- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Atomic models: Dalton to Bohr
Trace how models of the atom developed from Dalton to Bohr and what experiment led to each change.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The picture of the atom was refined over a century as new experiments revealed what earlier models could not explain. Exams often ask which scientist proposed which model, and what each model got wrong.
Dalton's model
John Dalton (early 1800s) proposed that matter is made of indivisible atoms. Atoms of one element are identical, and compounds form when atoms combine in fixed ratios. After the electron was discovered, atoms were clearly divisible, so the idea of an indivisible atom had to be dropped.
Thomson's model
J. J. Thomson proposed the 'plum pudding' or watermelon model: a positively charged sphere with negative electrons embedded in it like plums or seeds. The atom as a whole is neutral. This model could not explain Rutherford's experiment.
Rutherford's model
In the gold foil experiment, alpha particles were fired at a very thin gold foil. Most passed straight through, a few were deflected through small angles and very few (about 1 in 12000) bounced straight back. Rutherford concluded that an atom is mostly empty space with a tiny, dense, positively charged nucleus at the centre, and electrons revolve around it. Limitation: an electron revolving in a circle should lose energy and spiral into the nucleus, so the atom should be unstable, yet atoms are stable.
Bohr's model
Niels Bohr (1913) fixed this problem with these postulates: electrons revolve only in certain fixed circular paths called orbits or energy levels (shells) K, L, M, N, with no energy radiated while in them; an electron absorbs or releases energy only when jumping from one level to another.
| Scientist | Model idea | Key evidence or limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Dalton | Indivisible atom | Failed once electrons were found |
| Thomson | Electrons in positive sphere | Failed to explain scattering |
| Rutherford | Central nucleus, orbiting electrons | Could not explain stability |
| Bohr | Electrons in fixed energy levels | Explained stability of atom |
Worked examples
Example 1. Why did most alpha particles pass through the foil? The atom is mostly empty space.
Example 2. Why were a few alpha particles deflected strongly? They came close to the positively charged nucleus and were repelled, since both are positive.
Example 3. Why did a very small number of particles rebound? They hit the dense nucleus head on, which means the nucleus is very small and very dense.
Rutherford: atom has a small, dense, positive nucleus and is mostly empty. Bohr: electrons stay in fixed energy levels without radiating energy.
Key takeaways
- Dalton, Thomson, Rutherford and Bohr each improved the model.
- The gold foil experiment showed the nucleus.
- Bohr introduced fixed energy levels.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which scientist proposed the 'plum pudding' model of the atom?
- Ernest Rutherford
- Niels Bohr
- J. J. Thomson
- John Dalton
Show answer
Answer: C. Thomson pictured a positive sphere with electrons embedded in it like plums in a pudding.
-
2. In Rutherford's gold foil experiment, most alpha particles passed straight through. What did this show?
- The nucleus is negatively charged
- Electrons are heavier than alpha particles
- The positive charge is spread evenly through the atom
- Most of the atom is empty space
Show answer
Answer: D. If most particles pass through undeflected, there is nothing in their way: the atom is mostly empty space.
-
3. What was the main limitation of Rutherford's model?
- It could not explain the stability of the atom
- It had no nucleus
- It said atoms are indivisible
- It placed electrons inside the nucleus
Show answer
Answer: A. An electron revolving in a circle should lose energy and spiral into the nucleus, so the atom should be unstable, yet atoms are stable.
-
4. According to Bohr's model, when does an electron give out energy?
- Continuously while it revolves in its orbit
- When it jumps from a higher energy level to a lower one
- When it jumps from a lower energy level to a higher one
- Only when it is removed from the atom
Show answer
Answer: B. In a fixed orbit the electron radiates no energy. It releases energy only on falling to a lower level and absorbs energy to jump to a higher one.
-
5. Which idea of Dalton's had to be dropped after the discovery of subatomic particles?
- That matter is made of atoms
- That compounds form when atoms combine
- That atoms are indivisible
- That atoms combine in fixed ratios
Show answer
Answer: C. Electrons, protons and neutrons showed that atoms can be divided, so the idea of an indivisible atom was dropped.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.