outflow is 20 units, storage changes by
- +90 units
- -50 units
- +50 units
- +14 units
Show answer
Answer: C. 70 - 20 = 50 added.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.