- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Atomic models: Rutherford, Bohr and their limits
Recall what the alpha-particle scattering experiment showed, state Bohr's postulates, and use shell rules in exam questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Exam questions on atomic models usually test observations and conclusions, not heavy calculation. If you can link each observation to its conclusion, and each model to its weakness, you can answer almost any question.
Rutherford's alpha-scattering experiment
Alpha particles were fired at a very thin gold foil. The observations and conclusions are paired below.
| Observation | Conclusion |
|---|---|
| Most alpha particles passed straight through | Most of the atom is empty space |
| A few were deflected by small angles | A positive charge exists in a small region |
| Very few (about 1 in 20,000) bounced back | The positive charge and most of the mass are concentrated in a tiny, dense nucleus |
Rutherford's model: a small positive nucleus at the centre, with electrons revolving around it. Limitation: an electron moving in a circle should continuously radiate energy and spiral into the nucleus, so the atom should collapse. The model also could not explain line spectra.
Bohr's postulates
- Electrons revolve only in certain fixed circular orbits (shells) without emitting energy. These are the stationary states.
- Each orbit has a definite energy and is numbered n = 1, 2, 3... outward from the nucleus.
- Energy is absorbed when an electron jumps to a higher orbit and emitted when it falls to a lower one. The energy of the photon equals the difference between the two levels.
- Angular momentum of an electron in an orbit is a whole-number multiple of h / 2 pi.
For hydrogen the energy of the nth level is E(n) = -13.6 / n squared electron volts. So E(1) = -13.6 eV, E(2) = -3.4 eV and E(3) is about -1.51 eV. A negative value means the electron is bound; levels get closer together as n increases.
Worked examples
Example 1. What is the maximum number of electrons in the second shell? Working: capacity of shell n is 2 n squared. For n = 2 it is 2 x 4 = 8.
Example 2. A hydrogen electron falls from n = 2 to n = 1. How much energy is emitted? Working: change = E(2) - E(1) = -3.4 - (-13.6) = 10.2 eV.
Example 3. Give the electron distribution of chlorine (Z = 17) in shells. Working: 2 in K, 8 in L, then the remaining 7 in M: 2, 8, 7.
Maximum electrons in shell n = 2n squared. Energy emitted or absorbed = difference between the two energy levels.
Limits of the Bohr model
- It works well only for hydrogen and similar one-electron species.
- It cannot explain the splitting of spectral lines in a magnetic field or electric field.
- It conflicts with the uncertainty principle, because it fixes both position and speed of the electron.
Key takeaways: Learn observation-conclusion pairs, Bohr's fixed orbits, and the 2n squared rule. Remember Bohr's model is limited to one-electron systems.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which observation of the gold foil experiment showed that the positive charge and most of the mass sit in a tiny, dense nucleus?
- Most alpha particles passed straight through
- A very few alpha particles bounced back
- The foil stayed intact
- Alpha particles travelled in straight lines before reaching the foil
Show answer
Answer: B. Only a tiny, dense, positive nucleus hit head on can turn an alpha particle back. Particles passing straight through show empty space instead.
-
2. In hydrogen E(n) = −13.6/n² eV. How much energy is emitted when an electron falls from n = 3 to n = 2?
- 10.2 eV
- 12.09 eV
- About 1.89 eV
- 3.4 eV
Show answer
Answer: C. E(3) = −13.6/9 ≈ −1.51 eV and E(2) = −3.4 eV. Energy emitted = −1.51 − (−3.4) ≈ 1.89 eV.
-
3. What is the energy of the electron in the n = 4 level of hydrogen?
- −3.4 eV
- −13.6 eV
- −54.4 eV
- −0.85 eV
Show answer
Answer: D. E(4) = −13.6/4² = −13.6/16 = −0.85 eV.
-
4. Which of these is a limitation of the Bohr model?
- It works well only for one-electron species such as hydrogen
- It cannot explain why the hydrogen atom is stable
- It cannot explain the line spectrum of hydrogen
- It places the positive charge in a uniform sphere
Show answer
Answer: A. Bohr explained hydrogen's stability and line spectrum, but the model fails for atoms with more than one electron (and for line splitting in fields).
-
5. According to Bohr, the angular momentum of an electron in an orbit is:
- Any value, varying continuously
- A whole-number multiple of h/2π
- Inversely proportional to the orbit number
- Always zero
Show answer
Answer: B. Bohr's postulate: angular momentum = n × h/2π, where n = 1, 2, 3 ...
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.